PDA

View Full Version : Before the AGM, a State of the Nation/club debate.


andy110m
28-01-2014, 01:19 PM
Hi All,

With the AGM coming soon I wanted to share with you all a discussion I had this morning regarding changes to the buggy class and possibly the club in general.

I am apposed to the thoughts and comments I was hearing and my reasons for this will surprise some of you who've known me for a while.

The general gist of the conversation was about trying to make Ribble Valley into a more off road style buggy club with more slippery sections, rumble strips and possibly larger jumps. It was also mooted we pit in the other hall and carpet all the existing hall to create two tracks, one for off road and one for the GT12's. We all should run rubber tyres and raise the ride height to 10-12mm which you'd have to anyway with the changes to the track. We also threw around the idea of single class racing, either be a 2wd only or 4wd only club, along with a motor limit. I must confess the last two ideas I raised as they would logically follow the other suggestions.

What was said to be the driving force behind all this need for change was the wish to get a level playing field, get closer racing and reduce costs, and believe me we had some funny debate over whats affordable and what isn't:D.

Now I'll tell you why I think all this is completely wrong. Finally, after a few weeks of bringing my young lad and talking to other lads and dads, I get it. It took me a good many years but finally I now understand. Ribble Valley is a fun club, the strap line is racing for fun and its spot on.

This club is not for the fast racers who want nose to tail action for 5 minutes. I'm not decrying it at all, I think it does well and really enjoyed racing last week catering for the faster guys but its aimed at fun on a Friday night with your family and mates. These changes will take the club backwards. We have close racing now, we have cheap racing now. All the goals of our discussions are either wrong for the club or have already been achieved.

Thinking about the history of this club, the transformation from the days at Westview, then Fulwood to what its become now is unbelievable. The club has been racing for well over 20 years so many of the new ideas are old ideas and have been tried and assessed in the past. The good ones kept and the bad ones scrapped and this is whats brought us to where we are now. For example in the days of Fulwood, we raced touring cars and it was decided we enforce a motor limit. For all the same reasons, lower cost, closer racing etc. All it meant was all the members had to buy new motors and the fast guys did all they could to get the max performance. The results stayed the same, all we did was increase cost so it was scrapped. When we came to the current venue, we raced buggies on rubber and to be competitive you needed a new set every week which cost a fortune. We had bigger jumps but still people had cars on the deck and when I stopped coming, due to tyre cost, people started putting additive on mini pins to look to save an extra tenth of a second. Now its evolved to foams its great, about 15 quid for a set and they'll last a good couple of months.

The up shot of all this rambling is the committee should be congratulated for agreeing a plan, sticking to it and creating and developing a very successful club and format. It works as its is. From the automated booking in, the different practice for varying abilities, pretty much everything from the tuck shop to the foams to the 4 minute heats is right and works. I do have to hold my hand up and admit in the past I was pushing the committee to be more race minded but they held firm and were right to do so.

Its also worth remembering we've had this discussion about creating a race car club before. In fact one of the former racers felt so strongly the club should change direction he created not one but two clubs to attract the racers. The first was on a Saturday so no clash but numbers we're very low. He questioned people as to why and got told it has to be on a Friday night. So he tried again on a Friday and got the same result. So its been demonstrated, people want a racing for fun club, with good racing, yes sure, but they don't want a Southport, Chadderton or Worksop style. They don't want RVRCCC to be messed with to make it a racers club either. Or so I believe having talked to people over the past few weeks.

I'm looking forward to bringing my lad to race in the near future, or crash round the track as it will be for at least the first couple of months but at this club that's fine. Nathan and the other kids are the target market, not the A finalists. In fact this debate shouldn't concern me as a racer because when Nathan starts I'll be pitting for him (read, pitting as repairing his car every heat!) and trying to bring him on instead of racing myself.

I posted this to get the views of others, to start people thinking and see what the general thoughts are. These and other proposals I've been told will be made at the AGM so its a good discussion to have. You've got my 2 pence, its working very well, its certainly ain't broke so don't mess with it.

Please discuss.

spennyy2k
28-01-2014, 03:22 PM
The discussion came about via several racers, not wanting to change how the club is, ie to a pure buggy/racer club but as far as the buggies go more off road content not running them as touring cars. Yes there would could be an increase in running costs with tyres, this could be helped with a control tyre to a degree. At the end of the day they are off road cars and everyone asked across a range of driver abilities agrees with it (apart from 1). No one is saying the committee has done wrong or a bad job running things, and it is run well. Cars are getting faster and one thing that is definitely needed is a longer and wider track.

andy110m
28-01-2014, 03:48 PM
Firstly, full agree with Steve, nobody is or was saying the committee has done anything but good work however people are saying change is needed and the point I'm making is no it isn't.

We shouldn't want to raise the costs, I think that's just daft when we have something that works so well and so cheaply. Secondly, yes we race off road cars but we race them in an on road environment. People set up their cars to the conditions. No different to any other club. I can't see an issue.

Lastly, I disagree with the comment the track needs to be longer and wider. I'm sure the A final would love all those changes but this club isn't for those people. Its for the rest of the people who want to come and have a bit of fun with their toy cars on a Friday night.

spennyy2k
28-01-2014, 03:54 PM
I agree with what your saying however if it's tight and twisty it's hard for beginners, and its hard to pass at the top end as well, the last track had a 2.5m wide straight and it was far better

andy110m
28-01-2014, 04:05 PM
Good point Steve, tight and twisty can be tricky for a beginner. So we don't need track size, tyre, motor and car changes, all we need is a redesigned track?

If its still the same process as when I used to race, am I right in saying the track design is changed every 8 week series anyway? So job done?

spennyy2k
28-01-2014, 04:29 PM
The problem is there isn't enough carpet to make the track consistently wider

websteri
28-01-2014, 05:01 PM
I would say that the buggies should all be running rubber not foams - they are designed to run that way. The track can be improved with better ramps, a table top with underpass for the mardaves, and rumbled bits where the sheet is to test the suspension etc. Southport have that bit done really well. If it's a fun night then I don't see a need for foams. Keep it simple with Schumacher mini pins/spikes so all run the same. Foams isn't what they were designed for. My nephew can't be going out for foams etc. Let's just keep it simple and run tyres - seems logical

websteri
28-01-2014, 05:04 PM
And before the foams came in there it was fairer and more FUN. Seems like foams have divided everyone into the haves and have nots.

andy110m
28-01-2014, 06:05 PM
Sorry, I can't address you by name, I'm not sure who you are but I don't understand the haves and have nots idea. How can you stop people running new tyres every week which is what happened in the past? Surely thats haves and have nots.

The foams are simple to order direct from Schumacher, cost less than a set of the tyres your suggesting and last meeting after meeting. If we go back to rubber, racing will cost more. How does that benefit your nephew? I'm also interested, when we did race rubber, how was it more fun?

I'll also give you another reason why foams are good for RVRCCC. If a rubber tyred car leaves the track and keeps driving, there's a good chance it'll damage the floor. A foam car wouldn't.

We also need to get away from arguing what these cars were designed for. They were designed to race and that's what we're doing with them.

You do make a good point about Southport doing a good job, they do and its a great club for racers but again that isn't the point of RVRCCC. Its about fun. What you're talking about is making changes to benefit racers.

Its interesting though you've mentioned Southport. (Is your nephew booked in for Turf wars on Sunday at Southport because this is relevant if he is?) Its interesting because their members had the same issues Ribble had. High wear rates and high costs to stay competitive. They wanted to lower the cost of tyres. Pins or spikes both give good grip but wore out easily in one meeting. So they've all gone to running the old Schumacher blocks. They modify the tyre or the wheel to make them fit properly and they've solved the problem. (You could also argue our buggies aren't designed to run those tyres as our wheels are 2.2 not 2.0.but no ones looking to change that.)

Great grip and tyres now last about 4 meetings but its unlikely they'll use them elsewhere. They evolved exactly as Ribble has. They all think its great. So looking at your example of Southport, why would we want to do as they have in finding a better solution, then go back to why we found the solution in the first place?

spennyy2k
28-01-2014, 07:05 PM
FYI these old Schumacher blocks are infact new, if his nephew is a beginner then rubbers will be cheaper as A: he won't be fast enough to wear them and B:he won't chunk them to death. On my lads car he had 2 pairs of rear rubber tyres in about 6 months running at ribble and blackpool

spennyy2k
28-01-2014, 07:15 PM
http://www.redrc.net/2013/03/schumacher-block-rear-tire/

MattK
28-01-2014, 07:21 PM
I am going to chuck into this. :lol:

We must remember ribble is racing for fun, main aim and top of the list.

