PDA

View Full Version : I'm super discouraged!!!


moth898
20-02-2010, 09:52 PM
I raced my cat sx today for the first time and have to say I have my doubts about this car, as bad as that is to say!!!!

I was racing on a dirt track

In practice a harmless slide at low speed on my rear wheel resulted in a broken hub....a couple of high jump landings resulted in two broken arms(both broken at the pivot pin) and two bent aluminum pivot blocks(both left front)

I am by no means a expert racer but I have been mucking around in the hobby for 20 years and have never experienced anything like this. To have broken different parts would have been understandable, but to have the same part break in the same way from landing a jump clean stinks!!!

The car bottoms out in a thud all the time, I know what you will say, put stiffer springs. I did, didn't help.

I know Shumacher has softer arms and plastic pivot blocks as option parts, will changing them help or is this kind of breaking normal. My question is this, what do I have to change to make this buggy last like a 500 dollar buggy should?

mikeyscott
20-02-2010, 10:06 PM
How big are the jumps and what oil are you using etc.

Broken v little on my Cat SX so far. Had it since June last year.

Any big bolders on the track?

bigred5765
20-02-2010, 10:10 PM
was it very cold?? plastic gets brittle when its cold, having said that we have never had problems like that, and we have tested are old car big time.

moth898
20-02-2010, 10:34 PM
No bolders, the jumps give about 2 feet of air.

I'm using 40 weight oil and lellow spings. I though ti might have to do with the lipo being on the left, because every time I corrected my car with the throttle the car tilted left mid air

I'll post a picture of the track

MikePimlott
20-02-2010, 10:53 PM
Have you done the droop mods with longer shock bottom ends ?

A bit more droop would aid landings.

moth898
21-02-2010, 12:00 AM
Have you done the droop mods with longer shock bottom ends ?

A bit more droop would aid landings.

No, I did't get the memo....I am glad That you guys are here to help but maybe shumacher should create a simple site for these type of mods.

I also saw that someone was making a bar to join the bivot blocks,making them stronger, but I can't find anyone selling them. I very curious about the softer shock arms... do they break less than the originals.

I was also thinking of a old school mod.... we use to put a small piece of gas feul tube on the shock shaft to keep cars from bottoming out. Do you think it will affect the handlind in a negative way, because these guys already have a low ride height.

ApexSpeed
21-02-2010, 12:17 AM
This sounds like the exact same thing I went through a few years ago with a Corally RDX touring car. The very first time I set the car on the track, I hadn't even gotten to the driver's stand and was hit by another car practicing, and it broke a rear arm and hub carrier. Following that, every time I put the car on the track for practice, heats or races, something on the car broke. I'm not a world-class driver, but I'm not a hack either, and I couldn't believe how much breakage there was.

Ironically, I sold the RDX for a Schumacher Mi3, and never broke another part for 2 full seasons of racing touring cars (stock rubber). As much as I thought the RDX was a beautiful car with absolutely top shelf quality and design, the car just had really bad mojo in my hands. No matter what I did, I was buying replacement parts and sitting in the pits repairing things on far too regular of an occurrence. I still think the RDX was a really great car to drive, but I couldn't hit ANYTHING because I knew it was so fragile for me. Regardless of how many strong parts I put on the car, I still bent or broke them, and it ruined my driving. I drove every session paranoid of breakage—missing apexes by over a foot on purpose. It wasn't worth it anymore, so I sold the car.


What I'm trying to say is maybe that car and you aren't having good juju. Cut your losses, and move on to something else before you lose your mind with the car.




Just a thought from someone who dealt with the same thing before and spent a lot chasing "fixes."

moth898
21-02-2010, 04:31 AM
Bad vibes is right, I'm about to call a witch doctor to try lift the curse. My partner is running a cat so I bought it to be able to share experience and parts. He actually hasn't broken as much as me all year as I did in two qualifiers.

I was always a (sorry) kyosho fan. I'm going to give the cat two more races...If I cant get it to handle the way I want I'm going to make cat soup out of it.

So can all you cat pro's out there please give me all the help you can with this

Thank you

David Church
21-02-2010, 04:43 AM
I had simular problem, I will explain. My Cat was good straight out the box, no problems, then I changed a few bits during routine maintanance, then it broke almost every run, I did spurs, diffs came un done, wishbones, and even had trouble with the receiver, I worked through it, fixed all the broken bits, and it has been good since,
So don't give up too quickly, and once you have worked all the bugs out I think you will really like the Cat:thumbsup:

colmo
21-02-2010, 10:28 AM
It seems the current generation of Schumachers aren't for everyone - I've been hearing reports that both the Cat SX and Mi4 are high-maintenance vehicles - fast, yes, but for the likes of me, who drops his car on the track with barely a glance, not a good match.

