View Full Version : 210 vs 410 Build Quality
dpackster1980
16-07-2012, 09:13 PM
I've just finished building a 210 this week and recently sold a X6 to subsidize the purchase and to be honest.I wish I kept the X6!
I've built a 410 previously. During the 210 build I noticed the following issues that leave me disappointed.
1) Shock seal caps - On the 210 they are plastic, they leak and they strip. On the 410 they are alloy even on the R version and dont leak!
2) Upper shock mounts - On the 210 they are plastic which allows flex. On the 410 they are steel which doesn't.
3) Rear wishbone slop - On the 210 there is loads, I had to use an Associated hub spacer to get rid of it. On the 410 everything is as tight as a button.
4) Plastic hexes - The squash and pinch the bearings, so I bought alloy ones straight away.
5) Instruction Manual - On the 210 they insist in putting in the one with errors in it and haven't bothered to revise it. On the 410 its fine.
It seems since the takeover they are cutting costs at the expense of performance. I my eyes that is worrying especially for future releases. The 210 isn't a patch on the 410R which I have in terms of quality and build satisfaction!
Performance is good but due to the build its left a sour taste in my mouth. I wish I got a Cougar SV because to get it to a reasonable level I'd end up spending the same money and its all in one box.
Robocop
16-07-2012, 09:43 PM
Like you i had a 210 got rid of my 22 which i was really happy with.And i thought also the 210 was poor quality chassis sides did not line up with chassis parts missing,diff problems, droop screws that was inacessable in mid motor
Andrew Twigger
16-07-2012, 10:00 PM
... droop screws that was inacessable in mid motor
The droop screws have heads both top and bottom and so can be accessed from either side...invalid argument IMO.
t8rtot
17-07-2012, 03:52 AM
Its a catch 22, do you want to pay 350 for a buggy or still have a great preforming car that needs a little extra shimming (AE and Losi) have figured this out
jkclifford
17-07-2012, 04:25 AM
what a load of bollox.
My210 was out the first batch, and still all stock, original towers nothing has been changed except springs. Ally or plastic caps won't make a differnce, its the way the are built, and they don't strip themselves out.
the plasric hexes have a flange which touches the inner race, how tight are you doing the wheels up to warp it so much it touches the outer race?
Flex on the upper shock mount, if you can notice that then you must be the best driver on here.
Not being funny, but the 210 is one of the cheapest race spec kits out there, so you will have to excuse them for not including carbon and alloy everywhere. Considering you get 2 gearbox cases and everything to build it up in mid-rear, 3-4 gear configurations plus inserts for geometry!!
If you compare the cost to even a Cougar SV/SV2 it is silly cheap let alone a C4.1
dpackster1980
17-07-2012, 06:15 AM
what a load of bollox.
My210 was out the first batch, and still all stock, original towers nothing has been changed except springs. Ally or plastic caps won't make a differnce, its the way the are built, and they don't strip themselves out.
the plasric hexes have a flange which touches the inner race, how tight are you doing the wheels up to warp it so much it touches the outer race?
Flex on the upper shock mount, if you can notice that then you must be the best driver on here.
The flange eventually squashes over time causing the hex to rub on the hub!
As for the plastic shock stand off they are useless, eventually the long screw will bent over time just like all manufacturers that use this method. The Steel ones do not bend it wouldn't cost them much to shove these in the kit as well.
Plastic caps do leak more than the alloy ones, fact! You build the shocks and notice the caps are slightly wet you tighten them a like more and find that they strip. It would have added probably £4 to a kit to put the alloy ones in!
3/4mm worth of wishbone slop acceptable? Not in my eyes especially for the pedigree this buggy is claimed to be, it might be for others.
Did I say I was a good driver, no. I've been racing and building cars for 17 years plus currently F2 and race at the Nationals so over the years you know what's a good kit and what's a bad one!
I was questioning the quality between the 210 and 410 if you read my post. IMO they've dropped the ball on the 210 and clearly have tried to squeeze every penny out of it. I'd pay slightly more for the kit if it had the extras and would've enjoyed the build more.
Performance is fine but the puild is very poor at best.
dpackster1980
17-07-2012, 06:21 AM
what a load of bollox.
My210 was out the first batch, and still all stock, original towers nothing has been changed except springs. Ally or plastic caps won't make a differnce, its the way the are built, and they don't strip themselves out.
the plasric hexes have a flange which touches the inner race, how tight are you doing the wheels up to warp it so much it touches the outer race?
Flex on the upper shock mount, if you can notice that then you must be the best driver on here.
I'd rather have quality not quantity! The 3 things I mentioned would've cost Durango less then £10 to put in per kit and then it would've been excellent value for money. Instead the money just lines the new owners pockets which takes away form what Durango was originally.
chrispattinson
17-07-2012, 06:35 AM
The OP has made a great point. On Sunday, I had a look at his 210, and the spec of the kit is much lower than on the 410.
I think the expectation may be too much, from a company that set the bar high with the original 410 cars, and is now producing cheaper lower spec kits.
Regarding the plastic hexes, you should have confidence in tightening a wheel up all the way without it squashing, unless a torque wrench is supplied?