Ok, looking around the pits all or most the junior drivers currently run rubber tyres, so a change in that direction won't change anything really.
If a control tyre is introduced then there defiantly needs to be something to stop New tyres every heat or round, maybe same set for each half championship?

Also I think any increase in track size is better for any driver of any ability and alot more fun.

Only problem with a control tyre is if someone turns up for a 1st time with kit tyres, then these people should be allowed to race for upto 3weeks maybe or just don't score championship rounds while running non regulation tyres.

Ride hight is one of the things that should be raised and enforced, with or without control tyres.

These are my opinions
:)

andy110m
28-01-2014, 07:27 PM
Steve, Yes the blocks are new but they come out of the old molds, they are still a 2.0, not a 2.2 and most people cut them to ensure a good fit.

spennyy2k
28-01-2014, 07:30 PM
Ah ok, i assumed they were a new mould as well, I stand corrected

andy110m
28-01-2014, 07:34 PM
Matt is right about the bottom end not being affected but the mid field will be, they'll be going quick enough to wear mini pins so it isn't fun after a week and a half.

I don't know how you could police tyres either, your getting into the need to scrutineer the cars so surely that's another reason to leave it alone.

funkygrump81
28-01-2014, 07:52 PM
Who says it has too be a control tyre for buggys , we run 1/10th offroad buggys so just state that they should run comercially available buggy tyres ??!!??!!??!!this would also slow the cars down stop them sliding so much and cut down on damage too the track sections ?!?!?!

andy110m
28-01-2014, 07:53 PM
I've just been looking at older threads to see if this has come up before and I found this one talking about more jumps.

http://www.oople.com/forums/showthread.php?t=131740

Seems to cover very similar ground and Matt, you made the statement you couldn't afford to go back after running foams.

spennyy2k
28-01-2014, 08:02 PM
The control tyre was a suggestion to control cost as there is a mini pin style tyre available and cheaper than Schumacher. Just waiting on a price

andy110m
28-01-2014, 08:23 PM
Two more thread stating how good foams are and how they reduce cost.

http://www.oople.com/forums/showthread.php?t=129195

http://www.oople.com/forums/showthread.php?t=124690

Then I found the debate where this all started at start of last year. Seems to me, the foams issue at least, has been discussed and decided already.

http://www.oople.com/forums/showthread.php?t=119914

andy110m
28-01-2014, 08:37 PM
Wayne, the foams are commercially available and I don't get why you don't like them so much.

The issue if the club went back to rubber is how do you stop a competitive racer using a new set every run. I saw a racer trying to make the A final at the last turf wars use 3 sets of tyres.

What stops that person doing the same at Ribble? And where does it leave everyone else. If you're going to introduce rules to stop it who controls it?

The club is working well and has had this discussion before. Most people like foams and appreciate their benefits.

Again I ask, why change whats working so well?

MattK
28-01-2014, 09:19 PM
As I have said before cost is the issue for me. And that is what I have said above.
I think it's right there is open conversation and challenge to the rules as things change and progress overtime. Imagine if the rules never changed we wouldn't have Lipo and brushless motors and the cost saving they give.

I like foams and believe they are cheaper to run every week, but am open to discussion if it works out to be better for the club.

Bigger track will always get my personal vote, and I agree with the principle of raised ride height.

I think there should be rules about not standing with your hands in your pockets when marshalling, how many people are guilty of that I wonder and what final they normally make? :p

gaz23
28-01-2014, 10:53 PM
Wider track means easier for less experienced and also easier to overtake/let past for the more competitive.

More jumps means more fun for all drivers of all abilities (just ask the young ones and old codgers)

Never mind all the rest

Nuf said

No replies thanks just making my point

mark-rc
29-01-2014, 02:23 AM
Ok my turn!

If your a club member, your membership gives you the right to voice your thoughts and opinions on all aspects of the club. In my opinion, from what I have read, there are alot of valid and not so valid points been raised. I have been racing at the club almost on a weekly basis for the past four years, and have been racing in general for almost 27 years, at many different clubs and in many different classes. I'm not going to go over what everyone has said, but will just list my points and thoughts.

The Track: The system of the track now in the way it can be raced on by both on road and off road cars, with just a change of moving a barrier is good and it works! The problem I see is that the club is growing in numbers all the time! and the track is becoming to small for the number of cars in a heat, so if there is a way of having more carpet down and a bigger track, this will make it better for all, over taking, easier to get round with new drivers, and we would hopefully see alot less car breakages! As at the moment there are far to many cars getting broken because of the high speed, and the number of cars trying to get round on to tight of a track. Having a bigger track will also allow the use of more jumps, rumble strips etc, for the buggies, and that is what buggies are made for, and that's what make them so much fun! Everyone from the beginners, Anna and Arron right up to my level, buy and race buggies because we all love jumping and driving them on varying 'off road' surfaces. That's where the challenge and real enjoyment comes from racing a buggy!

Tyres, Foam: There are both good and bad points to both foams and rubber tyres. Yes, in terms of cost, foams 'will' last longer and you will get more race meetings out of them, 'BUT' foams are also easily ripped or chunked, and most times when that happens they are only good for the bin! 'FACT' Foams are faster on the track, you get the amount of grip you want by the amount of additive you put on them, and this makes general car setup not as important.

Rubber tyres: Rubber tyres make racing closer across all levels, they are slower around the track! This is because you get the right balance of grip through car setup 'you can drive a poorly setup car fast on foams but you can't on rubbers'. Yes you get less meetings out of rubbers, but for the beginner to mid level drivers, they don't have to worry about ripping or chunking them, and there skill level is often not good enough to make the most out of 'new' tyres, in fact, in most cases, new tyres give to much grip for them. As for ware rate, Anna and Arron had a new set of rubber tyres in October, they are still on the same set and they still get round the track at a good pace for there level! If your a good race level driver, you will ware out both rubber and foam tyres faster! and if you want to compete you need to have good 'new' tyres on your car be it foam or rubber! I know I can send Arron and Anna out to race, they crash and get crashed into, and I don't have to worry about the cost of having to replace foam tyres on there cars or tell them there night is over coz they have no tyres to race on!

Buggy- Mardave - Touring car: What is the class you are racing?? It's very simple, if your racing buggies, then the car should be set up as a buggy! If I 'Know' I can go faster on the track by changing my cars shocks and suspension on my buggy to be more like a touring car, is it right to say 'I'm just setting up my car for the track conditions'? If that's the case, Am I equally ok to think 'I know I can go faster than a buggy set up like a touring car, 'IF' I race a touring car with a buggy shell on it? What if I turn up with a 1/12th circuit car and race it against the Mardaves? There both onroad cars right? and they both look similar to each other. When I book in to the club on line, I am booking in to race in the 'Buggy' class. If I raced Mardaves I would book in to race Mardaves! Buggies should be ran as Buggies, this means the car should be within the limits of ride height, shock travel and all the basic guiding outlines that state what a '1/10th off road Buggy class' should be! If I want to run my 'Buggy' as a touring car, then I should go out and buy a touring car and race it with other touring cars! I race my car at other tracks, not just Layland, So now if I want to compete at Layland, I need to buy a full second set of shocks to set my car up with very little shock travel and set it sat on the deck! I can't keep taking apart the shocks on the car and putting them back to full travel for other tracks, as this would ware out the shocks and would end up costing more money to keep buying more shock oil to refill the shocks! So I would have to buy a second set of shocks. Now, the guy who is trying to keep pace with me, see's how much faster I am going with my tour car set up, and then realizes that if he wants to keep up with me he has to do the same! And then the guy who is trying to keep up with him, you get the point. There has to be a basic set of rule for each class, because if there isn't, where does it end? At some point, someone will turn up with a touring car with a buggy shell fitted and race it in the 'Buggy' class.

Fun club or Race club: The fact is, times move on, and so as the club. It is no longer just a beginners family fun club. the club is now made up of equal numbers of beginners, Ribble Vally regulars and good level racers that race at numerous other clubs! The club can no longer just cater for the the beginner family fun group. It has to look at everyone, and look at how thing can be changed for the benefit of all who race there. I go there with my family and we go there to 'race' and have fun! But, the club is growing, 'which is a good thing' but there are now that many cars on the track, with as much horse power as they can buy, going to fast, on a over crowded, tight track, this is leading to cars being smashed up far to much! I spend more time fixing broken cars than I do getting them on the race track, and I'm not the only one! over the past number of weeks, you would loose count of how many cars are getting broken, due to the way things are! I don't believe the 'if it ain't broke don't fix it' point at this time. Because cars are getting broke, on an ever increasing rate! And I don't see how this is meant to be 'cost effective fun' for the parents who have to keep spending to repair there kids cars every week.

andy110m
29-01-2014, 09:45 AM
Morning Mark,

I enjoyed reading your post, some good thoughts and comments. A lot of it I can agreed with if we are going to have change, the increase in track size for example would be good if it leads to less breakages and possibly more features. I do think it would give rise to different problems, space for pitting, time to build the track and put it away and the time required to race everyone and the extra people who'd come because of the different track.

