PDA

View Full Version : card cloning


DaveTheRave
16-04-2010, 06:26 AM
I don't want to further hijack the cougar thread, so I thought I'd start a thread on the subject..

Last week my debit card was cloned for 30 pound for an O2 pre pay top up.

This has never happened to me before, and I started using the schumacher site to buy bits around 8 weeks ago.

So have othjers had this problem then?

jimmy
16-04-2010, 07:10 AM
Seems to be quite popular :thumbdown:- but none of these people have bought from Schumacher.

http://www.sheffieldforum.co.uk/showthread.php?t=406022

http://www.consumeractiongroup.co.uk/forum/general-consumer-issues/214054-o2-ltd-prepay-scam.html

http://uk-mkivs.net/forums/p/313662/2096628.aspx

http://forum.o2.co.uk/viewtopic.php?p=153244&sid=3839ee7d48d3f0c25875da8b2aab15fc

jameswilkinson7
16-04-2010, 07:14 AM
My card was cloned last week too.. I haven't bought anything from Schumacher in months though.. I was blaming the petrol station on the way to work... They tried to top up a phone card with mine too.:mad: I really wouldn't expect it to be anything to do with Schumacher. The people in this the people in this industry seem to be the most honest I have ever come across

DaSloth
16-04-2010, 07:24 AM
Its nearly always the petrol stations :( I went through 3 bloomin cards!

mikeyscott
16-04-2010, 07:33 AM
Well I have my new card now and will be very cautious.

My bank have a list of 3 companies from January and one from the one just gone as they say it was a card not present transaction

I think it's time for PayPal to lower their fees and people using it more. I shop more at MK for this reason now.

DMS it's over the phone and Schumacher it'll be over the phone now too (not saying anything wrong with them).

Maybe their is a new virus / key logger doing the rounds?

I'll have a look on some the usual security websites.

Col
16-04-2010, 07:40 AM
I think it's time for PayPal to lower their fees and people using it more.

If more people stopped using gift, they'd be able to lower their fee's:thumbsup:

mikeyscott
16-04-2010, 07:42 AM
If more people stopped using gift, they'd be able to lower their fee's:thumbsup:

I they're looking at charging for this too now :(

Col
16-04-2010, 07:45 AM
Good

burgie
16-04-2010, 07:48 AM
it hasn't happened to me, but simon larkin (sly on here) had is cloned card used in an O2 shop in Nelson, also after using it to buy from the Schumacher website.

mikeyscott
16-04-2010, 07:49 AM
Good

Why?

Just means people with charge more or use bank transfers

mikeyscott
16-04-2010, 07:52 AM
it hasn't happened to me, but simon larkin (sly on here) had is cloned card used in an O2 shop in Nelson, also after using it to buy from the Schumacher website.

Seems to be a lot of O2 fraud on other forums, can he gurantee that it was Schumacher?

MatJohnson
16-04-2010, 07:59 AM
Having never ordered off Schumacher I can't 100% comment, but when you go through the process isn't there an SSL cert on the site?

If so, its either a key logger on your machine, or someone has got the details from the Schumacher DB (Very unlikely). I would go with petrol station over anything else

Mossy
16-04-2010, 08:05 AM
I work in retail, and card cloning is obviously an issue here. There is no way it can be pinpointed to a certain company, as the details are often obtained through the transaction process used at the bank/website.

Seems harsh to name any company (apart from petrol stations of course - robbing bastards!) linking them to card cloning on a public forum.

Si

chatts#725
16-04-2010, 08:07 AM
I think people are missunderstanding whats being said on here, no one is saying that schumacher is a dishonest company, for those of you so quick and eager to jump to there defence(prob after some kind of 'd' team driver backing or something) What is being said is that schumacher seems to be a common link in more than just a handfull of these claims and that maybe they need to review their internet security or their card details holding system, if they never know then they wont do anything so i have contacted them and my bank and hopefully now we can make this secure as im sure we would all agree its almost like a life line when you need parts fast, hope this can be sorted and faith in schumacher can be restored for all. ta:thumbsup: That was not in any way aimed at you si your post appeared whilst i was mid rant ha ha .