Unfortunately, £10 per kit may not seem a lot to you, but it will make a lot of difference to Durango on the volume of kits produced.
I'd also like to add that David knows how to build a car, from his time spent racing, and the time he spends preparing his cars (just ask his wife).
Anyway, let's not get tied up too much in the specifics, and congratulate David on posting a sensible post on Oople for a change :woot:
mattr
17-07-2012, 07:18 AM
I'd have to agree generally, i have a DEX410R and a 2010Spec, and even the 410R has a better fit and finish than the DEX210 (which looking at it, should *really* be an R as well, it has more in common than the 410R than the non-R version, lots more plastic than i'd expect.)
Specifically.
1) They don't leak, the seals, seal once you get to finger tight, difference between plastic and aluminium is negligible. In fact, as far as i can tell, the cap bottoms out. Tightening it further won't help, something else is wrong if it still leaks noticeably. (I have broken one crashing tho, will replace eventually.)
2) Upper shock mounts - yeah, i'll give you that, i swapped to steel mounts before i'd even finished building it, the plastic ones are a pain to adjust too.
3) Rear wishbone slop - i have slop on all three cars, so i used an extra shim where needed, 0,25mm IIRC. Going to a 0,5mm made them bind. So not a huge issue, there was FAR more slop on my B4.1.
4) Plastic hexes - Should last several weeks, if not months, but yes, they will eventually
5) Instruction Manual - Nah, there are errors in both the 410R and the 2010 manuals i have.
Still very happy with it, makes my B4.1 look like Fred Flintstones RC car.
Si Coe
17-07-2012, 08:48 AM
I do think its more of an issue of 'Compared to the 410' than absolute quality.
A few things to note:
1) The shock standoffs - yes they are plastic, yes the steel is better, but look at most other models and you'll see they use a screw and a plastic standoff. Its a lot cheaper and simpler than the custom made steel part. If the steel part was never offered, you'd have never known!
2) Ditto the plastic shock bottoms. They don't leak (well none I've seen do at least) unless they are faulty (and you can get faulty alloy ones too) and again are quite normal on many other brands. You've been spoiled by the previous Durango ones.
3) Plastic hexes - these are no worse than you get with pin fit wheels in general. Actually I converted my 210 to pin fit anyway and I'd rather that than alloy hexes.
What Durango have been doing is gradually paring down the bling compared to the original 410, with the view that if performance doesn't suffer but the price is reduced this is a good thing. However it seems that has alienated some of the target market.
I notice that there is a new non-R version of the 410 Short course, precisely as people demanded a full option version. Ditto I reckon the current 210 should be designated an R and a full fat version sold. But that might hurt sales as people will assume you have to buy the pricey version
cmgreen
17-07-2012, 11:21 AM
On a more positive note, the cougar SV2 is mint, build quality is quality!:thumbsup:
mark christopher
17-07-2012, 11:31 AM
On a more positive note, the cougar SV2 is mint, build quality is quality!:thumbsup:
Plus 1
rcjunky
17-07-2012, 12:03 PM
Why is everyne hating on Great Planes buying Durango and saying that is why the quality is lower? The DEX210 was released and sold before the company was sold... So far I like my car and have had no issues.
av4625
17-07-2012, 12:39 PM
If the steel part was never offered, you'd have never known!
Thats not the point people bought these cars because they wer better had nicer parts had more bling watever we bought them because of the custom parts etc
mattr
17-07-2012, 12:51 PM
Why is everyne hating on Great Planes buying Durango and saying that is why the quality is lower? The DEX210 was released and sold before the company was sold... So far I like my car and have had no issues.Not from me. Its that the 210 is more of a 210R when compared to the differences between 410/410R.
Maybe you'd be happy buying a BMW M-sport car and finding its got steel rims, cloth interior and grey plastic bumpers.
jkclifford
17-07-2012, 12:54 PM
So it would be better if the complete car was ally and carbon. For £350
Rear hubs with 0' toe c hubs with no set castor, front Hubs with no trailing adjustment rear wishbone holders with no anti squat, all made out if ally.
So out the box it looks the nuts but performace is down ands needs tweaking, Then get charged ££ for rear hubs with some toe in, ££ for wishbone hangers with anti squat, £££ more or less castor.
And of course after having the originaly ally parts you couldn't degrade youself and put plastic parts on, have to be ally ones.
the insert system is just amazing, how many times have parts been bought tried then slung in the box cos they wre no better or worse?!
Race performace 1st looks 2nd.
AfroP
17-07-2012, 12:57 PM
I'd have to agree with the OP and others on here
For a supposed high end kit there are plenty of issues with it.
The manual is the worst part, as somebody who isn't as experienced as most on here I found the manual very confusing as it lists part numbers for sections of the build that are incorrect, I managed to get through the build alright without issue and then I printed off the online manual. Neither of which make any mention at all of attaching the rear bumper in MM config.
A better explanation in the manual of how to build the diff would have been a massive benefit, had I not watched the video online, I would never have realised that the circlip has a flat and a rounded side or that the thrust race has 2 different thickness of washer.
The lack of alloy hexes, to me is simply a money maker on Durango's behalf. The alloy hexes were a fairly recent addition to the product line so they left them out of the kit knowing it would become an essential upgrade for the kit.