Where we have differing views is on the tyres and car set up.

Foams, I agree, can and do get chunked. But because there foam they can also be repaired very easily. OK you might not want to do it on a Friday night because the tyre needs to be trued up again but it means next week your tyres are back to full width and it didn't cost anything. With Rubber tyres "the" problem is how do you stop someone running a new set every week, or even every run? As you said you need to be on new tyres to be competitive. So as this Friday is my 3rd week back I'll have saved £50 ish on wheels, tyres and inserts by running my foams for the 3rd time. Even if I concede I reuse wheels and inserts its still around £30. I can't understand why anyone would want to return to rubber, we used to race rubber and that is exactly what happened, new boots every week, which is why I stopped racing at Ribble.

The car set up argument I also question. In answer to your comment, what stops someone racing a touring car with a buggy shell, the answer is simple, the RVRCCC construction rules.

http://www.rvrccc.co.uk/construction-rules/buggy-build-rules

The first thing it states, "Any commercially available 2WD or 4WD 1/10 scale Buggy Kit." A touring car kit isn't a buggy kit so can't be used. So hopefully we can agree on that can't happen so that's put to bed.

Lets think about sets ups. Your car at Southport on Sunday will be set up for the high grip conditions, I know you've worked on that set up to get your car working as well as it can and it does look dialled round the track. However, I'm also sure if you went to a slippy track the weekend after you'd make changes to dial your car to that track so I don't understand why your upset about people tuning their car to what is basically an on road environment at Ribble.

I think you're going to see more cars lower this week, I told a good few people last week how to achieve it. A couple of spacers under the pistons, thicker oil and stiffer springs. If you think about it all we're doing is reducing the droop whilst maintaining the min 5mm ride height.

The last thing I'd query is if an on road style set up is bad what about all the other technology from that section of our hobby. Using boost on speedos isn't at all common in off road because cars typically have more power than grip and just as in touring cars, because of boosting motor speed, we're having to pre-cool the motor to stop the car shutting down mid run. So purchasing a 50 quid piece of technology to get a speed advantage is fine but to achieve better handling a £3 pack of spacers and some fuel tube isn't?

But look, lets leave all this one side. This is all aimed at the sharp end of the racing and Ribble isn't aimed at you and I. Its aimed at Anna, Arron and Nathan to develop in racing with the emphasis on fun. It doesn't matter what daft ideas we dream up to give us an extra 10th, what matters is the people for whom Ribble is their only place to race and experience this hobby. We shouldn't add rules which complicate things, affects everyone and burdens the people running to meeting to enforce.

It comes down to choice. If you want to run foams, boost your motor or put spacers in your shocks, great do it, if you don't, then don't. All we do need to do is have fun on a Friday and leave the serious stuff to Sunday.

mark-rc
29-01-2014, 12:04 PM
Andy, I never said that I thought Foams are a bad idea. I just pointed out the good and bad points regarding foams and rubber tyres. Both for the beginner through to the pro drivers. One thing you have to remember is that not many if any people have a tyre truing machine. So when a set of tyres are damaged not everyone has either the knowledge or the equipment to repair the tyre, and as I said, If I put Arron and Anna on foams, as and when they rip or chunk them 'And they will', I would then have to tell them there race night is over for that week! until I can repair the tyre 'That being that I could'. The only way around that is to have two to three sets glued up ready for them, and then that makes the running cost silly. There is nothing to stop someone putting a new set of tyres on every run, and that has been the case for as long as I have been racing! And unless there is a tyre restriction of some sort, people will put new tyres on there cars, in reflection to how deep there pockets are! And that unfortunately is Racing! In any class Toy car or Real.

My car setup for southport, Chadderton, Bury and Ribble is setup within the limits of the cars adjust ability and what the car is designed to do. If I take my 8th rally cross to a blown out bumpy as hell track, and that track is more of 'Truggy Environment' That does not make it right that I then add truggy wish bones driveshafts and wheels to make my car more suitable to the track conditions. It goes against the 'spirit' of Off Road 8th Buggy racing. And the same applies to 1/10th 'Off Road Buggys'. As I also said, It is not just as simple as putting fuel tubing or spaces in the shocks. Many of the racers that race at Ribble also race at other clubs, and do not have two sets of shocks to setup. for those that only have the shocks that are on there cars, they are going to have to keep stripping down the shocks re build them with more oil, every weekend. That is an extra cost on top of what is already an expensive hobby. Yes I tune 'setup' my Buggy to the track conditions, But my Buggy is still 'Off Road' even in an 'OnRoad Environment'. I am not changing the suspension of an 'Off Road car' to an 'On Road car'.

The majority of racers at Ribble now are Buggy racers, and if you talk to most, they all want to race on a track that is more 'Off Road' than on road, That's what the 'FUN' is in Buggy Racing. The best thing about Ribble is that they have got very good at building a track layout that both the on road and off road cars can race on, with just a movement of a barrier. At the end of the day, we are racing buggies! and that is how we should be racing them. We should not be setting them up as touring cars and calling them 'Buggy Class'. Its an off road car NOT an On Road car.

The advancement in electrics 'Boost-Turbo speedo's etc' faster servos more powerful batteries, has not ever been within just one class of racing. the power you get, and how it works is a personal thing, some like turbo some don't! and that applies across all classes, unless it is restricted eg 'Blinky'. As is the case when it comes to tyres, how much power you can get out of your car reflects on how much you are able to spend on the better equipment. Your comment of ' Using boost on speedos isn't at all common in off road because cars typically have more power than grip', well I think you will find it's more Common than you think, I have been using turbo in my buggies since it started as a feature in speedo's, and many many off road racers have. Its just another way of adding speed to your car, in the same way as going from a 3 port rtr engine to a 3 port OS Speed, you buy the amount of power you want in your car! But no matter what or how much power you have in your car, the car is still either Off Road Or On Road.

Yes you are absolutely right when it comes to the fact that the club is about having fun! But, when Arron and Anna ask me why they can't keep up 'xyz' driver all of a sudden, when every week they have good close races with them, I have to tell them, that's because they have now got foam tyres and have limited there cars suspension to be like a touring car. I now have to buy two full sets of shocks and foam tyres for there cars, because if I don't they can't keep up with the same level of drivers that they are. Then they get frustrated and stop having 'Fun'. Everyone wants to win and finish as high up as they can, even the kid that come to race for the first time! Thats why they come to 'Race!' if all they wanted to do was drive there cars around, they can do that anywhere.

andy110m
29-01-2014, 12:24 PM
Mark, as always, great post.

I can't argue with anything at all in paragraph 1, and 5 to a point.

Paragraph 2, We're not using parts from other cars as in your example, its still all B44.2, its just adapted to its racing environment. People change oil many times at race meetings chasing set ups, I don't see a difference.

I know how many spacers to add and remove so its takes minutes to do. Just the same as if you were changing droop or a piston.

The boost in buggies, I thought people just motored up, seems I might be missing a trick so I'll try that but your right in what you say I've never really like the feel of boost.

Good debate so I'll add more when I return but for now would it help you if you thought of it as setting them up as we did in the early 90's before touring car existed!:D Pro-Cats for the Win.

ericd2477
29-01-2014, 12:56 PM
:lol:Hi All, just a few comments from me about the points made so far :-
THE TRACK - The committee has looked at ways of making the track larger and to add an extra width of carpet we would have to restrict the number of racers to about 50. Last week we had 61.
We have had numerous suggestions on how to change the track and we have invited people to assist our Track designer by building features but no one has volunteered. Storage of additional carpet and new features is also an issue because we have a limited space available.

THE TIRES - The committee has always had an open mind on Tires for Buggies and we have left this decision to the MAJORITY of buggy racers. It was a proposal at last years AGM from a buggy driver that we allow foams to be used and it was voted on and passed. If anyone wants to change this they can propose it for the AGM and it can be voted on again.

NUMBERS ON TRACK - We are currently in our peak period as a lot of out door people come in doors and new racers appear with Christmas presents. Our Total number of racers can fluctuate between 25 and 70 !!!
We can reduce the numbers on tack in one of 2 ways :-
1) Restrict overall numbers say 40 Buggies and 16 GT12.
2) Change the Race format to 2 heats and 1 Final with 6 minute heats/finals.