Chris Ashton
16-04-2010, 01:18 PM
We appritiate the feedback guys and rest assured we view our security very seriously. If there is a problem we will fully investigate our security measures.

mikeyscott
16-04-2010, 01:26 PM
Having never ordered off Schumacher I can't 100% comment, but when you go through the process isn't there an SSL cert on the site?

If so, its either a key logger on your machine, or someone has got the details from the Schumacher DB (Very unlikely). I would go with petrol station over anything else

Having an SSL cert means nothing, unless it's a trusted cert. Plus you can have a man in the middle attack. Aka when have a SSL proxy server that blows SSL apart to inspect it, put something like wireshark in there and you can see the data. We actively block self certs at work

I blocked a site the other week as when we looked at the traffic all the credential information was going out in clear text! Eeek

The other thing that I have arguments with people over - there is no such thing as secure email..

autoxvw
23-04-2010, 09:32 PM
So I guess this cloning isnt limited to you guys on the other side of the atlantic. My acct was hacked after a purchase to schumacher last week for $784.21 USD.

mdb_75
23-04-2010, 09:42 PM
I hope this is sorted soon, I've had three cards cloned after using Schumachers site, but until it happened to the last card I didn't really know where it was happening from.

mikeyscott
23-04-2010, 09:49 PM
This isn't good. Particularly with cougar orders due soon etc. I'll be ordering my Schumacher kit I feel from my other sources.

ramdrive
23-04-2010, 09:56 PM
It has to be an employee of Shumacher, mobile tops ups come on...

If it was a full on attack they would be wiping you accounts out.

You guys need to talk to the police ASAP.

ramdrive
23-04-2010, 10:01 PM
Penny drops, why are you supporting these guys, come on!

This isn't good. Particularly with cougar orders due soon etc. I'll be ordering my Schumacher kit I feel from my other sources.

mikeyscott
23-04-2010, 10:16 PM
Penny drops, why are you supporting these guys, come on!

Because the actions of the one employee shouldn't affect the many.

Have people spoken to Schumacher management to help them resolve the issue? If people believe that they have been cloned by Schumacher, let them and the bank know so they can pinpoint the potential problem.

ramdrive
23-04-2010, 11:05 PM
Mikey, with respect "the potential problem" is theft my friend plain and simple.

Take off those rose tinted glasses :blush:



Because the actions of the one employee shouldn't affect the many.

Have people spoken to Schumacher management to help them resolve the issue? If people believe that they have been cloned by Schumacher, let them and the bank know so they can pinpoint the potential problem.

mikeyscott
23-04-2010, 11:09 PM
Hence why I'd buy Schumacher bits from MK at the moment.

All I am saying is for people to contact Schumacher. Do we not want them to resolve the problem.

Nothing to do with rose tinted classes... I know it's theft, you don't need to tell me that. Mine got done, but the bank refunded me instantly.

Think I'll phone them on Monday a go from there.

ramdrive
23-04-2010, 11:14 PM
Sorry Mikey, this is a criminal matter and should be reported to the police.

And you still want to support these guys? get a grip! No product and they empty your account!

I am on your side mate...

Hence why I'd buy Schumacher bits from MK at the moment.

All I am saying is for people to contact Schumacher. Do we not want them to resolve the problem.

Nothing to do with rose tinted classes...

mikeyscott
23-04-2010, 11:16 PM
Sorry Mikey, this is a criminal matter and should be reported to the police.

the bank fraud teams liase with the police. Make the call then?

My bank first direct certainly do and they work with the other banks.

So everyone at Schumacher including the team drivers is a thief? That's a bit harsh..

I agree nobody likes being had, but I believe in working with them to fix it. I think company wise they are far better than many companies out there. SCS should have gone busted and stayed there.