Plastic shock caps, shock ends and limiters on big bore shocks is major let down, as are the plastic shock stand off's. They have the part in the product line so why not include it ?
The only other kit I can compare it to, is the TLR 22( as its the only other one I have built recently) The 22 included everything I needed(apart from hex keys/drivers) it had threadlock, a cross wrench, grease and even included shock oil and 2 sets of wheels.
I never had to look online for additional info to build the 22 and there was no issues with any of the manual directing me to incorrect parts frames.
The 22 is also around £10 cheaper than the 210
dont get me wrong I still love my 210 now that its going
but this isn't a love/hate thread. its a build quality thread and I think the 210 is unfortunately not up to standard for the price point.
Alan - South West RC
17-07-2012, 01:29 PM
As with everything in this sport it's down to personal preference. I've always had Schumacher cars but as everyone in the area was moving to the 210 I finally decided to try one for myself. I too was disappointed with the quality of the kit and the poor instruction manual and after only a couple of meetings I went back to Schumacher.
Having said that though I know people that have bought 210's and are really enjoying racing them and haven’t complained once about the quality. So as I said, everyone is different and that’s great for the sport as it adds variety.
-AP-
lordnikon
17-07-2012, 02:15 PM
Some valid commented so far, my point of view having 'moved up' from the Ansmann stuff is its priced and specced about right. I looked at the 22, 210 and SV2 as options and plumped for the 210.
Manual is an obvious and quick fix which SHOULD be sorted. However even with the mistakes in it you dont have to be a genius to work out the mistakes
Plastics, seemed a decent quality. I did have problems with a shock cap was not threaded properly, quick email to MBmodels and for them to talk to TD and it was on my doormat the next day.
The car would work out of the box however the metal standoffs and alloy hexes are like £10-£15 .... its not the end of the world, and gives you the option to upgrade if you want. If they had been included but the kit was £210 would i have bought it ?? Its hard to say tbh
As for price point, i bought it as it was a middle range buggy. High end Kyosho vegas and the DB1 are on another level build wise, but they are twice the price.
tomvanelsen
17-07-2012, 03:41 PM
The 210 was my first building kit and as a "unexperienced boy", it isnt the build quality that i think is bad(i find that it is a pretty easy to build kit), but its some of the parts that could have been better like the layshaft spacer,shock mounts(cuz they're a pain in the butt) and the rear shocktower.
Besides that i think its wrong that you guys are comparing durango to losi, ae or schumacher, but dont understand me wrong, they're all great companies, that all have their own little "faults", but what you guys are doing is comparing apples with bananas.
This is my point of view on the subject, if ive offended someone with this, im sorry i didnt mean to, so dont get mad at me.
-Tom-
dpackster1980
18-07-2012, 07:34 PM
So it would be better if the complete car was ally and carbon. For £350
Rear hubs with 0' toe c hubs with no set castor, front Hubs with no trailing adjustment rear wishbone holders with no anti squat, all made out if ally.
So out the box it looks the nuts but performace is down ands needs tweaking, Then get charged ££ for rear hubs with some toe in, ££ for wishbone hangers with anti squat, £££ more or less castor.
And of course after having the originaly ally parts you couldn't degrade youself and put plastic parts on, have to be ally ones.
the insert system is just amazing, how many times have parts been bought tried then slung in the box cos they wre no better or worse?!
Race performace 1st looks 2nd.
Did I mention alloy parts? Nope
Do I want all singing all dancing shock towers? Nope
A good example is the 410v3, alloy hangers all round, gold shock shafts, alloy shock oring caps and that has more machined parts plus 4wd. Yes its 4wd but spec wise it's amazing for the money (£90 more than a 210) well done Durango. :thumbsup:
Then look at the 210 spec, what do you actually get for your money very little apart from an alloy rear suspension hanger. Very poor indeed. :cry:
The performance is fine, but put it next to your box stock 410v3 and wonder could they have tried harder?????
The first 3 things I mentioned in the original post would probably be fine and would cost durango very little indeed as they have been knocking them out since day one. Fair enough alloy hexes I would class as a luxury but the rest is what everyone would generally expect and be happy with.
I'm not bashing Great Planes but seriously I know they've been reducing the cost and specs of the kits to make them more appealling but they didn't need to so drastically on the 210 compared to other models this is my gripe.
Jamesy
18-07-2012, 08:47 PM
Then look at the 210 spec, what do you actually get for your money?
A 2wd buggy that can compete at the highest levels in both rear and mid motor configurations that is competative 'out of the box' for a price just a little more than some mid motor conversion kits.
AfroP
18-07-2012, 09:24 PM
A 2wd buggy that can compete at the highest levels in both rear and mid motor configurations that is competative 'out of the box' for a price just a little more than some mid motor conversion kits.
You could argue that you get that from the 22 as well at less of the price.but with more in the kit. Alloy shock caps. Metal shock standoffs and titanium turnbuckles
AfroP
18-07-2012, 09:44 PM
Double post. Sorry
TonyM
18-07-2012, 10:14 PM
While waiting for the 210 to be released I bought a 22 and was so disappointed with many aspects of that kit, in particular the almost impossible task of fitting in the electronics into such a ridiculously confined space – shorty lipo’s!!!.