THE COMMITTEE - We do not like to turn anyone away especially youngsters and anyone who has traveled a long way. We do our best but it is a members club and YOU the members make the rules.

spennyy2k
29-01-2014, 01:25 PM
Personally I wouldn't do 6 minute heats due to motor temps and charging times, it would be a better idea to scrap practice instead and add another heat or 2

morpheus2010
29-01-2014, 01:32 PM
Having started at Wellfield, Ribble has managed to continue as a thriving Rc club when quite a few other clubs disappeared. I feel the main reason is they do cater for a broad range of drivers/abilities and maintain a friendly and welcoming venue for all, especially newcomers and youngsters. Quite a high percentage of juniors with mainly dads/mums funding the fun.

Always a balancing act to satisfy everyone but the "serious" racer can go to clubs/regional/national meetings that cater for their racing wants . Ribble do a good job with varying the track to suit on and off road racing and a racing series mixed with fun/practice meetings to balance. Fun/Pleasure is what the members come for week after week.

I've seen racers trash sets of mini pins at a single meeting, foams offer high grip and lower running costs for buggies given they can last a lot longer and as Andy says they are repairable if damaged.

Buggies are in the majority but GT12 has a place with regular attendance and I don't feel it should be pushed to the back so to speak when it comes to any decisions.

As Eric says numbers racing is limited to a maximum, but most nights manage to let all who have attended to race - Pre-booking will help guarantee a place. Pre Race-Practice, Three heats and a Final is the best balance IMHO

It should be said that the efforts of the committee and the volunteers on race control/refreshments (Thank you Ladies :wub) are what keep the wheels turning so we can all enjoy :D

ericd2477
29-01-2014, 01:46 PM
:lol:Practice only happens because most weeks we have a gap between the Track being completed and booking in closing at 7:15. We start racing at 7:30 which is in our experience the earliest practical time to start as people who work need time to get there. So we are into the total number of races that can be held ? Currently we try to run 5 buggy and either 1 or 2 GT12 racing 4 mins each. This give a max Race time of 2hrs 54 minutes. This takes us to 10:30 with extra time for setting up the finals. Bearing in mind we shold be locking up at 10:30 we are already running late. We have looked at this issue time and time again and there are only two answers - Cut Numbers or cut rounds.

adprim
29-01-2014, 02:01 PM
I've just done 5 meeting on 1 set of mini pins, fronts are still only half worn, but rear are done need replacing now but that's mine running quite quick,
What about the damage to the track, people running foams are slamming into the guttering, a lot of people use as a aid to get round,

in my opinion running rubber tyres the car speed = person's ability
but on foams speed is more than some people's ability, but that's how I see it

spennyy2k
29-01-2014, 02:05 PM
No one here is pushing gt12 to the back here this is just something a few buggy racers have been talking about, these areas we are discussing would have no impact on gt12 unless people were to move away and race a buggy instead.

spennyy2k
29-01-2014, 02:12 PM
I.dont see cutting rounds as an option, I wouldn't want to pay £10 for me and connor to race 2 rounds and a final. Things can be streamlined to claw back a few minutes here and there

MattK
29-01-2014, 03:09 PM
Love the open banter :)

From cost point I dont think that you can ever really justify that rubber tyres will be cheaper to run than foams (Agree if your lucks out you can trash a brand new set).

I really agree with both sides of the arguments on this but if it came to voting I personally would go along the lines of keeping foams, raising ride height and having a good time :lol:

andy110m
29-01-2014, 04:47 PM
As Matt said some good discussion around this so all comments welcome. Maybe you've thought of an angle which hasn't been mentioned yet so please get posting. All opinions respected.

The only question I'd throw back in the melting pot is if we keep foams, and to be honest looking at the comments on the threads I posted last night I really think we will, and propose to raise the ride height, what would we raise it too? My car is set to 7mm, with bump stops (just fuel tube on the shafts to stop) at 5mm, and its slightly above drive shafts level. Remember the overall diameter of foams is smaller than rubber so what ride height would we think is acceptable?

Also a few comments. Firstly following on with ride height and the comments I heard from race control about carpet damage. It isn't enough just to drop the ride height and think job done. I think the problem we're seeing is cars are above 5mm at rest but can bottom out in a dynamic situation which causes the damage. From that does it mean we should have a minimum ride height which the car physically can't fall under?

The second comment is about repairing chunked foams. Mark made a good point early most people probably don't have a machine to do it. Fair and valid, but I'll bet most people have a drill, a small piece of wood and some sand paper. When I started racing 12th I didn't have a machine so what most people did was get a bolt the same diameter as the axle, clamp the wheel with a nut and washer and put that in a drill. You can put the drill in a workmate or even get someone to hold it. Then put the sand paper on the wood and true the tyre.

Lastly, this is starting to look like a discussion about the sharp end. We need to ensure it isn't by not worrying about the A final but rather the club as a whole. The chap who commented about GT12 not getting pushed to the back is right, would a larger track suit that class? I don't know the answer, but I think we should try to keep this relevant to all in the hope that as many Friday night competitors contribute as possible. Any rule changes will, directly or indirectly, affect everyone.

corsa148
29-01-2014, 09:21 PM
Well personally I think the club does a great job ribble is about fun an weather it's foams or pins doesn't bother me I have been running both over the last few months. I think it just needs a couple more jumps/rumble strips an this w ould slow drivers down. All this crap talk happens every year round the time of the agm :p:lol::lol::lol:

The Bod
29-01-2014, 09:35 PM
Wow, some great responses which tell me something, people feel passionate about RVRCCC.

I have been racing at Leyland on and off for the last few years and love it. I take it for what it is, a fun club. That is why I have been bring my eldest, so that he can have fun. I like to try to be competitive but with a budget (my car and Olivers) and knowing my own abilities, i know my limits and aim for realistic finals (C or even B).

As others have already stated, the club has a great feel and attracts both new and seasoned racers. The increase in 'regulars' reflects the hard work that all at the club put in (especially Eric and Pete). I think we all race at Leyland with the acceptance that the track is what it is. If we wanted a track built for buggies, with lots of jumps, crossovers, rough surfaces etc designed for buggies, then we should choose a club/track more suited for that. The fact is Leyland is what it is and is a great venue.

Regarding crashing, this is always going to happen. Those in the A and B finals should have no excuses as in most cases they should be able to drive without either causing a smash, or being able to avoid the crash. The loud smashes tend to come from those racers in the C/D finals, who maybe are driving cars too fast for their abilities? This is always going to happen when we get the 'need for speed'. The starters/novices in the lower heats/finals will always break wishbones and the dads/pitmans should just accept it. We all were there when we were kids.

Regarding foams, I have just been converted to foams rather than using minipins. It was purely down to money and not being able to afford new pins on a regular basis. They are nothing new, I raced foams week in week out 20 years ago on carpet. Last Friday my first race was a wow experience. I had forgotten how much extra grip they gave the car. Once i get used to turning in later etc I am sure my lap times will come down. Foams do not make you go faster on the straights, just round the bends/corners. Surely if more people are using foams, racing should be tidier with less cars flipping over the track markers into other cars or drifting wide round bends into other cars. So surely no one should be concerned by the quantity of cars running them.

Regarding carpet/floor damage, as Eric stated on Friday we need to have a minimum ride height to prevent damage after the jumps. Do we have any spare sections of carpet that we can simply place on the landing zone to help reduce damage to the wood?

At the end of the day, i think the way the club operates works extremely well and should continue. If a driver wants more than the club can cater for then there are two options, respect the club for what it is, or, get more competitive buggy racing elsewhere.

A great debate but not everyone can be pleased in a hobby that accepts all abilities on the same playing field.

Great work RVRCCC :thumbsup:

Jon D
29-01-2014, 09:35 PM
Track
I agree with Eric that we can't widen the current race surface by adding another roll of carpet as this wud result in storage and pit issues as we only have limited space so why don't we widen the track sections? The track itself is very tight and very technical y not widen the track and have less in it? Racing wud b more fluid and ther wud b less chance of serious collisions because cars wudnt b traveling in opposite directions 3 or 4 times at high speed as we all no cars fly over the track from time to time and that's wen collisions occur southport indoor is a very similar size to r venue and they don't have no wer near as much of a technical track like we do there's is basic
A straight
A couple of hair pins
A couple of 90' bends
And a few jumps
And that's it u don't get any dirty driving becomes Thers room to overtake all round the track and I think most accidents are caused by ppl trying to get past others on such a tight track obviously accidents do happen but it's rare cos Thers room to adjust properly to take corners and overtake
I think the way the track is designed at the moment is around the mardaves but the club surely makes most of its money thro buggies so y not design the track (width) around a buggy as it's more popular by about 500%? This wudnt affect Mardave races as they hug the barriers all the way round and we can jus lift the jumps out if they don't wanna go over them ??
Tyres
I don't think banning foams is the way to go ppl should b aloud to choose wot ever tyre they want as long as it doesn't damage the carpet I mean after all we are "racing for fun" arnt we?? And to b fair foams don't burn the wood as much as rubber tyres wen the cars come off the track! And foams can't b that bad as race control sell additive ??!!
Foams re for carpet
Rubber tyres are for off-road surfaces
It's not like any1s saying if Buggys can't use foams neither can mardaves are they ?
1 thing I do agree with is ride hieght I think we shuld hav a min height and that this shuld b enforced with cars being scrutinised by race control if they appear to b very low and penalties bein handed out

Lee1972
29-01-2014, 10:00 PM
Not really bothered if we ban foams or not, personally would like to see more track features and at the last AGM we were promised a separate technical area on the track for buggies which has never happened. If your passionate for change then get down to the AGM, raise your proposal and let the members vote.

gaz23
29-01-2014, 10:46 PM
Now thants a proper post, no bollocks just a voice for the buggy masses.

