PDA

View Full Version : Pumilio Design gear differential for TRF501/511 and DB01/DB01R


mof
26-07-2010, 12:50 PM
Just installed my gear diffs on my TRF501. The diffs are manufactured by Pumilio Design. I have not yet driven them, but they feel very smooth, hopefully they will perform too :woot: On the down-side, at least on my car (TRF501) the front upper deck needed some cutting for the diff to fit, but at least on my opinion, it is not that big of an issue.


Pic.

http://lh5.ggpht.com/_CbsnmK9PWPY/TE2DpLg7n7I/AAAAAAAAADo/PRGIkLW2Tmw/s720/pumilio_diff.JPG

The price is 120 eur for one diff, which equals to slightly more than a new ball diff made with ceramic bearings and balls.

craigosh
26-07-2010, 05:13 PM
How much were they Mof? and who do i speak to about ordering some?

jasonrcb
26-07-2010, 05:27 PM
Im liking the look of those, seriously would be interested in a set if you have more details :thumbsup:

marco NL
26-07-2010, 05:34 PM
looks good

I also want them where to buy:thumbsup:

Jan Larsen
26-07-2010, 06:20 PM
Also interested in where to buy :)

mof
26-07-2010, 08:41 PM
Pm sent.

Mr. Red
26-07-2010, 08:53 PM
Made in Finland?

mof
26-07-2010, 09:01 PM
Made in Finland?

The casing is.

Internal gearing is from an Xray NT1. Outdrives are custom machined Tamiya TRF501 oneway outdrives and the pulley is also a custom machined Tamiya pulley.

fastinfastout
27-07-2010, 01:23 AM
some details on price and where to order them from would be nice.

Lee Martin
27-07-2010, 07:55 AM
look nice!

Smartalec
27-07-2010, 08:02 AM
The website is a bit of a struggle and I can't see them on there at all ........... how do we order? :(

mof
27-07-2010, 08:13 AM
The website is a bit of a struggle and I can't see them on there at all ........... how do we order? :(

PM sent.

mof
27-07-2010, 08:15 AM
look nice!

They feel even nicer :thumbsup:

Too bad I have not yet had the opportunity to test them on the track :cry: But I've heard good things on them from some other drivers.

mof
27-07-2010, 08:41 AM
The price is updated on the first post.

fastinfastout
27-07-2010, 09:24 AM
120 euro?

surely that is a mistype.

a set of gear diffs is going to cost 1.3 times more than a db01r?

mof
27-07-2010, 09:50 AM
120 euro?

surely that is a mistype.

a set of gear diffs is going to cost 1.3 times more than a db01r?

No, it's not a mistype.

I am not the one who makes them, but there are a few factors to this. Firstly, the need to buy the gears, pulleys, oudrives etc for the diffs. Then a quite a bit of custom machining (outdrives and pulleys need custom machining), then there is the whole diff case that needs to be manufactured and so on. And the production rates are low, it is not a mass product.

If you go and buy all the necessary stuff to make a ball diff with ceramic bearings and balls and TRF501/511 outdrives, it will be quite expensive too (the prices are rounded values):

Outdrives, 23 eur
Ceramic balls, 10 eur
Ceramic thrust bearing, 10 eur
Ceramic bearings, 10 eur
Screw and nut, 10 eur
Pulley, 4 eur
Diff plates, 4 eur

The cost comes to around 70 eur for one. So yes, the gear diffs are more expensive. But they are also a different product compared to the mass produced parts that you use for the standard diffs.

And I think it is not right, or fair, to compare the price of an entry level model like the DB01R (which by the way costs around 300 eur in Finland with no tires, wing or body, so in reality around 370 eur with the necessary stuff... taxes, gotta love 'em...) in Hong Kong etc to something custom made, like these diffs.

PS. If you look at the price of mass produced carbon or alloy parts for TRF501/511, you also see a trend of not-as-cheap-as-db01r-would-have-been :) Rear front or rear lower bulkheads. 30 eur. Each (so 120 eur total for the car). 60 eur for the chassis (one piece of carbon fibre), oneway 45 eur, alloy hubs 40 eur / pair and so on, even the body is 45 eur. The diffs don't seem as pricey as if you compare them to the plastic parts of the db01 as if you compare them to the price of the parts for the TRF models...

RBX
27-07-2010, 03:04 PM
What are the advantages over ball diffs?(i had to ask)

Jan Larsen
27-07-2010, 03:46 PM
No maintenance whatsoever once the right oil is found. If its manufactured (and build) correctly...

fastinfastout
27-07-2010, 03:49 PM
I find it very hard that there is hardly any maintenance with gear diffs. Just ask any durango owner, even the spec r owners. Tell me a gear diff that doesnt leak!

mof
27-07-2010, 05:37 PM
Ran a couple of runs today with the diffs. I really, really, like them. :thumbsup:

mof
27-07-2010, 05:38 PM
I find it very hard that there is hardly any maintenance with gear diffs. Just ask any durango owner, even the spec r owners. Tell me a gear diff that doesnt leak!

