PDA

View Full Version : just wondered cougar sv who is and what.


purplenut
10-02-2010, 10:44 AM
Thought i would just find out who&how many people are ordering the sv and witch model.
Ive pre ordered mine just now as i dont have much time i did think about the pre assemble kit,but then thought ive always built my cougars so sod it i will make time.
I ve ordered the cf version just had to,from mk models price drop already.:thumbsup:
Leon

frogger
10-02-2010, 10:51 AM
I ordered the CF Pro kit version. Can't wait, thinking of adding a SX2 to that as well :thumbsup:

purplenut
10-02-2010, 11:05 AM
Well if i sell my trf501 i will also,love shuy gear:thumbsup:
The sv will look great with my other cougar collection.

bigred5765
10-02-2010, 11:07 AM
both new cars are on my to do list hope they arrvie soon,cfpro cougar and the full fat catsx2,

DCM
10-02-2010, 11:58 AM
SV S1

bigred5765
10-02-2010, 12:11 PM
and heres your lovely s1 shocks dcm, :confused:

purplenut
10-02-2010, 12:12 PM
i was about to say that lol,£80 for the shocks hhhmm cf one got to be.

mikeyscott
10-02-2010, 12:17 PM
I've pre ordered the K111 kit, which is the CF non built one. Had some really bad build issues with my last pre built Cat SX PB.

Haven't decided whether I'm looking my Cat SX for an SX2. Will prob just order the big bore shocks and sell the Losi shocks that are on my Cat SX at the moment.

My Cat SX is already pretty up to date with the LIPO stiff chassis, alloy mounts and so on. never had a prob with the slipper with RW spurs.

DCM
10-02-2010, 12:30 PM
and heres your lovely s1 shocks dcm, :confused:

not to bothered to be fair....

mes
10-02-2010, 05:58 PM
I'll probably get the carbon kit unless it turns out too pricey hereabouts, in which case I will not buy the SV at all; I've got already a car with crappy shocks...

Alex H
10-02-2010, 06:18 PM
Schumacher should have released the 2wd first and then a 4wd. Thanks to the arrival of the Cougar the Cat has gained great interest even in Sweden. Have not even seen a Cat in real life and now suddenly I know of at least 4 people who is going to buy it due to the Cougar. Me as well:thumbsup:.

Have ordered and paid for the Pro kit and the SX2 too. Down payment so far;)

Danosborne6661
10-02-2010, 06:30 PM
Preordered the Cougar SV carbon shiney shine one :)
It would be rude not to really!

Darren Boyle
10-02-2010, 07:03 PM
All of our pre-orders so far are heavily waited in favour of the PRO as opposed to the S1 (by over 3 to 1) and EVERYONE (baring 1 person) with us has ordered a kit and not a pre-built "lazy mans" car :thumbsup:

mikeyscott
10-02-2010, 07:08 PM
All of our pre-orders so far are heavily waited in favour of the PRO as opposed to the S1 (by over 3 to 1) and EVERYONE (baring 1 person) with us has ordered a kit and not a pre-built "lazy mans" car :thumbsup:

Glad people are opting for the kit as the pre built quality on the Cat last time was rubbish

mes
10-02-2010, 08:02 PM
Why pay more for less fun?! :confused:

8rad
10-02-2010, 08:18 PM
Is the S1 really gonna come with those shocks? The design of those shocks has not changed since 1991. Way to take a cutting edge buggy and make it sucky!:thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:

mikeyscott
10-02-2010, 08:22 PM
i thought it would have come with the original cat SX shocks

Darren Boyle
10-02-2010, 11:12 PM
Guys, they do have to get it down to he "S1" price somehow though.... Just changing Carbon to S1 and removing some of the fancy diff bits is never going to save them the £80 differance that there is between the two specs.

The S1 is supposed to be the "budget man's" car (or as I think the Schumcher press release read) for the "racers with an eye on cost". Just because the shocks are not big bore and just becuse they are not threaded does NOT make then bad! For most club racers they will be MORE than adequate!!!