Great job Jon. D

Next time I want a 1000 words of utter knonsense please- must try harder ha

gaz23
29-01-2014, 10:50 PM
Defo buggy rep material there lad, ya got my vote 🐀🐀🐀

The Bod
29-01-2014, 11:04 PM
Defo buggy rep material there lad, ya got my vote 🐀🐀🐀
PMSL
:thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:

andy110m
29-01-2014, 11:15 PM
Just back home and checking oOple. The great and interesting debate rolls on, good to see.

I enjoy reading well written, thoughtful posts and this thread has had many of these although I think The Bod has TQ so far. A great even handed, balanced reflection of where we are. I couldn't disagree with any of his post.

Also Jon makes a good point about Southport and their fairly simple tracks. I must admit their track feels a lot larger than Ribble but they're both based in a sports hall so can't be too different. I'll post in the Southport section and ask, Simon will know.

We could make the track wider but that would mean less track effectively. The lap times aren't the longest now, around 13/14 second average, so if that dropped to a 10 second average would that create more issues?

A lot of people have mentioned ride height, and ensuring its sufficient but what would that be? My car was 7mm at both ends last week. I'm going to experiment this week and raise it to 8mm at the rear and 10mm front. My thinking is surely no one could argue that's too low, especially if I bump stop it at 4mm so it can't bottom out. I'm hoping it'll be better over the jump and hardly lose anything in the infield. We'll see.

Back to topic, Lee you're right, if everyone attends the AGM, it'll certainly be interesting:woot:

MattK
29-01-2014, 11:19 PM
Could just ban additive for buggys. Foams would be great then and everyone would be slower and we can have a drift class.:lol:

It would als put less stress on the drive train, but I think that's just an issue I suffer with. :lol:

Serious suggestion on additive though.

andy110m
29-01-2014, 11:30 PM
Matt on the additive I think after round 1 the mardaves would put down enough that the difference wouldn't be that great.

Also what stops people loading the foams by soaking them during the week. They aren't cheating because they aren't applying additive at the meeting but that's just human nature and it happens at every level. The last 8th on road worlds nearly got cancelled because of legal cheating. In the end I think they got round it by the organisers giving the competitors hand out tyres a few minutes before the start of the heats.

Now we aren't there and this is racing for fun so if we add rules they need to be a benefit. I'm wondering who would enforce them and do you not think that would detract from the easy going nature of the club?

andy110m
30-01-2014, 07:27 AM
Well thanks to Eric at SRCC we've the dimensions of what they use.

Astro size 30metres x 4metres x 3 rolls. Pitting 2x 2mx30m carpet with approx 2m strip of concrete flooring. Track min 2.5m, straight 3m with max 8 cars in heats/finals

For those who haven't been its a great set up at Southport and worth the trip. They race on the Astro and use carpet to cover the pitting area to avoid damage to the floor.

How does that compare to the Ribble track?

spennyy2k
30-01-2014, 08:20 AM
Ribble track is 2m all round I think, tho im sure it narrows at points. The last track had a 2.5m straight if i remember correctly and that would be ideal all round so all we are asking is another 1m of carpet roughly, which I'm sure could be accommodated if people set up the pit area properly. It would also make life easier if the straight went under the rostrum rather than the opposite side of the hall.

MattK
30-01-2014, 11:23 AM
Theres a key point there andy, what ever rules are imposed on tyres or such like there is always a way of cheating, always starts with one person and then spreads to others. :thumbdown:
The same thing would happen I think with a control tyre, even if they are marked in some way, there will always be a work around, then you are into spending loads of cash on tyres.
This is just repeating stuff from earlier now.
I think more features, bigger carpet, higher ride heights etc.. are all god suggestions and hope something can be worked out, but banning foams I dont think is the way forward in my own personal opinion.

On foams front there was only limited intrest in my option to get some cheap foam donunts but I havent ordered yet so if anyone is intrested let me know as will be at the club friday (I am the one with the white Yokomo). :thumbsup:

The Bod
30-01-2014, 11:26 AM
(I am the one with the white Yokomo). :thumbsup:[/QUOTE]

Assume it is fixed now :)

spennyy2k
30-01-2014, 11:58 AM
He is the one with the slow white jokomo

Lee1972
30-01-2014, 12:25 PM
He is the one with the slow white jokomo

:thumbsup:

MattK
30-01-2014, 01:16 PM
Thanks Lee :lol:

Sadly true, must be the foams slowing me down :lol::lol:

Car fixed, destryed both idlers. Car ready to go again.
So in 4 weeks I have broke the diff, idler gears and shock cap. I am glad its a cheap hobby!!
:thumbsup:

ericd2477
30-01-2014, 02:40 PM
Theres a key point there andy, what ever rules are imposed on tyres or such like there is always a way of cheating, always starts with one person and then spreads to others. :thumbdown:
The same thing would happen I think with a control tyre, even if they are marked in some way, there will always be a work around, then you are into spending loads of cash on tyres.
This is just repeating stuff from earlier now.
I think more features, bigger carpet, higher ride heights etc.. are all god suggestions and hope something can be worked out, but banning foams I dont think is the way forward in my own personal opinion.

On foams front there was only limited intrest in my option to get some cheap foam donunts but I havent ordered yet so if anyone is intrested let me know as will be at the club friday (I am the one with the white Yokomo). :thumbsup:

We had a control tire for buggy about 3 years ago and it was not popular with buggy racers. If you want the power of purchase the club might be able to help but only if the Majority of buggy racers can agree what to use.

MattK
30-01-2014, 04:42 PM
Cheers eric.
I will wait until this is all sorted then we can discuss then.
I can keep the guy on ice for the moment.

:lol:

rallymaddaz
30-01-2014, 06:57 PM
Cheers eric.
I will wait until this is all sorted then we can discuss then.
I can keep the guy on ice for the moment.

:lol:

Surely if as Lee states extra track width has already got committee approval and just needs buying, then why not buy a roll of astro turf (deep pile) this would then make foams / rubbers much more even and personal preference would prevail. Also There is no issue with the gt12 layout so they won't need to go onto the astro section.

For me the main things are:

1 very poor driver etiquette
2 track is too narrow ( see note above)
3 we end up with poor track layouts where for instance we have opposing direction straights - and are then afraid to change it because we voted on it.
4 the track pieces are now in really poor condition ( largely due to foams )
5 there is not enough off road sections for the buggies
6 the rostron is a little too low
7 cars are run too low - but if you address point 5 this will take car of itself

I enjoy coming to rvrccc for fun racing and long may it continue - it's run really well and with slight tweaks address my point above it would be even more fun.

But don't lose sight of the fact the lower heats and finals are the young talent of the future, after all the best driver in the country and ex world champ came through a local club racing for fun just like this.

fidspeed
30-01-2014, 07:39 PM
watching this thread with Interest as an outsider

firstly Ribble are to be wholeheartedly praised for operating a thriving club
Remember clubs are only as successful as the hardcore few (normally) that often sacrifice their racing and time for the enjoyment of others don't abuse them too often or you wont have club at all

I have been a member of my local club for almost 20 years and we started with buggies then "wide salooons " and eventually touring cars we also race Friday nights . we have a similar number of racers we have evolved over these years by slow process, what we have found is that racers come and go from juniors to seniors but the club relies on the same few hardcore regulars that turn up almost every week to set up and run race control and then pack away, take memberships and run the clubs finances

We too try to focus on the juniors and novices they are the future , more experienced racers pick and choose which club/meeting they attend to benefit themselves and their desires, juniors often do not have that option

I have seen clubs that start with all good intentions divert from the path from which they set and eventually folded

club nights should be primarily focused on fun for all novice and "pro" alike
no driver is bigger than a club

It is great to see all this interest in the future of Ribble and whatever the outcome at the AGM I hope that everyone pulls together for the future of the club

overall remember its only Toy car Racing

best wishes from an outsider

dave fiddling

andy110m
30-01-2014, 07:57 PM
Good to see some banter entering this, Jokomo, love it!:thumbsup: Mind due I can't say to much, that's exactly what happened to my C4.1 last week at Southport. Two idlers and a diff.