If durango diffs leak often / a lot, that does not mean that all of them do...

mof
27-07-2010, 05:46 PM
What are the advantages over ball diffs?(i had to ask)

Maintenance free is a bold thing to say, so I'll just say that a lot less maintenance. 100% slip free, which, at least in theory, translates to more precise throttle control. Consistent performance, no need to readjust the diffs. Easier to setup correctly than ball diffs.

I am not saying one can't make a ball diff as good as a gear diff. But I can't, and I can say that my diffs have never been smoother while being slip-free than they are now. :thumbsup:

Jan Larsen
27-07-2010, 05:50 PM
I find it very hard that there is hardly any maintenance with gear diffs. Just ask any durango owner, even the spec r owners. Tell me a gear diff that doesnt leak!

When comparing the durango diffs to 1/8th diffs, its easy to see why. The "o-ring" (if you can call it that) simply isnt up to the task. It dosent help putting washers in between partly because of the design, but mostly because the ring dosent compress like conventional o-rings. 1/8th diffs do not leak because they're build slightly different.
I dont own a durango, but i've seen the diffs up close and personal and I'm sure its only a matter of small tinkering to make the seal work 100%.

mof
30-07-2010, 04:10 AM
The pink DB01R in this vid has these gear differentials, but as the track is very slippery, I am not sure if the video shows any advantage or disadvantage of the diffs... but I decided to post it anyway :woot:

h-8_WFrCgIQ

T4miy4 Guy
30-07-2010, 05:23 AM
Hey Mof

I personally couldn`t tell but nice driving and loved the track ! it had some different kinda jumps i haven`t seen before :woot:.

Keep us up to date with how the geared diff holds up and perform!

Cheers

Andy

Migs
03-08-2010, 06:05 AM
yeah 120 euro per diff is off the chart, i agree it can be justified how they arrive to the pricing, but no way would i even think about it

that vid shows just how well the DB01R's jump that thing just flies over that large jump up the back and lands nicely on the down ramp and was being driven very well, my one is probably the best car ive had in terms of jumping

fastinfastout
03-08-2010, 08:07 AM
apologize for going off topic, but since your on the subject.....

what weight, whether lipo or plus additional weight is a good balance for the db01r?

currently using around 290gram lipos

mof
03-08-2010, 08:31 AM
yeah 120 euro per diff is off the chart, i agree it can be justified how they arrive to the pricing, but no way would i even think about it


Yes, the price is high, and it is everyones own choice wether they want to spend the money on their car or not. I am quite happy with them, no leaks so far, and they are currently in my TRF501, and if I were to buy a DB01R, I would just swap them there, and if I were to buy a 511, I would just put them there. Pretty versatile diffs in that manner. And to lower the initial cost of purchase, I sold my old diffs, which I really don't want anymore. :)

Jan Larsen
03-08-2010, 11:59 AM
mof, tell you contact to check his email. Havent got a reply yet.

mof
03-08-2010, 12:40 PM
mof, tell you contact to check his email. Havent got a reply yet.

I believe he's been on summer holiday. Hopefully he'll answer you soon.

Migs
04-08-2010, 02:35 AM
apologize for going off topic, but since your on the subject.....

what weight, whether lipo or plus additional weight is a good balance for the db01r?

currently using around 290gram lipos

all i tend to do is match the weights left to right, with a 290g lipo, ur electrics should add up to the same amount on the other side of the car, if u do get the other side to balance up to 290 ur car would end up being around 1560g depending on a few other factors. mine started out around 1590g so i put lighter electrics in and a lipo the right weight to balance it up and its now 1515g,which is just above our legal limit here, lightening up the car doesnt seem to have affected the handling, but the car jumps and flies through the air even nicer than it did before

carnage
04-08-2010, 11:34 AM
Hey Mikey, I thought legal weight for 4wd was 1600g

mof
04-08-2010, 12:26 PM
all i tend to do is match the weights left to right, with a 290g lipo, ur electrics should add up to the same amount on the other side of the car, if u do get the other side to balance up to 290 ur car would end up being around 1560g depending on a few other factors. mine started out around 1590g so i put lighter electrics in and a lipo the right weight to balance it up and its now 1515g,which is just above our legal limit here, lightening up the car doesnt seem to have affected the handling, but the car jumps and flies through the air even nicer than it did before

Although this is offtopic, I'll comment on this anyway...

The motor (the heaviest of the electrics apart from the batteries) hangs out quite a bit on the DB01/DB01R, so just having them (lipo and the rest of the electrics) weigh the same does not mean the car is balanced out.