On the cheaper B-Max from Yokomo the cheap kit comes with plastic shocks to save money (just thank god that Schuey did not make them plastic too, there would be uproar!! LOL)

purplenut
10-02-2010, 11:15 PM
I think the link about the relase of both cars together is right.
I my self is will to sell the wife and all 4 kids to get a sv,only joking if she is reading this lol,but as soon as the sx2 was launched i was well i want that to,i think they have been clever to do this BUT i wish they had NOT.
God dam schumacher:thumbsup:

Tom3012
10-02-2010, 11:18 PM
Mines pre-ordered, the dogs nuts kit version, got it quite cheap too:thumbsup:

DCM
10-02-2010, 11:20 PM
Guys, they do have to get it down to he "S1" price somehow though.... Just changing Carbon to S1 and removing some of the fancy diff bits is never going to save them the £80 differance that there is between the two specs.

The S1 is supposed to be the "budget man's" car (or as I think the Schumcher press release read) for the "racers with an eye on cost". Just because the shocks are not big bore and just becuse they are not threaded does NOT make then bad! For most club racers they will be MORE than adequate!!!

On the cheaper B-Max from Yokomo the cheap kit comes with plastic shocks to save money (just thank god that Schuey did not make them plastic too, there would be uproar!! LOL)

For once, I mostly agree, I also think that Schumacher know the Pro kit will sell more, and when you actually add up the cost difference, as don't forget, although Big Bores cost £80 (apparently), the kit shocks also cost, I don't expect to see Titanium turnbuckles either, no Carbon will save lots too.

purplenut
10-02-2010, 11:21 PM
How bloody cheep if more than me i will throw all toys out of pram lol:thumbsup:

Darren Boyle
10-02-2010, 11:24 PM
For once, I mostly agree Wow! :woot::wub :thumbsup: LOL

DCM
10-02-2010, 11:25 PM
I did say mostly, can't go breaking tradition!! :lol:

Darren Boyle
10-02-2010, 11:26 PM
How bloody cheep if more than me i will throw all toys out of pram lol:thumbsup:
It will be VERY interesting to see if all of the "cheap" shops get the stock they are hoping for when it is released...... :o

Darren Boyle
10-02-2010, 11:30 PM
I did say mostly, can't go breaking tradition!! :lol: If the forum wasnt full of characters with there own opinion it would be a very dull place indeed......

I have all the time in the world for a person with their own piece of mind as long as their discussion, views and points are well constructed, thought out and I guess in a readable language, unlike some of the random text speak and poor punctuation we see all too often on here nowadays....... :(

purplenut
10-02-2010, 11:33 PM
I take it thats not at me?.:cry:

Darren Boyle
10-02-2010, 11:43 PM
No not at all, aimed at people "past" more than anything who seem to have been escorted out of the back door by Jimmy never to return :thumbsup:

There are still a few around though and lots of silly threads full of bickering too much too though :(....

purplenut
10-02-2010, 11:44 PM
No not at all, aimed at people "past" more than anything who seem to have been escorted out of the back door by Jimmy never to return :thumbsup:

There are still a few around though and lots of silly threads full of bickering too much too though :(....
I thought as much:thumbsup:

ian h
10-02-2010, 11:48 PM
K111 CF pro all the way for me, may consider an sx2 as well!!!!!!!:woot:

8rad
11-02-2010, 02:44 AM
Guys, they do have to get it down to he "S1" price somehow though.... Just changing Carbon to S1 and removing some of the fancy diff bits is never going to save them the £80 differance that there is between the two specs.

The S1 is supposed to be the "budget man's" car (or as I think the Schumcher press release read) for the "racers with an eye on cost". Just because the shocks are not big bore and just becuse they are not threaded does NOT make then bad! For most club racers they will be MORE than adequate!!!


Point taken DMS. Correct me if I am wrong but does the CAT S1 not come with the same shocks as CAT SX? The fact remains that those shocks were designed twenty years ago. There is virtually no difference between those and the ones on my JRX2. It would have been easy for Schumacher to cut costs without eliminating one of the most appealing aspects of the Cougar SV, THE WICKED COOL SHOCKS! For example, they could have included the shocks with steel shafts instead of Ti and used plastic shock caps in place of the shiny purple bits. There are lots of other places they could have cut costs.