Just a question, I've noticed a few people saying, as Rallymaddaz point 5, foams damage the track markings? I'm not sure I understand that, could someone explain please.

I think this thread is now looking for some conclusions which will probably take the form of proposals for the AGM.

In summary, for me anyway. I think all of us agree the format we have at the moment is successful, the racings enjoyable so only minor tweaking in a few areas could be needed.


The majority of people are in favour of foams.
Think the track design could be improved although appreciate this is difficult given the restrictions in the size of the hall and the storage.
Maybe more off road features would be good provided it didn't detract anything from the youngsters and can be stored.
Are we happy with a 5mm ride height or should it be raised slightly?

I think we've kicked around more that this but these are the area's we keep returning to. I'm looking forward to tomorrow evening, I'll see what an increase in ride height does to my car, it was awesome last week so I'm hoping it's not to different. If anyone wants to have a look how my cars set up please come over and have a chat.

MattK
30-01-2014, 08:15 PM
At least jokomo is better than s**t-worxs :lol:

If you run more ride hight on foams you will get more roll and camber change on the wheels which will basically cone the foam more.
So I found you had to compensate for that in the top link setup of the car.
May just be my car though.

Astro turf section, I never thought of that.
Do you reckon that "as good as grass" stuff would work and be like racing outside in the early 90's.:thumbsup:

andy110m
30-01-2014, 09:22 PM
s**t-worxs:thumbsup:

I've stiffened it up hoping it'll still resist rolling.

Can but try, if its a dog it won't take 10 minutes to put it back.

spennyy2k
30-01-2014, 09:32 PM
s**t-worxs..... Would be better if you spelt it properly, it's sworkz.... Mind you it's still more readable than a previous post

andy110m
30-01-2014, 10:24 PM
[QUOTE=spennyy2k;834377]s**t-worxs..... Would be better if you spelt it properly, it's sworkz....

Steve, it's sworkz.... that doesn't!:D

morpheus2010
31-01-2014, 02:12 PM
Good discussions - Regarding Ride Height issue, Damage to the Carpet is more likely to be caused by cars cartwheeling and screw ends digging in - Shock tower bolts or axle stubs with exposed thread ends for example. The chassis on most if not all cars are flat and to tear a carpet it needs a sharp edge to cut in.

Scrutineering may be helpful - problem is who will do it :confused:

Regarding track layout its easy to criticise, but when members have been asked to suggest layout - little forthcoming. :eh?:

Driver etiquette is a constant issue that pre-race briefing tries to address, safe and considerate driving is the motto that some tend to forget once the red mist of speed takes over, although breaking the car because of hitting the barrier, usually at the end of the long straight is a self imposed penalty ;)

I remember coming home from a meeting in Blackburn cheesed off with some of the demolition derby driving that went on that day, only to watch Formula 1 drivers banging into each other on the tele. :cry: felt better after that :lol:

I like the Juniors Star Chart Series where youngsters get certificates of achievement as their driving skills gain more laps and not just win. Big Thank you to Janice :wub for taking the time to chart their progress.

Over all Ribble must be doing something right to be a successful, well attended club over the years.

andy110m
31-01-2014, 02:48 PM
Brilliant comment about ride height, I'd not even considered it and you're right, its a lot more likely to be a crashing car, with shock tower bolts or something causing damage rather than a car bottoming out.

The only time that wouldn't be the case would be if a screw has worked loose. Maybe we don't have an issue after all?

Again we need to remember, Ribble is a fun club not aimed at top competition. Yes, as Mark said, people go to race but primarily they go to have an enjoyable evening. That follows into what Morpheus says about Janice doing a great job for the kids. I've told Nathan about the certificates he can get, I think he's more excited about them than the actual racing, especially when he understood he didn't have to win to get them, just complete the benchmark number of laps.

I think its a great concept and hope its continued.

Jlc57
03-02-2014, 09:31 PM
Not a driver so no real input to some of the discussion but I do have a few questions, which you may also want to consider when putting any proposals to the AGM:

1. For the fun drivers who will help them with ride height, tyres or any other stipulations we make. Many juniors come with a parent who has no experience of racing and certainly won't have a whole load of RC stuff which many of you guys have collected over time.
2. Who would scrutineer to make sure that the cars are as stipulated?
3. If we restrict the number of drivers in each heat, are people prepared to turn up and not be able to race because we've already filled all the heats?

Janice

rallymaddaz
03-02-2014, 10:30 PM
Not a driver so no real input to some of the discussion but I do have a few questions, which you may also want to consider when putting any proposals to the AGM:

1. For the fun drivers who will help them with ride height, tyres or any other stipulations we make. Many juniors come with a parent who has no experience of racing and certainly won't have a whole load of RC stuff which many of you guys have collected over time.
2. Who would scrutineer to make sure that the cars are as stipulated?
3. If we restrict the number of drivers in each heat, are people prepared to turn up and not be able to race because we've already filled all the heats?

Janice

Janice if you put sufficient jumps on the buggy section of track and use a deep pile AstroTurf for the extra width (which already has committed approval from what I am led to believe ) the ride height and tyres will take care of itself - there would be no need to scrutineer - you could stipulate a guideline of 15mm ride height.

8 in a race is what we run anyway so not sure there is any need to turn people away. Perhaps you could run 10 in the gt12 class due to the smaller scale?

Jlc57
03-02-2014, 11:14 PM
Over the last few weeks we have had 9-10 in buggies due to numbers and we've had 14 gt12 so we would have needed to turn people away.

rallymaddaz
03-02-2014, 11:23 PM
Perhaps make it pre booking only then and have it all set up ready to go during the busy period - track is usually finished by 7ish so you could take half hour or so back there. You could adjust this when the outdoor season starts

andy110m
04-02-2014, 09:06 AM
Morning All,

I've a few points starting with where is this astro going to go? We don't really have the space to extend the track.

The second is beginners could be put off by multi surface and jumps. They want to learn and develop car control to get round the track without crashing. They aren't, at this stage anyway, interested in learning to fly doubles.

Last point, Why would astro mean the end of foams? Foams work reasonably well on astro, a chap at SRCC sometimes runs foams at their outdoor track. All a racer will do is look to see which gives the best lap time. If 80 or 90% of the track is flat carpet, cars will still be at min ride height, very firm and on the best tyre for the majority of the track.

Final last point, I promise. As Janice said, the core of the club want to turn up and race in a fun, family environment. They don't want to worry about conforming to rules and specifications. If I'm wrong and they do, why not enforce the BRCA lipo and motor lists? That way we could turn most people away and ruin the club very quickly because it seems to me that's what this and most of the other ill conceived and self serving suggestions will do.

RVRCCC is a great fun club which works. Tinker with the fringe things if you want, any chance of bottles instead of cans in the tuck shop please and maybe add or reduce 20p to a transponder rental but please guys, lets all realise what this very successful club is about and leave the core framework alone.

rallymaddaz
04-02-2014, 12:59 PM
Morning All,

I've a few points starting with where is this astro going to go? We don't really have the space to extend the track.

The second is beginners could be put off by multi surface and jumps. They want to learn and develop car control to get round the track without crashing. They aren't, at this stage anyway, interested in learning to fly doubles.

Last point, Why would astro mean the end of foams? Foams work reasonably well on astro, a chap at SRCC sometimes runs foams at their outdoor track. All a racer will do is look to see which gives the best lap time. If 80 or 90% of the track is flat carpet, cars will still be at min ride height, very firm and on the best tyre for the majority of the track.

Final last point, I promise. As Janice said, the core of the club want to turn up and race in a fun, family environment. They don't want to worry about conforming to rules and specifications. If I'm wrong and they do, why not enforce the BRCA lipo and motor lists? That way we could turn most people away and ruin the club very quickly because it seems to me that's what this and most of the other ill conceived and self serving suggestions will do.

RVRCCC is a great fun club which works. Tinker with the fringe things if you want, any chance of bottles instead of cans in the tuck shop please and maybe add or reduce 20p to a transponder rental but please guys, lets all realise what this very successful club is about and leave the core framework alone.


Andy,

Your missing the point and continuing to carry on posting on the other thread when you have been asked not to do so - These are very simple rules that you should be able to comply with "Keep the proposals short and to the point and no long discussions" - For clarity this means stop posting on the other thread now youve had your say.