If I remember correctly, the car on the video I posted has around 290g lipo + 60g additional weight on the battery side to balance the car left/right.

burniburn
04-08-2010, 12:30 PM
Where can you order these diffs? Thanks.

mof
04-08-2010, 12:36 PM
Where can you order these diffs? Thanks.


You got a PM.

burniburn
05-08-2010, 08:48 AM
Thanks buddy!:thumbsup:

Welshy40
05-08-2010, 09:33 AM
I preferred gear diffs in my zxr in the 90s on high grip surfaces as they worked better and made the car feel easier to drive. I used different grease thicknesses to better suit the surface. Strange that gear diffs are coming back in a big way. Still way over priced but look great.

mof
10-08-2010, 12:05 PM
Just in case someone ordered these (or use some other gear diffs), remember to readjust your slipper. Remember that gear diffs have zero slip so they will cause more strain to the belts.

Pipi
11-08-2010, 01:08 AM
Is there a site to place an order of these diffs?

mof
11-08-2010, 05:38 AM
Is there a site to place an order of these diffs?

You got a PM.

Jan Larsen
12-08-2010, 09:55 AM
I've just taken delivery of a set of these. They're assembled from the manufacturer and filled with 5000 front and 2000 rear Ultimate oil. Their journey from Finland to Denmark did not present any leak problems. Bearings are included. No manual, so you're a bit on your own if it comes to disassembly, but if you have ever build geardiffs before, you should have no problem.
The diffs will be tested this weekend as they were delivered. The test will be on a fairly bumpy high grip carpet track - basically the biggest punishment possible. The track is known for killing off rear (ball)diffs due to several fast, on-power corners, so this will be a good test I reckon.

mof
12-08-2010, 12:28 PM
I've got zero leaks so far after a couple of weeks runtime with the diffs. I have Ultimate Racing 5000 oils front and 1000 rear, seems to work fine so far :thumbsup:

Compared to my previous setup (front one-way and a ball diff rear) I am able to drive the cars a lot more aggressively and have a lot more control over the car in the air. I realize, of course, that this partly (even mostly) due to having a front diff instead of one-way. Anyway, I have messed up zero jumps with these, which is nice. :)

Jan Larsen
12-08-2010, 12:39 PM
Installation went without a hitch in my 511. No custom filing/dremeling needed. No shimming needed either which was a surprise. They feel great in the car but only time will tell if they perform aswell.

Jan Larsen
14-08-2010, 11:22 PM
Right, first test drive completed. 12 packs of 8 minutes each, so about 1,5 hours worth of driving. And it went a bit like I expected...somewhat.

Good: Durability - These things will last a good while, but not forever (read further down to see why), awesome forward traction, consistency (wont burn out or readjust ifself like ball diffs). Apparently easy on driveshafts aswell, but I did swap the lot for new ones before the test and they showed no wear.
Drive feel was almost excatly like ball diffs, except for the forward drive. The included oils were spot on for the track (high grip carpet). 5000 front, 2000 rear.

Bad: Hard on belts if slipper isnt adjusted just right. First lap, first bit of hard braking and the horrible noise of belt skipping presented itself. Had to tighten the belt one notch. The belt is fairly new and the pulley is obviously all new, so it wasnt a wear problem. Nothing under acceleration.

Did they leak? Well.......yes. They did leak. I noticed about what seemed like half a drop(ish) of fluid on the rear diff outdrives and about the same on the front. The front I left unchanged (for comparison reasons), but the rear I decided to take apart to check its internals and see if I could fix the problem. The internals are just like any other geardiff, so nothing new in that compartment. One thing worth noting here - the spider gears does come in contact with the case, causing some rotating marks. Whether that'll mean anything in the future, I dont know. Time will tell.
I also noted a large amount of play from the outdrives when tugging it when the diff is assembled. This struck me as odd and could be contributing to the leaking.
Took it apart and put a 5x7x0.5mm Schumacher spacer in between the bearing and the o-ring to compress the o-ring a little further and also to bring the crown gear closer the spider gears. This didnt cure the problem, but it sure helped. The diff felt notchy as I reassembled it, but the slop was well and truely gone. Was a little worried about going overboard with the fairly thick spacer, but 11 packs later and the action is now smooth, so it was just a matter of breaking it in. The leaking hasnt been completely stopped but only a very small amount was found under the bearings. Something like a quarter of a drop. I can live with that. The bottom of the car is bone dry. So is the front of the car, despite the heavier amount of leaking. I estimate about 2 drops excaped from the front diff which was left completely unattended throughout the day.
The front diff will need the same solution as the rear, but I ran out of spacers (needed 4, found 3...obviously) so that'll have to wait.