I found the 210 build a breeze. Sure, the manual was incorrect, but I just went by the pictures, found the right parts and hey-presto job done.
At a few pounds/dollars/Euros over many of the conversion kits, which also require a donor car, I think the 210 is fantastic value. It works out of the box. OK, there are a few week points e.g. rear shock tower and steering link in particular, which you soon fix with hop-ups. However, I’d bet there are fewer hop-ups which are really needed for this buggy than most others on the market.
Having said all of that, I’d agree that for an extra £10-£20 it would have been nice to have the shock alu bottoms and 410 shock stand-offs as standard. I’d also pay an extra £6-8 to have a TD equivalent for the brilliant Tresrey rear hexes’.
Chris Doughty
19-07-2012, 08:38 AM
Hello All,
I'm interested to work out more what the deal is here.
Is the perceived problem with 'spec' or with 'quality'?
There also seems to be a big spread between people who really liked the kit, and people that really didn't like the kit, I'm keen to work out how there can be such a broad spread of opinion.
Other than mistakes in the manual which have been corrected for the online version and all future prints, what else is wrong with the manual? how would you have liked it to be better?
The way the current TD manuals work is that they are an assembly instruction manual, they are not a build guide, we use our Team Tech Tips section of our website where we can be far more content rich and go into more details of the process and techniques to building stuff.
Just so everyone knows for sure, the DEX210 project was BEFORE the Hobbico/Great Planes deal.
I'm also slightly confused by people saying they would happily pay more for the kit if it had a better specification... whats the difference between this and just buying the option parts?
I'm interested to hear everyone's feedback, TD always try and produce the best cars possible (certainly for quality) and also want the spec affordable to the broadest range of people and that is a race winner right out of the box.
and in my opinion, the DEX210 IS that... I ran a box stock DEX210 with optional gear diff (because I gave away my Ball Diff to another driver) - the ball diff might have actually been better at that track!
I ran the KIT springs, KIT pistons.
Thanks
lordnikon
19-07-2012, 09:24 AM
Chris, nice to see TD taking some interest in customer feedback :thumbsup:
As a 'step up' from my previous ansmann X2c i found the build quite straight forward. I didn't know about the online manual being 'fixed' and just worked around the obvious mistakes in the one provided in the box. If it had been my first build of an RC car then it would have been quite confusing with the errors, so if wanting to appeal to 'newbies' then this needs sorting.
I dont think the spec is bad at all personally, ok it may not be upto the 410, but i have never had one so cant really compare.
As an out of the box 'race' ready car i think it hits the mark. I purchased the 401 stand offs, rear tower, steering link and the cream weight stuff, but this is part of the hobby. It would have worked out of the box, the option parts make it better.
I would say however if it had the option parts in it and the price was another £20-£30 more i would have probably looked more at the SV2.
TonyM
19-07-2012, 10:15 AM
Chris - as stated already, it's almost perfect out of the box, but you asked for ideas for improvement, so here goes:-
1. Get your hints and tips ready before a new product launch. I, like many others, didn't realise that the thrust washers had slightly different hole diameters and also that there is a wrong and right way to insert the circlip. Result, 2 diffs blown before the hints and tips section on building the diff came out a couple months later. Also, I can't see why this simple information couldn't have been put in the manual.
2. If a part looks weak re-engineer it before launching it. A prime example is the steering link. When we first saw this at my club we all said it would break too easily and sure enough it does.
3. If something works perfectly on another model, don’t reinvent the wheel and produce a lesser item. E.g the tower shock mounts – almost everyone I know has converted to the 410 rear mount all round. Not for bling, but ease of changing positions.
4. When bringing out a hop-up to fix issues first look at what others have done. E.g. wheel hexes, Losi, Tresrey and many others have produced hexes with screws so you don’t have to worry about losing the pin. The TD alu hex is just a straight copy of the plastic one.
5. Body – change it so you don’t have to use the silly cowling. Many others have produced bodies which fit both mid and rear motor mounts without the need for a cowling.
6. Try and lighten the diagrams in your manual. Sometimes it's difficult to see any detail as it's just coloured too dark to see any distinguishing features.
Chris Doughty
19-07-2012, 10:51 AM
Tony, thanks for the feedback.
I'll not reply to everything individually as I know I will end up spending all day on here playing forum tennis with everyone. but here are a few points.
the c-clip thing - the single biggest thing with this is over-crimping the clip - this is very bad. the orientation of the clip and small details like this can slightly help to compensate for this so our build guide and tech tip mentions this to ensure the best chance of it working well.
if you use the correct c-clip pliers and very very careful to not over-crimp the clip, It will work with the clip both ways round.
The body does not need to be used with the cowls, you can simply cut out your rear section for your motor plate.
The reason we went with the option for the cowls is that you can use a single painted body with ALL configurations, when you change to rear-motor (for example oOple race) you use the same body, just with the rear motor cowl, no hole in your body for where your motor plate would be...
also, no Ugly bulges to cover the motor plates.