With regards your above post

1) the extra carpet (or as we are suggesting Astro) already has committe approval from last year, so space must not be an issue.
2) The youngsters actually perform better over the jumps - if you paid attention to what happened last year, when I altered the hump back jump they actually loved it and, performed much better, breakages and crashes wherre substantially reduced.
3) Yes foams will work on short pile astro - again read the previous posts where we are suggesting long pile astro and more jumps - You will naturally have to raise ride height then to accomodate the jumps and you will find there is little difference in performace of the two types of tyre then - Oh and for clarity I dont buy the foams are substantially cheeper arguement because as previously said they chunk, you need attitive - its more difficult for the youngsters as, you have to be in the know to be able to buy a set.
4) Most youngsters buy a ready to run kit off the shelf which is usually pre-built to Off Road buggy spec - so there ride height will be more in tune with the suitibly altered track. - If they want to learn in a on road flat track environment then buy a GT12 not a Off Road Buggy (The clues in the name)
5) with regards Fringe things - I consider the above to be Fringe things without altering the make up of the club - we all love the family atmosphere of the club and the excellent manner in which its run
6) Who mentioned running to BRCA Rules - again read the proposals - the worst it means is that someone checks the ride heights and tyre type, which will only take checking for a month or so before all you will need are spot checks.

Now I suggest we leave it there for others to have there say - you might even find some others agree with you and dont want any change - but carrying on forcing your point is loosing your argument credibility.

andy110m
04-02-2014, 04:12 PM
I must have missed something on the other thread. Can't find where I was asked not to post?

Never mind. On this thread we've got 4 pages of great discussion, thoughts and ideas, with for's and againsts being aired.

I can't see any problem with that.

The reason I keep posting is to ask how these ideas are going to work. Its no good to simply say I think we should have this and offer no suggestion as to why or how.

Astro for example. I've asked numerous times, with the pits packed and can't be relocated or pushed back where is this extra track going to go? How much of the track will this affect? Where will it be stored because trust me, long pile astro is very heavy. If it was approved at last years meeting why hasn't it happened. I suspect because its in the file marked "to hard to do". We have a growing GT12 section, I assume they aren't going to like having a smaller track?

All manor of things have been mentioned, Jumps, who'll build them and where will we put them? How will the tracks be altered to ensure visibility around the jumps. Again how will the mardaves cope and if they're going to be removed every time who's going to do it.

So if we're going to post suggestions is it to much to ask for some explanation?

NickC
04-02-2014, 04:16 PM
I ran for the first time in three years last week and had a brilliant time, the club is run very well and also very friendly so hats off to you all for that I also had loads of fun on rubber tyres so I will stick with them for now. Iv always hated foams for buggy's but that is just my opinion.

As for the track if you could gain more room then it would be great but for the room there was on Friday I think it was pretty damn good. Bigger tracks with jumps and off road sections are all well and good but it has to be set up and put away afterwards so its a trade off.

The main thing is from my point of view is that it remains good fun racing so if any changes are to be made i would say nothing major.

andy110m
04-02-2014, 05:07 PM
I've re-read your post and I can't do as you suggest and leave it. Sorry.

1) the extra carpet (or as we are suggesting Astro) already has committe approval from last year, so space must not be an issue.
Already answered really. I've known this committee for a long time and if it hasn't happened its because they've tried and it isn't possible without to much disruption.

2) The youngsters actually perform better over the jumps - if you paid attention to what happened last year, when I altered the hump back jump they actually loved it and, performed much better, breakages and crashes wherre substantially reduced.
Youngsters love jumps, we agree. But I keep marshalling those jumps and most of the crashes happen when they try to get over fairly simple jumps. We don't need to make it harder by adding more. When you altered the jump you took away the steep attack angle which reduced the breakages, so well done for that, but it didn't reduce the number of rolls, bobbles and crashes that all require marshalling.

3) Yes foams will work on short pile astro - again read the previous posts where we are suggesting long pile astro and more jumps - You will naturally have to raise ride height then to accomodate the jumps and you will find there is little difference in performace of the two types of tyre then - Oh and for clarity I dont buy the foams are substantially cheeper arguement because as previously said they chunk, you need attitive - its more difficult for the youngsters as, you have to be in the know to be able to buy a set.
Asked and answered. To be honest I don't like foams either but they perform great and save a fortune. Foams can be repaired if you chunk them and an £8 bottle of additive will last 12 months. Many people have posted where to get them so I don't understand "being in the know". Add up a set of wheels, inserts and tyres each meeting. Then you'll see the savings.

4) Most youngsters buy a ready to run kit off the shelf which is usually pre-built to Off Road buggy spec - so there ride height will be more in tune with the suitibly altered track. - If they want to learn in a on road flat track environment then buy a GT12 not a Off Road Buggy (The clues in the name)
I agree with your first comment but so what. A beginner going to be roughly the same no matter what they drive and the state of the set up, within reason. Also they are learning in an on road environment. The reason they don't buy a GT12 is because they want to play with them outside. I understand that, who doesn't love taking a 2wd buggy on some waste ground doing some donuts:thumbsup:

The off road buggy comment I wanted to answer separately with a thought about this years North West BRCA regionals. Two 8th tracks are on the calendar and some people seem not to be happy saying the tracks are to rough for 10th scale. Well its off road so what's the problem? Maybe that's too off road? My view is these are racing buggies and provided we're racing, I'm happy.


5) with regards Fringe things - I consider the above to be Fringe things without altering the make up of the club - we all love the family atmosphere of the club and the excellent manner in which its run
We're together in our views of the atmosphere of the club and the running of it. Where we come a part is our views on what's a major or minor change. The track, introducing checks and changing what people buy, or how much they buy is heading towards major.

6) Who mentioned running to BRCA Rules - again read the proposals - the worst it means is that someone checks the ride heights and tyre type, which will only take checking for a month or so before all you will need are spot checks.
The BRCA rules was a tongue in cheek comment. I agree with you about needing to enforce rules if we have them. What I'm concerned about is how far does that end up going.

The point of this thread is to look at what we have and ideas for change. All things need to change but not for the sake of it. My posts are only one mans opinion so aren't right or wrong, same as anything posted on here. If you agree, say why. Same if you disagree or if you've got ideas which haven't been posted.

All this is coming down to one thing, the AGM. I've been to AGM's before. Ones for Ribble and other clubs, the format is always the same. A full agenda with not enough time so what happens is a brief 5 minute discussion then a vote. So the unofficial place for debates and airing views is forums. This forum thread in fact so I apologise for bringing that to the other thread but lets carry on thinking and posting.

MattK
04-02-2014, 05:08 PM
[QUOTE=rallymaddaz;835560]Andy,

Oh and for clarity I dont buy the foams are substantially cheeper arguement because as previously said they chunk, you need attitive - its more difficult for the youngsters as, you have to be in the know to be able to buy a set.
QUOTE]

Really!!!! I have been back racing since this time last year and am on my SECOND set of foams! so thats a years racing for approx 30 quid!
If we are being picky add 8 quid for the additive. Still cheaper than pins any day of the week. And as far as being in the know to buy them I am sure that small company called shumacher racing may sell them. Also people are putting additive on rubber tyres so that cost will stay the same.

I am not trying to put down peoples opinion but the above comment just seems untrue.

Just to also clarify I havent trued up the foams before using them and for my first set didnt remove the belts from the wheel either. The club are also working on making foams more readily avaliable to club racers and I am sure the guy from ross models would be happy to sort people out with a set if asked.

Just a thought :)

I do understand why some people want to get rid of foams but I am not convinced it will make racing any better.

rallymaddaz
04-02-2014, 07:34 PM
[QUOTE=rallymaddaz;835560]Andy,

Oh and for clarity I dont buy the foams are substantially cheeper arguement because as previously said they chunk, you need attitive - its more difficult for the youngsters as, you have to be in the know to be able to buy a set.
QUOTE]

Really!!!! I have been back racing since this time last year and am on my SECOND set of foams! so thats a years racing for approx 30 quid!
If we are being picky add 8 quid for the additive. Still cheaper than pins any day of the week. And as far as being in the know to buy them I am sure that small company called shumacher racing may sell them. Also people are putting additive on rubber tyres so that cost will stay the same.

I am not trying to put down peoples opinion but the above comment just seems untrue.

Just to also clarify I havent trued up the foams before using them and for my first set didnt remove the belts from the wheel either. The club are also working on making foams more readily avaliable to club racers and I am sure the guy from ross models would be happy to sort people out with a set if asked.

Just a thought :)

I do understand why some people want to get rid of foams but I am not convinced it will make racing any better.