I'm wondering if the Cougar SV will depart from this trend - it certainly looks tough!

moth898
21-02-2010, 04:09 PM
The maintenance is not a problem. It has a couple of issues that have to be addressed.

moth898
22-02-2010, 04:26 AM
I had simular problem, I will explain. My Cat was good straight out the box, no problems, then I changed a few bits during routine maintanance, then it broke almost every run, I did spurs, diffs came un done, wishbones, and even had trouble with the receiver, I worked through it, fixed all the broken bits, and it has been good since,
So don't give up too quickly, and once you have worked all the bugs out I think you will really like the Cat:thumbsup:

where can I buy the bar that joins the front pivot blocks

David Church
22-02-2010, 06:43 AM
where can I buy the bar that joins the front pivot blocks


He is Stegger on here [email protected]

I have both braces he makes, but not even used them yet:woot:

Southwell
22-02-2010, 10:09 AM
Might be worth checking your chassis isn't tweaked and the weight balance is ok if it isn't jumping very well as you could be doing a lot of landings on one side, rather than landing flat.

moth898
22-02-2010, 12:51 PM
Might be worth checking your chassis isn't tweaked and the weight balance is ok if it isn't jumping very well as you could be doing a lot of landings on one side, rather than landing flat.

something is wrong, every time I correct with the throttle the left side dips. Can anyone suggest a reason?

BRS
22-02-2010, 02:10 PM
I find the car weak too, the softer arms will help some though. The BW brace is essential as the alloy front blocks are imo very soft alloy.

I like the car I just dont think its made strong enough for todays brushless performance.

moth898
23-02-2010, 08:39 PM
I don't think that brushless motors have too much power for the car to handle, I actually think the car is too heavy. The weight is making it hard for me to setup.He's a link to a video of the track. I broke my front arm once on the last jump, before the staightaway, landind a little past the jump on the flat. The second arm broke on the first jump after the straight again because I overshot the jump. As you can see ther is no real big air jumps and its on dirt so its even more forgiving. Can anyone suggest a setup for this track?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=moRuBYauvq0

Alfonzo
23-02-2010, 08:46 PM
Cool track. I can't for the life of me think why you couldn't get the CAT to run nicely over that. I'm sure someone who knows the car well will be able to help with some setup advice.

David Church
23-02-2010, 08:53 PM
something is wrong, every time I correct with the throttle the left side dips. Can anyone suggest a reason?


Could be a siezed wheel bearing??? My car jumps good, its not the design of the car thats giving you trouble, it must be mechanical.

moth898
23-02-2010, 09:52 PM
I had the same thought and bought a set of acer ceramic bearings to replace them all. Or the easiest answer is that I am a horrible driver:( and make a good car go bad.

Mossy
24-02-2010, 10:06 AM
Try my seup from the Euros - its listed in the manual.

Si

moth898
24-02-2010, 12:07 PM
I guess your Simon Moss...i'ts a pleasure. I'm goining to do that this weekend, I also found a couple other of your setups on the web that I'm going to try. I got two questions if you don't mind. how do you adjust the lenght of the shock, do I simply unscrew the ball joint or do I change the shaft. And how would I limit bottoming out?

Thanks
Bill

lochness42
24-02-2010, 05:17 PM
I got two questions if you don't mind. how do you adjust the lenght of the shock, do I simply unscrew the ball joint or do I change the shaft.
I can answer this one - use longer ballcup cut to length you need - unscrewing isn't safe as you are risking stripping thread in ballcup.

moth898
24-02-2010, 07:48 PM
You wouldn't happen to have a part number would you?

David Church
24-02-2010, 07:55 PM
U2989Ball Grippa Sockets - (pk 8)

David Church
24-02-2010, 07:56 PM
Found it here

http://www.racing-cars.com/main.asp

Malek
25-02-2010, 02:48 AM
I guess your Simon Moss...i'ts a pleasure. I'm goining to do that this weekend, I also found a couple other of your setups on the web that I'm going to try. I got two questions if you don't mind. how do you adjust the lenght of the shock, do I simply unscrew the ball joint or do I change the shaft. And how would I limit bottoming out?

Thanks
Bill

Don't be hard on yourself there Bill,when you get this car setup right you will love it.Keep in mind it was only your first race there.When i took your car for a spin there i found your camber was out of wack now everyones setup should suit there driving style of course.Im sure if you took my cat sx for a spin you would hate the feeling of it.but for me it works great and as you know im always tweaking something but one change at a time.when you take the car for a first run don't focus how fast you will go but how you can get around the track without crashing and picking up the pace from there.