Darkness of the diagrams in the manuals, I understand, we will work to make sure that the diagrams of multiple plastic parts aren't too dark in future manuals.
mattr
19-07-2012, 11:51 AM
Chris, my criticisms of the kit really boil down to TD not calling it an R spec kit. Which it really is. Would have given RD the opportunity to sell a full fat kit at a 50 quid premium too! (I'd have bought one, as it is I'm buying a mixture of td, tresrey, cream and other Hopups) And the shock mounts. For an eternal tinkerer, the steel mounts are essential. And were included in the 410R.
Anything else is not even bad enough to be called a minor irritation.
Matt
Still not had any contract about my oversize gear diff tho. ;)
AfroP
19-07-2012, 12:33 PM
As a few people have already stated it seems more like an R spec kit than a full fat race machine.
Yes the car is "race" ready out the box but aren't all 2wd kits at the moment?
B4.1 FT worlds kit, Losi 22, SV2, whack in your electrics and away you go. So I dont see how or why this is being used as a "plus" or a feature of the 210
The Circlip in the diff is terrible, the manual does not say that circlip pliers are required and I for one don't know many people that have any, the margin for error with that 1 part if far too great as the manual does not specify that there are 2 different sides, only after very close inspection or viewing the online build guide does this become apparent.
a little foot note or warning in the manual would help a lot.
There is far too much platic in use around the kit
plastic hexes just screams cost cutting/cheapness as does the plastic shock stand off's and shock O-ring caps.
Steel turnbuckle's when every other competition 2wd kit has titanium, again points to lack of build quality and more cost cutting.
The manual is for me the the worst part of the entire kit, there are far too many mistakes. even the updated online manual has mistakes as it doesnt mention anything about attaching the rear bumper, in mid motor config.
lack of little touches which again points to cost cutting, manual does not mention that threadlock is a required item and other kits include threadlock but the 210 does not.
There are several "essential" upgrade parts that many 210 owners are buying and adding during the build as they have been labled as weak points on the car.
The circlip - schumacher and Xray both have an alternative that is cheaper than the Durango spare
Alloy wheel hexes - should be in the kit
Carbon steering link plate - as the kit supplied plastic is too weak
Slipper pads - replace with associated part as the kit pads are too thin
I do love my 210 and look forward to racing it and getting it to a more comfortable standard for me but on the points that have been mentioned here I cant feel that it could have and should have been better.
I love my DEX210 and yes there are a few areas I would like some alloy for some added strength, but ive not really broken much since release. Although im not very fast!
I think TD should improve on getting out upgrades before third party companies produce them. It is nice to have a few different brands producing products but TD could make more money here.
But then you have to acknowledge TD are releasing various different kits and having to develop those too, while having a change of ownership.
TonyM
19-07-2012, 02:14 PM
Tony, thanks for the feedback.
The body does not need to be used with the cowls, you can simply cut out your rear section for your motor plate.
The reason we went with the option for the cowls is that you can use a single painted body with ALL configurations, when you change to rear-motor (for example oOple race) you use the same body, just with the rear motor cowl, no hole in your body for where your motor plate would be...
also, no Ugly bulges to cover the motor plates.
I tried that but, in comparison to the other bodies. I found that without cutting out the section for the cowl the TD body was rubbing against the motor solder posts and was not fitting correctly. If the body incorporated the 'hump' as per the cowl then all would be OK.
dpackster1980
19-07-2012, 05:18 PM
Tony, thanks for the feedback.
I'll not reply to everything individually as I know I will end up spending all day on here playing forum tennis with everyone. but here are a few points.
the c-clip thing - the single biggest thing with this is over-crimping the clip - this is very bad. the orientation of the clip and small details like this can slightly help to compensate for this so our build guide and tech tip mentions this to ensure the best chance of it working well.
if you use the correct c-clip pliers and very very careful to not over-crimp the clip, It will work with the clip both ways round.
The body does not need to be used with the cowls, you can simply cut out your rear section for your motor plate.
The reason we went with the option for the cowls is that you can use a single painted body with ALL configurations, when you change to rear-motor (for example oOple race) you use the same body, just with the rear motor cowl, no hole in your body for where your motor plate would be...
also, no Ugly bulges to cover the motor plates.
Darkness of the diagrams in the manuals, I understand, we will work to make sure that the diagrams of multiple plastic parts aren't too dark in future manuals.
It's great that someone is wanting to know what think.
On the quality side of things I have the following issues:-
1) Rear wishbone slop, this would have been noticed by any TD driver when building the kit. This should've been rectified prior to release.
2) The HD ball cups still have slop in them like the old ones, still like to pop off when changing camber but don't seem to pop off as easily so still not great. I think its to do with them not wrapping round the ball enough.
3) I should've spoke to TD customer support but needed to get the car ready, I had an oversized idler gear shaft so the bearings were tight and are going to be a pain to get off.
Now the spec:-
1) Metal shock stand offs, these were on all TD cars including the R range so are and were expected.
2) Alloy shock caps, as per above and they are on the 410v3.
3) Gold shock shafts, they are on the 410 but not the 210. They've been introduced on one model and not the other.
4) Plastic Steering rack, fair enough if you have a servo saver. A pressed steel one would be better.