The issue could be with their hosting company or whoever provides the checkout facility online etc

I will still be buying an SV. Christ, spent £200 on Cougar and Cat stuff over the last week.

ramdrive
23-04-2010, 11:57 PM
OK..


the bank fraud teams liase with the police. Make the call then?

My bank first direct certainly do and they work with the other banks.

So everyone at Schumacher including the team drivers is a thief? That's a bit harsh..

I agree nobody likes being had, but I believe in working with them to fix it. I think company wise they are far better than many companies out there. SCS should have gone busted and stayed there.

The issue could be with their hosting company or whoever provides the checkout facility online etc

I will still be buying an SV. Christ, spent £200 on Cougar and Cat stuff over the last week.

Alfonzo
24-04-2010, 12:38 AM
Sorry Mikey, this is a criminal matter and should be reported to the police.

And you still want to support these guys? get a grip! No product and they empty your account!

I am on your side mate...

You're the one that needs to get a grip. You seem to be suggesting the whole company is conspiring to rip your card. What've you been smoking? :lol:

MattW
24-04-2010, 09:17 PM
Ram, that is a very serious accusation you've come up with there.

As a team driver, my card number has been held on file at Schumacher for a good number of years - and i'm happy for it to continue to be.

moth898
24-04-2010, 09:55 PM
OK..

Who is this guy? This site is for helping people not spewing shit all the time, can Jimmy kick him off the site already!!!!

ramdrive
24-04-2010, 10:15 PM
I have made no accusations here, other drivers have, did I start this tread?

Money has been taken from fellow drivers accounts without permission, is this not theft?

As a team driver would you say anything else?

Ram, that is a very serious accusation you've come up with there.

As a team driver, my card number has been held on file at Schumacher for a good number of years - and i'm happy for it to continue to be.

ramdrive
24-04-2010, 10:16 PM
What shit, facts my friend read the thread...

P.S how old are you 13 -14?

Who is this guy? This site is for helping people not spewing shit all the time, can Jimmy kick him off the site already!!!!

bigred5765
24-04-2010, 10:26 PM
What shit, facts my friend read the thread...

P.S how old are you 13 -14?
Sorry Mikey, this is a criminal matter and should be reported to the police.
I have made no accusations here, other drivers have, did I start this tread?

Money has been taken from fellow drivers accounts without permission, is this not theft?

As a team driver would you say anything else?

And you still want to support these guys? get a grip! No product and they empty your account!

I am on your side mate...

o but you have made accusations mate plain and simple you have accused them in the statement above
No product and THEY empty you account.well if thats not a wild accusation i don't know what is, you have spoken without knowing the facts my friend, i doubt anyone at schuy has anything to do with this,and if you have doubts about your own account you should ring them direct instead of coming on a open forum trying to flame them,
buy the way im not a team driver but my lad is

ramdrive
24-04-2010, 10:38 PM
You are right "Pit Bitch" I retract all previous statements in this thread!

I believe Shumacher are an honest company and wish them well with there new release.



Sorry Mikey, this is a criminal matter and should be reported to the police.
I have made no accusations here, other drivers have, did I start this tread?

Money has been taken from fellow drivers accounts without permission, is this not theft?

As a team driver would you say anything else?

And you still want to support these guys? get a grip! No product and they empty your account!

I am on your side mate...

o but you have made accusations mate plain and simple you have accused them in the statement above
No product and THEY empty you account.well if thats not a wild accusation i don't know what is, you have spoken without knowing the facts my friend, i doubt anyone at schuy has anything to do with this,and if you have doubts about your own account you should ring them direct instead of coming on a open forum trying to flame them,
buy the way im not a team driver but my lad is

stegger
24-04-2010, 10:46 PM
You are right "Pit Bitch" I retract all previous statements in this thread!

I believe Shumacher are an honest company and wish them well with there new release.

Ramdrive your out of order. There's no reason to get personal :mad:

bigred5765
24-04-2010, 10:58 PM
deleted

mikeyscott
24-04-2010, 11:21 PM
I haven't made any accusations, just asked people to speak to the retailer in question.