Dennis
Cat SX
Cougar SV (Soon)
B44
B4

moth898
25-02-2010, 05:49 AM
Found it here

http://www.racing-cars.com/main.asp

Thanks David I ordered some, and alot of other spare parts:cry:

moth898
25-02-2010, 05:54 AM
Don't be hard on yourself there Bill,when you get this car setup right you will love it.Keep in mind it was only your first race there.When i took your car for a spin there i found your camber was out of wack now everyones setup should suit there driving style of course.Im sure if you took my cat sx for a spin you would hate the feeling of it.but for me it works great and as you know im always tweaking something but one change at a time.when you take the car for a first run don't focus how fast you will go but how you can get around the track without crashing and picking up the pace from there.

Dennis
Cat SX
Cougar SV (Soon)
B44
B4

This is my friend I race with, I am the paduwan and he is the jedi night. After taking the car out for the first time getting used to it and my initial setup, he decide my setup sucked right before the first qualifier and changed everything. After that everything started to go south. The next time you come near my car Denis I might bite your finger, and not gentle like.

I will defeat you my master!!!

Don't worry...You'll find I catch on real fast

David Church
25-02-2010, 06:21 AM
Thanks David I ordered some, and alot of other spare parts:cry:


Good job:thumbsup:

I have been driving the Cat for over a year and still finding little set-up changes, with the help of my masters Moss and Williams:thumbsup:

moth898
03-03-2010, 02:03 AM
I just got my replacement bits for the cat and noticed the front pivot blocks are alot beefier, they are also with 4m srews up from 3m. Do you think I still need the brace from stegger?

I'm still alittle unsure about what oil to use in the shocks, Mr. Moss uses thinner weight in the front and lighter in the back, but I'm afraid of bottoming out my front end. What should I do?

clintscreations
03-03-2010, 05:31 AM
Give that set up a try that I mailed ya
My kitty is real comfortable to drive

Make sure your motor is close to center belt and lipo is as close to center as possible

after you break the stock arms ....try the med flex....if they still break easy .... put the arms in boiling water for 10 or 15 min.......that will make em flex

moth898
03-03-2010, 11:58 AM
Give that set up a try that I mailed ya
My kitty is real comfortable to drive

Make sure your motor is close to center belt and lipo is as close to center as possible

after you break the stock arms ....try the med flex....if they still break easy .... put the arms in boiling water for 10 or 15 min.......that will make em flex

That's what I'm doing, your setup and moss's are almost the same exept for the 12.5 front steering blocks and the oil. It's the lighter oil in the front that I don't understand. I used 40 in the front my first race and bottomed out heavily, going to 25 will probably make it worse.

clintscreations
03-03-2010, 12:37 PM
Oh ok

I can see your point about the thinner oil

Gibbon666
06-03-2010, 09:16 PM
That's what I'm doing, your setup and moss's are almost the same exept for the 12.5 front steering blocks and the oil. It's the lighter oil in the front that I don't understand. I used 40 in the front my first race and bottomed out heavily, going to 25 will probably make it worse.

I'd say don't go with the 25 oil. I've tried it and could never stop the car bottoming out. I found a switch to 350cst made a huge difference, even though that only works out to 30W in most brands. This was running 3 hole pistons and cut diaphragms. If its big, big jumps you would probably want to go with something like 400 or 450 cst.

It could just be that the brand Simon is using works out a bit thicker than some other brands of 25W.

The front brace is awesome - I'd class it as a necessity if you are on the M3 front screws. With M4 you should get away with more impacts - but only time will tell.

moth898
06-03-2010, 10:46 PM
I ordered the braces from Stegger and some other parts from Schumacher America right before they closed, the medium wishbones were in that order. Stegger I'm not worried about but I have a little concern for the American order, I hope it didn't get lost in the transition. I ordered from the UK and recieved the parts in two days...stunning service.

Mossy
07-03-2010, 09:28 AM
I use Schumacher oil, but the track that setup is designed didnt have any big jumps. To be honest I would stiffen the sping first rather than go up on the oil - you need it to be reasonably soft to generate the grip.

Si

moth898
07-03-2010, 10:52 PM
Your absolutely right, I raced today and had very little front traction. I had Losi 40 oil and shumacher grey rear spings up front and traction over the bumpy sections was almost non existant. The rear was great with shumacher yellow springs and 30 Losi oil. Only broke one front wisbone today, witch is a good thing. The only recurring problem was the servo arm striped on me a couple of time. The first one was original, the second was a original but not for my servo so that stipped too, the third lasted me the main. I'm figuring to go with a aluminium servo arm but not sure if it will damage the servo, my futaba servo has a aluminium spocket so aluminium on aluminium isn't the ideal senario. Does Sumacher or anyone else make a servo saver arm for the lipo setup?

lochness42
07-03-2010, 11:00 PM
Do you have ballstud in top or bottom hole on your servo arm?

moth898
07-03-2010, 11:09 PM
Top hole

lochness42
07-03-2010, 11:30 PM
Use bottom one then - it will help with durability of both servo and servo arm and you should be fine. I managed to break gears in my KoPropo at my first race outing on our really rutted track and I was pushing really hard - switched to bottom hole and didn't have any probs since that.