5) Plastic hexes, they would squash over a short period.
The above would make it the same spec as the 410 and people would be a lot happier.
cigbunt
19-07-2012, 05:23 PM
I've only upgraded the
rear shock tower to carbon
changed the turnbuckles to losi
b4 slippers
got the front carbon shock tower and steering link in my box not needed to change them and only thing I've broken is a rear wishbone, and i crash loads...
in regards to plastic hexes I've not squashed mine, am i doing something wrong?
210 has got so many upgrades i don't think there all "needed"
dpackster1980
19-07-2012, 06:58 PM
I've only upgraded the
rear shock tower to carbon
changed the turnbuckles to losi
b4 slippers
got the front carbon shock tower and steering link in my box not needed to change them and only thing I've broken is a rear wishbone, and i crash loads...
in regards to plastic hexes I've not squashed mine, am i doing something wrong?
210 has got so many upgrades i don't think there all "needed"
All upgrades are not needed, but taking away what was standard on all previous models including R versions and replacing it with cheaper components especially on just a single model seems very odd. It makes the 210 not even a 210R.
Origineelreclamebord
19-07-2012, 08:41 PM
I agree with you, I would rather have seen a DEX210 with the 410's high grade finish, and I would have paid the extra money, but I understand it's more profitable to attract a larger public with cars of a more down to earth finish. So for the money you pay for it, you really can't complain. A higher spec DEX210 would have cost pretty much the additional money you'll now spend on the upgraded parts seperately.
dpackster1980
19-07-2012, 09:06 PM
I agree with you, I would rather have seen a DEX210 with the 410's high grade finish, and I would have paid the extra money, but I understand it's more profitable to attract a larger public with cars of a more down to earth finish. So for the money you pay for it, you really can't complain. A higher spec DEX210 would have cost pretty much the additional money you'll now spend on the upgraded parts seperately.
It wouldn't have raised the price that much, lets say the mark up for buying the parts as an upgrade is 100%. The price of the kit is an extra £26 to put the alloy hexes in, the gold shock shafts, the metal shock mounts, pressed aluminium steering rack and the red alloy oring caps. That would put the retail price upto £225. It's still cheaper than the rest and it would appeal more so due to the extras.
Everyone is a winner, get the manual right as well and Durango would be laughing. It would also make the kit what it was meant to be a top spec race winner from the box. :thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:
Si Coe
19-07-2012, 09:30 PM
Ah - but you forget that cost to Durango is not the same as cost to you.
The shock standoffs for example had to be specially made, whilst a screw and some nuts costs literally pence if you buy enough.
Likewise making the mould for the plastic o-ring caps may cost a fair amount, but once made the more caps you make the cheaper they effectively become. In contrast the machined caps essentially take the same effort regardless of how many you make.
The result is that with those parts I'm sure it would be a lot more than £20-30 more because they make it much harder for Durango to make, and less profitable.
Anyway - my view on the quality of the car is that it is at least as good as many other high end models. Maybe not as good as a 410 (I don't own one so can't say) but certainly as good as the AE, Losi and Yokomo cars I've worked on.
But then I bought mine because its a great 2wd car, not because I wanted a 'luxury' model. Admittedly I've blinged mine up since, because the car really does deserve the carbon and alloy, but it doesn't need it.
My dex210 kit was missing the thrust bearings for the diff when building the kit and I had reliability issues with the diff after running it a few times. The clutch pads didn't last long either. I have replaced the standard diff with a geared diff and use associated slipper pads and all seems fine now. It's not an expensive car to buy and parts are reasonably priced so i am happy. I haven't broke it once either. I can certainly see the points made regarding the specification compared to the 4wd and I would of paid extra for a higher spec kit.
dpackster1980
20-07-2012, 04:52 PM
Well just spent £14 on 2 parts trees with new oring nuts and one is showing signs of leaking. What a waste of money, this wouldn't happen with the alloy ones. Not happy in the very slightest. It's a complete joke, if this is the way Durango is going they can stick any future cars I've had enough! :thumbdown:
jimmy
20-07-2012, 05:00 PM
Where are they leaking? The orings should stop leaking or am I missing something?
jimmy
20-07-2012, 05:02 PM
Why did you spend £14 on plastic oring nuts when the RRP of the alloy ones is £12?
dpackster1980
20-07-2012, 05:22 PM
Why did you spend £14 on plastic oring nuts when the RRP of the alloy ones is £12?
I couldn't find stock anywhere of the alloy ones so my hands were tide. They are leaking from what appears to be between the nut and the washer that sits inside. The orings are fine so I've had enough, it'll get ran for a season and sold.
jimmy
20-07-2012, 05:28 PM
If the orings are pressed against the body, and pressed against the shaft ------ where is the oil possibly coming from?
Have you checked there's no deep scratches inside the body or on the shaft ? or even a cut on the outside of one of the orings?
I don't think I've ever used the plastic caps myself but I have some on my new shocks I'm building. If the orings aren't getting compressed enough then I guess that could cause some leaking - why not try a thin washer between the centre plastic spacer and the last oring (or either way round) to press on the orings a little more and ensure they're engaging the body and shaft properly.