Where have these rude comments come from, I thought it was a place to give help and advice.

For those genuinely not interested in the schumacher brand, buy something else?

From my personal experience Schumacher has been one of the most helpful teams.

Lock the thread?

ramdrive
24-04-2010, 11:56 PM
Not personal at all, I feel sorry for the poor guy.

Ramdrive your out of order. There's no reason to get personal :mad:

ramdrive
25-04-2010, 12:00 AM
I agree Mikey, this is getting silly now. I will back off.

I hope you get sorted on your parts and car, we should be supporting the Brits and not knocking them, I have and am sorry and hope they do well.

Good luck with it mate.

I haven't made any accusations, just asked people to speak to the retailer in question.

Where have these rude comments come from, I thought it was a place to give help and advice.

For those genuinely not interested in the schumacher brand, buy something else?

From my personal experience Schumacher has been one of the most helpful teams.

Lock the thread?

bigred5765
25-04-2010, 08:27 AM
Not personal at all, I feel sorry for the poor guy.
sorry no need to its my choice,poor guy hmm doubt that:thumbdown:

mark christopher
25-04-2010, 08:41 AM
I have made no accusations here, other drivers have, did I start this tread?

Money has been taken from fellow drivers accounts without permission, is this not theft?

As a team driver would you say anything else?

It has to be an employee of Shumacher, mobile tops ups come on...

If it was a full on attack they would be wiping you accounts out.

You guys need to talk to the police ASAP.


and your not accusing anyone?

Oscar
25-04-2010, 08:50 AM
Regardless of what has been said above, perhaps everyone needs to consider that card fraud is often via highly organised channels.

As an example, I read recently about one of the UK's largest retailers ( I think maybe Tesco?), being associated with card fraud. Essentially, it happened via the chip and pin devices that are on the end of each till. It turned out a number of these devices had been supplied new from the manufacturer with a data logging system and mobile phone system built in. This then in turn relayed all card data and pin numbers back to an overseas gang.

Obviously the retailer, although involved, had no idea what was going on.

So, even if there is an issue, (and I do say IF), it may not be that simple;)

Big G
22-07-2010, 12:18 PM
yay. I got the automatted phone call from barclays again today.

the only site I've been using lately is Schumacher's :(


it hasn't happened to me, but simon larkin (sly on here) had is cloned card used in an O2 shop in Nelson, also after using it to buy from the Schumacher website.

LOL mine was £30 from O2 Nelson/Slough, £30 top up at Tesco and £5 top up at T mobile Hatfield GB.

mikeyscott
22-07-2010, 12:31 PM
I had a phone call from First Direct last week after someone tried to buy some cowboy boots online in the states..

I also had some attempted iTunes purchases.. I'm in the process of setting up another FD account purely for Internet that'll have money transfer to it for purchases and will have a 0 overdraft that won't be allowed.

Internet fraud is a big problem and I'm using Paypal these days or sending cheques for stuff bought online etc.

Team No Idea
22-07-2010, 12:42 PM
yup, not sure if it was just just fluke but i used the schumacher website and within 1 week i was ripped of for £1000. not happy:thumbdown:
Luckily Nationwide got it sorted. Wont be using the internet for buying without paypal or something in the future!

Big G
22-07-2010, 12:46 PM
I use paypal for everywhere else

mikeyscott
22-07-2010, 01:25 PM
I use paypal for everywhere else

I know people who have had their PayPal accounts hacked :thumbdown:

c0sie
22-07-2010, 01:41 PM
I had my PP account hax0red and all the money spent on some online gambling thing lol