I am just bitter because I was going to buy the S1 and now I am not so sure.:confused:

DCM
11-02-2010, 07:16 AM
The only difference really, between the shocks on a B2 and a B4, is that the B4 ones are threaded... now, the B2 is going back some...... It would of been nice to of seen them as plain big bore ones, not threaded, but hey, for the most of us, really, what are you wanting the big bores for, as I am sure that it, in the end, won't change my finishing position in my racing!!

pro4nut
11-02-2010, 08:19 AM
Point taken DMS. Correct me if I am wrong but does the CAT S1 not come with the same shocks as CAT SX? The fact remains that those shocks were designed twenty years ago. There is virtually no difference between those and the ones on my JRX2. It would have been easy for Schumacher to cut costs without eliminating one of the most appealing aspects of the Cougar SV, THE WICKED COOL SHOCKS! For example, they could have included the shocks with steel shafts instead of Ti and used plastic shock caps in place of the shiny purple bits. There are lots of other places they could have cut costs.

I am just bitter because I was going to buy the S1 and now I am not so sure.:confused:

But plastics will only save money if they have the moulds already. Shock parts as you mention would have added a production cost not reduced it, if you look at the spring cups they are the same as the sx?
Consider that plastic parts only become cost effective once a volume target is met. This is why lots of the cars out there have common components from older models in a manufacturers range.

I don't believe any real pictures of the s1 have appeared yet, so the actual appearance of the shocks is only speculation.

mes
11-02-2010, 10:06 AM
In the German forums, a team driver mentioned the "old" shocks; for me it sounds to be the ones I had on my Cougar 2.

Not taking into account the higher production costs, I'd prefer threaded plastic shocks over unthreaded metal ones.
If the S1 featured the CAT SX shocks, Schumacher would probably less CF kits, but more Cougar SVs in total...

Anyway, I'm set on getting an SV with threaded shocks! :p

Cooper
11-02-2010, 10:15 AM
you don't HAVE to use (old) schumacher shocks :-)

Tamiya, losi, anything you've got lying around from your previous 2wd.

Darren Boyle
11-02-2010, 11:45 AM
But plastics will only save money if they have the moulds already. Shock parts as you mention would have added a production cost not reduced it, if you look at the spring cups they are the same as the sx?
Consider that plastic parts only become cost effective once a volume target is met. This is why lots of the cars out there have common components from older models in a manufacturers range.

I don't believe any real pictures of the s1 have appeared yet, so the actual appearance of the shocks is only speculation.

What Wayne says is spot on, any "alternative spec" part (including plastic shocks) would ONLY be chaeper of thery already have it tooled up from previuos use, if it needed a new tool making it would not be any cheper for them.

Schumacher have confirmed to those of us who have spoke to them that the S1 will use the "old" style shocks that are used on current models like their nitro recreational vehicles

mark christopher
11-02-2010, 12:48 PM
the actual appearance of the shocks is only speculation.


not true

check the parts listing for the spare for couger sv, then read darrens post above

http://www.racing-cars.com/sp/category/New_Cars_and_Parts/subcategory/Cougar_SV/templateid/12/searchbox7/Shock_Absorbers.html

eichkay
11-02-2010, 02:34 PM
Ive ordered the Pro CF version in kit version of course...

just wondering what springs come with the bigbores and what else to order as spares..

purplenut
11-02-2010, 05:28 PM
Ive ordered the Pro CF version in kit version of course...

just wondering what springs come with the bigbores and what else to order as spares..
Iam glad i ordered the kit one now as it sounds like made up versions have not been to good?.
Is it mid march yet.:thumbsup:

8rad
12-02-2010, 02:15 PM
But plastics will only save money if they have the moulds already. Shock parts as you mention would have added a production cost not reduced it, if you look at the spring cups they are the same as the sx?
Consider that plastic parts only become cost effective once a volume target is met. This is why lots of the cars out there have common components from older models in a manufacturers range.


By that logic how would any manufacturer be able to produce new kits with 90% new parts and expect to turn a profit? Besides, with the CAT SX2(big bore shocks) replacing the SX on store shelves it would have been cost effective to put the SX threaded shocks on the Cougar S1 because the tooling is already in place. It really does not matter to me because I have a spare set of SX threaded shocks I can use if I choose to get the S1.

I am just being devils advocate because I am enjoying this discussion.:D

Alfonzo
12-02-2010, 02:32 PM
By that logic how would any manufacturer be able to produce new kits with 90% new parts and expect to turn a profit? Besides, with the CAT SX2(big bore shocks) replacing the SX on store shelves it would have been cost effective to put the SX threaded shocks on the Cougar S1 because the tooling is already in place. It really does not matter to me because I have a spare set of SX threaded shocks I can use if I choose to get the S1.