The alloy caps are in stock at Team Durango.
Chris-S
20-07-2012, 05:41 PM
I couldn't find stock anywhere of the alloy ones so my hands were tide. They are leaking from what appears to be between the nut and the washer that sits inside. The orings are fine so I've had enough, it'll get ran for a season and sold.
http://www.team-durango.com/part-info.php?partNo=TD330023
FYI, I've never had any problems with either the plastic or the metal caps.
dpackster1980
20-07-2012, 05:45 PM
At £6 delivery I'll wait until MB have them. I suspect with the plastic caps you can't compress them enough. The plastic caps are without doubt the most moronic cost cutting rhing TD could ever do. The 410R had cost cutting that didn't affect the performance and in some cases made it better. This is just stupidity if its not broke leave it alone!
jimmy
20-07-2012, 05:48 PM
I just had a quick look with some digital calipers and a bit of macro photography - and the plastic caps I think press the seals better. The plastic cap on the body is approximately 0.1mm shorter overall than with the metal cap.
http://www.oople.com/rc/photos/misc/news/tdshockcaps.jpg
Like I said though - if you're finding the shocks leaking there's got to be a cause and the most obvious other than damage (which I'm sure you've checked for) would be the seals not getting enough pressure - adding a 0.5mm plastic washer or similar should help matters. I don't think the plastic caps are a problem - but like I say, I've not used them myself yet.
dpackster1980
20-07-2012, 05:49 PM
Now I'm going the have to spend another £14 to get the alloy ones when a retailer does have them. I guess I'll be lining TD pockets yet again. :thumbdown:
dpackster1980
20-07-2012, 05:57 PM
I just had a quick look with some digital calipers and a bit of macro photography - and the plastic caps I think press the seals better. The plastic cap on the body is approximately 0.1mm shorter overall than with the metal cap.
http://www.oople.com/rc/photos/misc/news/tdshockcaps.jpg
Like I said though - if you're finding the shocks leaking there's got to be a cause and the most obvious other than damage (which I'm sure you've checked for) would be the seals not getting enough pressure - adding a 0.5mm plastic washer or similar should help matters. I don't think the plastic caps are a problem - but like I say, I've not used them myself yet.
That doesn't take into the account that the plastic could be forced out by the pressure of the orings behind it which would allow them to leak alloy caps wouldn't.
jimmy
20-07-2012, 06:03 PM
I've got lots of bits here so I don't mind jabbing a screw driver into my shock to test your theory - with the last spacer (that sits inside the cap) in place. I have to say it's an interesting idea but having just forced a driver against it I don't see that being a realistic possibility. Just my personal observation and opinion.
I am worried that you're wanting alloy caps believing they will fix your issue when they might not.
Adam Skelding
20-07-2012, 06:05 PM
At £6 delivery I'll wait until MB have them. I suspect with the plastic caps you can't compress them enough. The plastic caps are without doubt the most moronic cost cutting rhing TD could ever do. The 410R had cost cutting that didn't affect the performance and in some cases made it better. This is just stupidity if its not broke leave it alone!
The plastic caps aren't a moronic idea. They replace an over engineered part with something that performs the same job at a fraction of the price.
If one of your shocks are leaking there's probably an issue elsewhere. The red alloy caps won't fix the issue as jimmy mentions they are actually a little shorter but the internals are the same. Might be worth having someone else look over your shocks.
Plastic hexes. I've just replaced mine after a year of running. They had worn but I guess a year of running is ok?
Shock stand-offs. The all metal ones aren't cheap and if you are getting the screw version to flex then they can't be done up properly.
The 2wd market is the most cost conscious around, it's what most people getting into buggy racing start with due to low start up costs and running costs. We trimmed off cost to the end customer without affecting performance. Giving the customer cash in his pocket to upgrade as he chooses.
Adding CF, Ti and custom alloy parts adds a surprising amount to kits. Usually too much for us to justify. The 410 was an exception, one which worked at the time due to its originality. But the model isn't the same for all classes.
The manual was a little rushed but we try and catch with online versions.
If you are still having issues with your shocks try getting hold of one of the team and get them to check them over. It's unrest to have a 2nd pair of eyes look them over.
Just a heads up though guys, if you think that compressing an o-ring will make them seal better, they won't, they will spread and start to become unseated, they work best just touching the surface, unless you have square profile o-rings, but in all my years of engineering, I have never found squishing an o-ring to make it seal better, it only makes it leak worse.
hotrodchris
20-07-2012, 07:01 PM
DCM just what I was thinking probably overtightened I run with the plastic caps and if I find a leak its always from the top because I have over tightened the caps!
jimmy
20-07-2012, 07:04 PM
I don't think you'd say a floating o-ring that barely touches the sides does a good job of sealing would you Steve? If they aren't held firmly in place they won't seal too well don't you think. :lol:
jimmy
20-07-2012, 07:08 PM
DCM just what I was thinking probably overtightened I run with the plastic caps and if I find a leak its always from the top because I have over tightened the caps!