I also had my A&L bank account hacked (never bought a Schumacher though lol) and someone bought £100 worth of flowers from Interflora! Poor Wifey has never had £100 worth of flowers from me lol

racingdwarf
22-07-2010, 01:58 PM
Reading this thought I would just say that one of our club members Bought himself a cougar a few weeks ago, ordered some parts from the schumacher site with a new card he had used nowere else at all, this was the 1st transaction,not used the card for anything else before. then put it back in his wallet and didn't use it again, about 5days later the card supplier was on the phone, someone had used the card details to top up a mobile phone and tried to use it for a couple of other things too

so there is realy only one place those details could have been taken from....

pro4nut
22-07-2010, 02:33 PM
yay. I got the automatted phone call from barclays again today.

the only site I've been using lately is Schumacher's :(




LOL mine was £30 from O2 Nelson/Slough, £30 top up at Tesco and £5 top up at T mobile Hatfield GB.

Those addresses are the fixed address locations for card transactions made online.

I bought some stuff off the schumacher site and shortly after i spotted a transaction for IWOOT for a few hundred and a single transaction from a mobile phone retailer.
The most worrying one i advise you look out for though is single transactions of £1 value to mobile phone retailers as this indicates they have run a URU authentication, and a successful one to validate your identity prior to conducting a credit check. To pass this check they must have skimmed both the address details and card details from the site in question.
This had also happened to me. On the plus side 1 phone call to my bank, a signature on a claim form and the money was returned to me in a few days.
Like i say though the damage they could do to your credit rating by taking mulitple mobile phone accounts is more dangerous.

Balders
22-07-2010, 02:39 PM
Reading this thought I would just say that one of our club members Bought himself a cougar a few weeks ago, ordered some parts from the schumacher site with a new card he had used nowere else at all, this was the 1st transaction,not used the card for anything else before. then put it back in his wallet and didn't use it again, about 5days later the card supplier was on the phone, someone had used the card details to top up a mobile phone and tried to use it for a couple of other things too

so there is realy only one place those details could have been taken from....

I had the same issue with Schumacher on their old payment processor, brand new card not used anywhere else on the internet and it was skimmed for around 500 quid shortly after an order from them...

I spoke with them over email and made a few suggestions around security which I'm pleased to say appear to have now been addressed. The original card processing engine they were using dated to back to 2006 and as technology has moved on so have exploits. I don't think this problem was caused from someone within Schumacher just some sod on the internet knowing how to hack the site.

If you look at the ordering process on their site now it is 100% better and appears to be more secure.

Handling Cc details on line is a minefield, if anyone was going to setup an online transaction site now I would strongly suggest they use one of the many reputable 3rd party payment gateways like paypal, Barclays or Lloyds to name but a few. Yes you do loose a small %age of the order cost in fees but at the end of the day that's got to be worth it to maintain your reputation.

Thats my 5p worth anyway! :)

Mike

Shaun 'TheSheep' Atkinson
22-07-2010, 03:32 PM
It has to be an employee of Shumacher, mobile tops ups come on...

If it was a full on attack they would be wiping you accounts out.

You guys need to talk to the police ASAP.

They do this for small amounts at phone companies to see if there is money in the account and if anybody notices, if nothing comes back from them taking the small amount out, they then go on to wipe your account out.

Just ask my brother it happened to him not long back :(

mikeyscott
22-07-2010, 03:37 PM
I'm on card number three this year :(

racingdwarf
22-07-2010, 03:56 PM
I agree with a post above, i don't think it would be an employee in schumacher, after all it's a small firm,
As has been said I think some cleaver sod is getting info from the site..

c0sie
22-07-2010, 03:59 PM
Can I just say that although I posted in this thread to let people know about my experiences of having bank accounts compromised, I am in no way part of the "Schumacher" discussion in this thread.