moth898
11-03-2010, 09:42 PM
Hey gents,

I broke my wing mounts and uppper rear transmision in a miscommunication between my brain and hand, I throttled instead of brakeing and ended up landing straight on the wing mounts:thumbsup:. I changed out the plastic Tranny for the aluminium type and fabbed my own wing mount out of aluminium. My question is;

Does having a solid wing mount put to much force on the upper tranny mount, In otherwords will it break my tranny or shock tower in a accident? Or am I better of sticking with the stock plastic wing mount as a type of crumple zone?

chatts#725
11-03-2010, 10:36 PM
i run a solid rear wing mount and im not the most carefull, i do have alloy upper mounting/diff mounting tho, not had any problems other than it batters the wing a lot more:woot:

moth898
11-03-2010, 11:03 PM
I also noticed in the alloy tranny two theaded holes that I can't see any use for. What are they for?

Some other people have posted pictures of cats with what seems to be different than stock wing mount. Can a different one be installed?

lochness42
12-03-2010, 10:36 AM
Well solid wing mount and alloy top gearboxes will make shocktowers weak link. Not that it will break at slight touch, just that this will be part that will have to absorb most of the force applied on rear.

2 holes are there for rear shock mount - so you don't have to fiddle with everything.

To wing holder - I've used Durga one for last season - there are few different brands that will fit - use search function I belive you'll find thread about it.

moth898
13-03-2010, 08:37 PM
I just finished installing every option part available for the cat in a effort to make it as solid as possible....never mind making shumacher a little richer at the same time:D

The new thicker front medium wishbones look alot stonger than the original design. I only have concerns, or questions about two parts.

1)will the one way diff make it harder to stop and steer?

2)How does the rear suspention conversion affect handling?

Thanks,
Bill

stegger
13-03-2010, 09:02 PM
1/ The one-way will give you loads off steering off power and you will only be abel to brake with the rear wheels resulting in the car swopping ends ;)
2/ The rear shock conversion is used for very bumpy tracks.

moth898
13-03-2010, 09:09 PM
So your suggesting not to use the one way. What kind of a course is it ment for?

moth898
14-03-2010, 05:41 PM
Has anyone noticed how contaminated the shock oil gets after a race. The bare aluminium walls are turnng the shock oil metalic in colour after just one race.

Does anyone know what shocks can replace the stock set?

lochness42
14-03-2010, 10:29 PM
Has anyone noticed how contaminated the shock oil gets after a race. The bare aluminium walls are turnng the shock oil metalic in colour after just one race.

Does anyone know what shocks can replace the stock set?

Big Bore shocks seems to be without this issue from what I've heard from team - oil stays clean for much longer time than std shocks. Just wait for them.

moth898
16-03-2010, 09:52 PM
What I want to know is how many years has Simon Moss been racing to get to that level of driving?

I want to know if I stand a chance of getting there befor I'm 50!!!:thumbsup:

lochness42
17-03-2010, 11:57 AM
Moth - 42

moth898
17-03-2010, 12:04 PM
:cry:

PsycoChris
18-03-2010, 04:22 AM
Big Bore shocks seems to be without this issue from what I've heard from team - oil stays clean for much longer time than std shocks. Just wait for them.

You give great advice. I like your ideas. I love the Cat and cannot wait till the Big Bores come out. Going to be sick. Shocks are dialed!

Mossy
18-03-2010, 09:51 AM
What I want to know is how many years has Simon Moss been racing to get to that level of driving?

I want to know if I stand a chance of getting there befor I'm 50!!!:thumbsup:

Not quite 50 lol. Around 16 years now, Nationals and Euros for the last 8/9 i think.

The big bore shocks dont contaminate the oil at all, although this never really affected the performance of the small bore - its just the colouring out of the shock bodies.

moth898
18-03-2010, 11:48 AM
I was right on the money--35 plus 16 would make 51 years old.....I wouldn't make it there anyhow.....my wife wouldn't let me play with my toys that long:cry:.

I'm waiting for the Bigbores from day to day like everone else....can't you do anything about that Mossy. Go to shumacher and say "MY FOLLOWERS NEED NEW SHOCKS" and slam your staff to the ground in biblical fashion....that'll get their attention:thumbsup:

lochness42
18-03-2010, 01:15 PM
I was right on the money--35 plus 16 would make 51 years old.....I wouldn't make it there anyhow.....my wife wouldn't let me play with my toys that long:cry:.

I'm waiting for the Bigbores from day to day like everone else....can't you do anything about that Mossy. Go to shumacher and say "MY FOLLOWERS NEED NEW SHOCKS" and slam your staff to the ground in biblical fashion....that'll get their attention:thumbsup:

Oh Dear :woot::D