I am just being devils advocate because I am enjoying this discussion.:D

I can think of at least three manufacturers that don't exist anymore, so turning a profit would appear quite tricky in this business. And who's surprised at that.

T4miy4 Guy
12-02-2010, 04:15 PM
If the forum wasnt full of characters with there own opinion it would be a very dull place indeed......

I have all the time in the world for a person with their own piece of mind as long as their discussion, views and points are well constructed, thought out and I guess in a readable language, unlike some of the random text speak and poor punctuation we see all too often on here nowadays....... :(

What Wayne says is spot on, any "alternative spec" part (including plastic shocks) would ONLY be chaeper of thery already have it tooled up from previuos use, if it needed a new tool making it would not be any cheper for them.

Schumacher have confirmed to those of us who have spoke to them that the S1 will use the "old" style shocks that are used on current models like their nitro recreational vehicles

Just had too :p

Andy

Darren Boyle
12-02-2010, 04:59 PM
:eh?: Hey that post was at nearly 2am..... LOL

mes
12-02-2010, 05:29 PM
:thumbsup:

pro4nut
12-02-2010, 05:34 PM
By that logic how would any manufacturer be able to produce new kits with 90% new parts and expect to turn a profit? Besides, with the CAT SX2(big bore shocks) replacing the SX on store shelves it would have been cost effective to put the SX threaded shocks on the Cougar S1 because the tooling is already in place. It really does not matter to me because I have a spare set of SX threaded shocks I can use if I choose to get the S1.

I am just being devils advocate because I am enjoying this discussion.:D

Enjoying it as well!

Volume of production changes the efective cost of production. Going back years i worked for a small uk company making models, now the tooling cost for making a kit in plastic at that time was £10k and the price at pos for the kit was £20. We needed to sell 500 kits to pay for the mould but that assumes a 100% profit. Actual business profit margin was 10% and we at the time were a manufacturer retailer so we didn't have to pay someone else to sell our goods.
So we actually needed to sell 5000 units to cover the initial tooling cost.
Often we would manufacture a new kit which actuallly used another model as its base and had cast components to make it into something else. Then the only start up cost was new packaging and tooling for white metal casting at £200 a mould.

The tooling is in place for the existing shocks however these shocks have more parts and more operations required in machining increasing cost of manufacture = more expensive than using 'the old school' shocks.
Also, and i could be wrong the big bores are included with both versions of the sx2, so the shocks on the current sx may well now be out of production so little tooling advantage would be gained.

Thats enough for me

toppers3933
23-02-2010, 10:44 PM
pro cf kit ordered today. how excited am i. it looks sweet.:thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:

madwestmo
24-02-2010, 10:40 AM
Do you get wheels but no tyres with the pro kit ? Its a bit unclear on the website

Thankyou !

Darren Boyle
24-02-2010, 12:08 PM
I have just spoken with Schumacher who have confirmed that NO the Cougars do NOT come with tyres in the kits.

madwestmo
24-02-2010, 12:20 PM
just a set of rims ?

mikeyscott
24-02-2010, 12:24 PM
Doesn't bother me as I think most people end up bolting on the tyres they need.

When I got my Cat SX I bolted on some worn tyres. B4 and XXCR didn't even look at the kit tyres.

madwestmo
24-02-2010, 12:27 PM
yeh but i wasnt asking about tyres , i was wondering if the kit will come with a bare set of rims for you to put whichever set of tyres on you wish ?

Darren Boyle
24-02-2010, 12:27 PM
Doesn't bother me as I think most people end up bolting on the tyres they need.

When I got my Cat SX I bolted on some worn tyres. B4 and XXCR didn't even look at the kit tyres.

Exactly, so why bother to include expensive tyres in akit that will never suit everyone.....

Our understanding is that the Cougar will include the wheels.......

madwestmo
24-02-2010, 12:29 PM
thats good them including wheels as everyone can use these

mikeyscott
24-02-2010, 12:48 PM
B4 rims at the ready

B4 Sloth
24-02-2010, 02:34 PM
I emailed them last week,

no to tyres, yes to wheels.

Shame they could not have included a set of yellows really.

mikeyscott
24-02-2010, 03:33 PM
I emailed them last week,

no to tyres, yes to wheels.

Shame they could not have included a set of yellows really.

Problem is they are trying to cater for all markets and I think the no tyres option is better.