Accusing Schumacher or their employees of fraud etc is some serious shit :)

slow bob
22-07-2010, 04:25 PM
There is a quick fix for this problem

you can only use the card to top up 3 seperate phone sims

so if you have 3 trusted freinds with pay and go phones give them each a £5 top up .. problem solved

TUCRACEMAN
24-07-2010, 09:53 PM
Its nearly always the petrol stations :( I went through 3 bloomin cards!
I had a gas station in California steal my American Express number and try to charge $5000. That was interesting.
~D

steel
24-07-2010, 10:27 PM
Well i thought i would give my 2 pence worth i normally only use paypal to purchase but since purchasing a couple of schumacer cars i have had to use my card to order numerous amounts of spares over the last couple of months and i have had no problems with my card and the only place i have used it is with shuey :thumbsup:

Big G
24-07-2010, 10:54 PM
credit to barclays on mine. reported on thursday and a new card arrived today :)

telboy
24-07-2010, 11:10 PM
It has to be an employee of Shumacher, mobile tops ups come on...

If it was a full on attack they would be wiping you accounts out.

You guys need to talk to the police ASAP.


I haven't used my new card at schumacher and we had our bank account cleared out recently.
They start by getting something small (like O2 top up - which they did with us on the thursday night) then once they know the card works with a small amount that you may not notice, they then go on a shopping spree....costing us £150 in flowers (just like cosie :s) from an interflora store in kings lynn, and then they tried to buy $900 worth of designer clothes from the US.

So I wouldn't say its much to do with Schumacher but an overall lack of security on the internet. If these people want your details, they'll get it.

We contacted the bank and the fraud squad contacted us on the friday.
They basically asked if we'd had the card taken off us for any transactions. As it happened it had been taken off us at a cadbury's store as their regular chip and pin was not working....apparently. So thats where we think ours was done. Every other transaction has been chip and pin....which is still just as easy to clone as the old system. :(

It would be helpful if more places did include Paypal as a payment method though.

daz
25-07-2010, 09:55 AM
My bank have just contacted me today on a Sunday, to say my card number is being used to get a i phone from the apple website. They thought it was strange activity cos i have just topped my own mobile up the day before. The transaction was declined and card stopped, so no cash came out of my account. Well done HSBC for being so vigalate.
And by the way i bought some items from the schumacher website on Thursday, and its the first time ive used my card on line for months. Not saying its them but somethings not right.

howies3
25-07-2010, 06:59 PM
same here, i also have only used my card on schumacher website and someone used it to buy phone top ups £20 of O2 and £40 for Orange so it got flagged up and they reported it to me.

chatts#725
26-07-2010, 06:09 PM
I was involved in posting in the early part of this thread and am not accusing anyone as this is some kind of hacking or wrong doing wether it is is known or not, my point is that i had a cat sx and ordered regularly from the manufacturer, in turn i had 5 new cards in the first 4 months of this year due to unorthourised purchases from O2 prepay slough, tesco mobile, euro tunnel, a hotel in london and various others, my bank in the end told me to stop using my card to buy from this manufacturer, i sold my cat sx stopped ordering and guess what not a dickybird since hey presto!!!!!!!!!!!

Big G
26-07-2010, 06:34 PM
and I bought it lol

steel
26-07-2010, 07:03 PM
Well i thought i would give my 2 pence worth i normally only use paypal to purchase but since purchasing a couple of schumacer cars i have had to use my card to order numerous amounts of spares over the last couple of months and i have had no problems with my card and the only place i have used it is with shuey :thumbsup:

Well after posting this the other day:blush: i have had the phone call from the bank i also have been duped outa £200 pound on orange tmodile o2 pre pay:thumbdown:

racingdwarf
26-07-2010, 07:26 PM
I was involved in posting in the early part of this thread and am not accusing anyone as this is some kind of hacking or wrong doing wether it is is known or not, my point is that i had a cat sx and ordered regularly from the manufacturer, in turn i had 5 new cards in the first 4 months of this year due to unorthourised purchases from O2 prepay slough, tesco mobile, euro tunnel, a hotel in london and various others, my bank in the end told me to stop using my card to buy from this manufacturer, i sold my cat sx stopped ordering and guess what not a dickybird since hey presto!!!!!!!!!!!

Thats funny? the club member I posted about earlier who had probs. The 1st thing they tried to do with his details was o2 prepay in SLOUGH Hmmmm