Thinking somethings inferior and is going to leak even before building it - then stripping them out whilst building, would suggest there's been some serious cranking down on these plastic parts. Finger tight!
dpackster1980
20-07-2012, 07:22 PM
I dont think you can over tighten them, the cap tops touch the shock body so they will strip. That means you can't over compress the orings unless either the plastic spacers are too big or the bottom of the shock body isn't deep enough where the orings sit.
What's definitely making me think its the caps is the rest are looking a little wet, they're starting to leak not anywhere near as bad.
I build them the same way as my 410 shocks they don't leak.
TonyM
20-07-2012, 07:23 PM
I've not had any problems with either the the plastic or alu versions. However, I aways grease the 'O' rings with AE green slime, or similar, when I build them. If I forget, then I get leakage.
MHeadling
20-07-2012, 07:56 PM
I can't believe so much talk on o rings and shock caps!
AE use plastic shock caps and these work just fine as do the Durango ones, don't see too many people complaining about these shocks.
Like anything if you over tighten plastic to metal you run the danger of it stripping.
Also any shock on a Rc car if you don't grease the shaft (shock shaft! Lol) it'll damage the O rings.
It's all simple stuff!
I don't think you'd say a floating o-ring that barely touches the sides does a good job of sealing would you Steve? If they aren't held firmly in place they won't seal too well don't you think. :lol:
Thinking somethings inferior and is going to leak even before building it - then stripping them out whilst building, would suggest there's been some serious cranking down on these plastic parts. Finger tight!
They shouldn't be tight, but not slack either, they should just about slip in, so when your o-rings are old and swollen, they don't sit in the bore correctly, if they are a dense o-ring, they will pinch the shock shaft and impede movement, if they are soft o-rings, they won't seay correctly and leak.
As for shock building, my Schumacher and Tamiya shocks only ever get built finger tight, as Jimmy says, and they only leak when something is worn. If you have cranked on them like a Gorilla on Speed, damage is already done to the seals and the moulded plastic threads.
Alan Reeves
20-07-2012, 08:36 PM
I really don't think the 210 deserves all this bad press, Mine is from the first batch and has performed really well week in week out ever since.
The few problems I've had have been sorted by Durango quickly and free of charge!
One was the gear diff, I sent this back direct to Durango and they upgraded the parts, rebuilt it for me and sent back a diff ready to fit into my car and even filled with the oil of my choice!!
The layshaft spacer also crushed on mine, but again a quick photo, emailed off to Adam and a new one arrived in the post the next day.
Infact the Durango staff are brilliant, I have had a few phone calls with them chatting about the car and set ups etc always willing to try and help no matter what :thumbsup:
If your having problems, give them a call... you may be pleasantly surprised!
If I was able to offer any advice for the update model if and when it comes out my biggest recommendations would be to look at :
the wheels - these don't stay round for very long
The rear hub clearance - I have found these clog when running on grass and cause binding
Rear shock tower - this has proved to be too weak
In conclusion...
I don't think there are any more issues with the 210 than any other 2wd, its just a matter of learning the car and modifying it to suit yourself. It is a race car and I think it should be tinkered with to make improvements... that's how you get an edge over your rivals!
jayst
20-07-2012, 08:50 PM
i cant believe all the negativity , ive a 210 from the first batch and had no problems with it . the ball diff is still running fine and not been rebuilt since i pruchased the car , my friend now runs it as i changed to the gear diff because he had problems . caps were fine only upgraded to alloy red 1s as i had the old 410 shocks lyin around .also turnbuckle plastics have been fine too . the only thing i was breakin was the steering link and rear tower but thats just me crashing.
i love all the team durango products and will continue buying and racing them. :thumbsup:
keep up the good work td :thumbsup:
hotrodchris
21-07-2012, 06:15 AM
The car as a whole is solid, upgraded rear shock tower as saw a few break prior to me getting mine and had issues with ball diff so got a spare one and modded the spacer problem solved!
The main issue with this car is the operator but that would be the same whoever the manufacturer was!
Stretch
21-07-2012, 08:33 AM
So, to summarise:
The OP bemoaned the lower spec of the 210 compared to the 410, and the errors in the instruction manual.
Adam explained why this was so and apologised about the manual.
The rest seems to be talking about a range of build problems.
Yes? :)
Just don't get me started on the quality of the bearings in my 2010 spec full-fat 410....
I just want to add that I called Durango uk about my missing thrust bearing and other small issues I was having. They were very helpful and sent me replacement parts without charge.
dpackster1980
19-08-2012, 03:05 PM
Solved the leaking shock issue, use Tamiya ones. The ones TD supply are useless, they seem different the the ones in my small bore 410 shocks that don't leak.
As for the sloppy ballcups it looks like I'll be going down the HPI balls and rigid Losi cup route again!
sime46
20-08-2012, 02:05 AM
Really tho????
dpackster1980
20-08-2012, 06:04 AM
Really tho????
Different orings no leaks and kit orings with oil weeping from them tells me the kit orings are very poor.
The kit ones seem very soft compared to the 2010 410 ones. People can say whatever they want but I've had both to bits alongside eachother and its a fact.
dpackster1980
20-08-2012, 08:07 AM
Really tho????
My wording was crap in my post, I meant the shock end orings were rubbish not the shocks themselves.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.