Matt

You missed at least three months worth of racing last year - I'm on my forth set of foams since June last year and I don't go all that often - the point is you can't buy a set off the shelf ready to run as per the rubber tyres therefore you are disadvantaging those that

1) don't know where to get the foams from
2) don't know how to prepare there wheels to take them
3) don't have the facility to install them


How is that racing for fun and fair for all - don't get me wrong I like the feel of driving on foams but it's not equal for all and as such should be reviewed.

Chris has used one set of rubber tyres on his daughters car since august and they are still going strong.

Oh and out of interest I've used both yellow and blue pins and providing the tarp is not in the course there is no difference in lap time but a huge difference in wear rate.

spennyy2k
04-02-2014, 07:44 PM
i think this is getting a little bit distorted and largely by one person, i wont name names but its andy :D, all people have been asking for is a more off road enviroment for lack of a better word. There is room for a bit of extra track and i will discuss this with the committee hopfully on friday night rather than adding another subject on here to get moaned about. as far as extra features go and building them i have already said to eric im more than happy to get stuck in and help out. At the end of the day people want to race off road cars on an off road track at their local club not at another club on another day .... oh im probably on my 10th set of foams in under a year

MattK
04-02-2014, 08:15 PM
I did miss some racing but still did about 9months on one set, but was 2wd and they were kamtec foams not contact so maybe a difference there.
It does seem to me that the top racers in the club (so me defiantly not included) don't want foams. So would it not be better for those to run pins rather than banning foams? Most people will copy the top racers anyway. That way there will be no issue those that don't like foams will be pure racing off road cars and those that do can carry on.
I like the other ideas people are suggesting, but a ban on foams is not a good idea, if they are that bad and expensive and not much different to pins you don't need to run them.
If we ban foams there will be something else that creates a problem instead like wing size or motor power or type of deodorant you wear.:D

There will always be something! Fact.:lol:

andy110m
04-02-2014, 08:18 PM
Thanks Steve, its good to be credited with provoking creativity and ideas:D

Foams, love em or hate em, Rally makes a good point about mounting a set first time. Thinking back to when I first did it, aged 12, I got glue everywhere. All over my bedroom carpet, my parents went booloo.

Anyway to the point. If anyone wants some advice how to mount foams, plenty of people at the club have this knowledge, the mardave guys for sure, all you have to do is ask. Anyone can come and ask me, I'll show you. If you're running 12mm hex or AE wheels and ask me in advance, I'll bring my truer.

Andy-j.smith6
04-02-2014, 08:20 PM
[/QUOTE]At the end of the day, i think the way the club operates works extremely well and should continue. If a driver wants more than the club can cater for then there are two options, respect the club for what it is, or, get more competitive buggy racing elsewhere.

A great debate but not everyone can be pleased in a hobby that accepts all abilities on the same playing field.

Great work RVRCCC :thumbsup:[/QUOTE]

Think this sums it up very well for me.

The club has regulars who have come for years, is great at encouaging youngsters, is very friendly and one of our biggest problems is the distinct possibility of having to turn racers away! It must be doing something very right.

Not saying we shouldn't look for improvements, but I just hope we get things in context:)

Andy-j.smith6
04-02-2014, 08:31 PM
Sorry couldn't resist, although i recognise I risk extending the debate:yawn:

I wasn't too happy when the switch to foams happened. I held out as long as possible, but succumbed in the end. I now have very mixed feelings about the thought of being forced to go back to pins. I also honestly found it very easy to buy them once I found out what they were called.

My own experience has been they have really saved me a lot of money. Ran the first set on the b44 since foams kicked off. Whats that, nearly a year? I only swapped them last week. Only used one additive stick in that time too. Never chunked or had to repair (touch wood).

Anyway, just thought i would share my experience.

tinnylad
04-02-2014, 10:17 PM
Not sure what is happening to your foams but Im on my original sets on both my 2wd & 4wd buggies which can be used upto 3 times a week, and have been for the last 2 years. If it was decided to ban the use of foams then unfortunately this would be the last winter we race here, it would just be to expensive for tyres on top of the fuel costs.
Things seem good at the club! No point rocking the boat just for the sake of it. Unless it was for wider lanes lol :thumbsup:

MattK
04-02-2014, 10:20 PM
What about mardave full spikes as a control tyre.:thumbsup:

andy110m
05-02-2014, 09:06 AM
Rally asked me a question, and a valid one, in the other thread.

When I didn't want to buy tyres every week for Ribble, what did I do at the events I did race at?

The answer is I bought tyres. However, I see a difference in buying tyres to race at Chadderton and Worksop which are large, monthly events and buying a set of tyres every week at Ribble just to stay competitive with your mates.

On the other weeks I raced 8th Nitro at either of the three great tracks we've got fairly locally or at the regionals. At these events I hardly ever bought tyres. It sounds daft but 8th cars will get 3 - 4 meeting out of a set of mini spikes. If its really warm and dry, we'll run pins and get 2 - 3 meetings. Granted they cost £11 a pair rather than £7-8.

I've said this to a few people, I think Nitro, once you've bought into it, is cheaper to run week in week out than 10th. I'm sure they think I've been sniffing the fumes though:D.

Getting back to topic, Rally made a great last comment that I fully support. Any changes must suit the majority. We all need to consider that and not propose change thinking only from our own view point.

I'm happy to concede I could be wrong, I don't think I am because look at the success the club is enjoying. But the AGM results will tell us either way.:thumbsup:

ericd2477
05-02-2014, 10:32 AM
:thumbsup:Matt have you been sniffing fumes ?

MattK
05-02-2014, 11:09 AM
The smell of nitro fuel gets me up in the morning :lol:

ericd2477
05-02-2014, 01:37 PM
The smell of nitro fuel gets me up in the morning :lol:
:thumbsup:Thought so .
But on a more serious point , my personal opinion on the Foams or No foams decision - I think it is too big an issue for a few people at the AGM to make this decision. I will be proposing at tonight's Committee meeting that we give the facts to all the Buggy drivers and then take a pole of them all.

morpheus2010
05-02-2014, 03:24 PM
:thumbsup:Thought so .
But on a more serious point , my personal opinion on the Foams or No foams decision - I think it is too big an issue for a few people at the AGM to make this decision. I will be proposing at tonight's Committee meeting that we give the facts to all the Buggy drivers and then take a pole of them all.

Sensible suggestion there Eric :thumbsup: Could create ballot papers that have yes/no options to be returned at a meeting.

Happy to print them to be handed out. I like the idea of a Club newsletter e-mailed to registered members. Quarterly ? and/or news notices.

I'm happy with the current layout series, change of track in mid series rather than every week - gives slower racers time to learn track foibles. :blush:

Practicality of any changes have to be a factor i.e. bigger track, more jumps, Astro turf, minimum ride height etc. I've seen two clubs in the last two years that catered for big jumps, Table Top etc struggle to get the numbers.

Ribble numbers show that in general terms regular racers are okay with the current operation.

andy110m
09-02-2014, 08:04 PM
Seems all the good discussion is now to bed waiting for the AGM on the 10th. I'm looking forward to that, especially as the venue is a pub!

I've got a cunning plan to invite the missus out for a drink so she can drive home:D

Anyway something else to throw about, Lee has just explained the rules around points, an extra three for TQ, two for second and one for third.

I really don't get that because I've always thought qualifying is against the clock and rewarded by grid position. Awarding points turns each heat into a race.:confused:

As I say I've only just noticed this. Could it be the reason many people have voiced concern over driver etiquette? Just a thought and maybe another for the AGM?

Rob Scott
13-02-2014, 06:04 PM
why not just run, any car, any tyre, no rules? Making things more level for all competitors makes it boring, plus, no one is ever really on a level playing field regarding driver skill, amount of money spent, latest car, skill in building/setting up a car.

Chuck touring cars in with buggies, any tyre you want, slap some more jumps/rough sections in there? People then set up their cars to suit the track.

At the end of they day they are toy cars, running indoors on carpet... not exactly true scale replicas of real cars, running on real world surfaces. :lol:

madmax
13-02-2014, 10:02 PM
Hello

I am not a member but am known at the club my name is Lee Chorley

I am a member of southport and occasionally race at ribble,

all the committee at ribble in my opinion do an excellent job in running the club. when I do race at ribble I don't care if im last / first whatever I just like the atmosphere, when I have been their and not raced I have helped the younger drivers with setups to improve their driving as they are the future of this sport, whether you are running rubber or foams it shouldn't matter, the people who go to race go to win and the people who go for fun are their for a good night.

by putting restriction / control tyres in place it will only turn people away.
(like the dirt hawgs) as long as the young kids are kept safe and the cars don't damage the track just keep it going,