So, are they worth the price? Considering the leaking and play in the outdrives, no. Slash 20-30€ off it, then yes, absolutely.
I'll be using them instead of the ball diffs, but I'll keep the ball diffs for loose surfaces since I have my doubts about geardiffs and slippy surfaces.


http://img39.imageshack.us/img39/7568/back1x.jpghttp://img84.imageshack.us/img84/3233/frontms.jpghttp://img443.imageshack.us/img443/9977/front1w.jpghttp://img5.imageshack.us/img5/1763/backke.jpg
http://img59.imageshack.us/img59/5581/carwxa.jpgNo oil on the chassis.

mof
15-08-2010, 05:32 AM
Great to have some feedback and tips from more experienced drivers than myself. :thumbsup:

PS. I hope you will at least try out the diffs on loose surface and see how they perform, and not just install the ball diffs without even trying the gear diffs out?

Jan Larsen
15-08-2010, 09:56 AM
Of course. Trouble is though; we dont have any tracks that can be considered slippery, they're all carpet tracks.
I'm hoping to get a spot for the worlds in Finland next year. If so, then I'll try them out on dirt/clay, but until then, no.

DaveG28
19-08-2010, 04:51 PM
I could almost get tempted by these but does anyone know if:

a) there is an instruction manual/exploded diagram available

b) can the individual gears/pulleys be bought separately for maintenance?

mole2k
19-08-2010, 05:29 PM
I would be quite tempted by these although does anybody know how they would perform on low grip polished wood with shallow wooden jumps?

I also run the car on very high grip smooth astroturf and carpet jumps. Would you need a different oil in the diffs for this surface or would you get away with using the one set of oil. (currently running rear ball diff and one way front)

Jan Larsen
19-08-2010, 06:32 PM
Dave: No manual/exploding diagram, but they're not rocket science. If you have build geardiffs before, you'll know what to do.

Parts should be available seperately, but I dont see any need for them in the near future. My pulleys on my ball diffs are 1,5 years old and still not worn. The gears are Xray NT1 gears which can be bought everywhere.

Mole: The standard oil works just fine on high grip carpet. I use it and drive the same laptimes as with ball diffs.
A video like you search for is posted on page 1 or 2 in this thread.

mof
19-08-2010, 07:26 PM
I would be quite tempted by these although does anybody know how they would perform on low grip polished wood with shallow wooden jumps?


The video I posted earlier is of a very low grip track, and the car is a DB01R with 5000 oils in front diff and 1000 rear.

mof
19-08-2010, 07:30 PM
I could almost get tempted by these but does anyone know if:

a) there is an instruction manual/exploded diagram available

b) can the individual gears/pulleys be bought separately for maintenance?

a) No, since it is a custom product, but the diffs are very simple. If you were to change the pulley, though, you need to be carefull when tightening the new one so you won't bend the aluminium ring that presses on to the pulley (I am not talking about the big blue part, but there is a smaller/thinner ring on the inside), and make sure that the screws stay correctly on the threads as the thread is quite open.

b) As Jan already said, the gears are from an Xray NT1. The pulleys are standard Tamiya ones but custom machined (the center hole has been opened quite a bit). The pulley, if you would need a new one, could be customized at home or your workplace etc if you have proper tools for it, or you can of course buy a spare with the diffs.

mof
02-09-2010, 02:26 AM
A slight update. The increased strain on the rear belt is starting to show, I need to replace the belt and possibly center pulley for the rear belt too, remains to be seen. Are there aluminium center pulleys available?

Other than that, the diffs are still working nicely. Only a small amount of leaking that I can live with. The chassis remains dry and clean so no issues there. I've changed to 3000/1000 oils for our track (I used to have 5000/1000), seems to work fine for me at least.

Jan Larsen
05-09-2010, 04:49 PM
Finally got a chance to testfit one of these in a TRF416. Its not a drop in fit, but the modification required is actually very easy. All you have to do is put approx 1,5mm of diffspacers on each side between the diff and diffbearings. Very simple to do and it will work.

Also, as mof, I've had to replace the rear belt and center pulley recently. Both were about 6 months old.

marco NL
28-01-2011, 11:32 AM
hey guys

someone has already tried a spec-r diff to make it fit for 511

or is it not possible ???


Thanks marco

simoncrabb
28-01-2011, 11:35 AM
Noooo, don't buy gear diffs. Buy Lazy Balls! Put food on our table!

Actually, I love the durango gear diffs, one less thing to think about on race day.

marco NL
28-01-2011, 11:46 AM
hi

I've been using Ceramic Diff Balls

_valtsu_
28-01-2011, 01:54 PM
hey guys

someone has already tried a spec-r diff to make it fit for 511

or is it not possible ???


Thanks marco

It is possible, but it's not so easy. Pictures are from my car.

Front:
https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/_UpLguEpuDtQ/TULHL2ok-kI/AAAAAAAAAMs/XnLRR2PDcvQ/s640/Diff1.JPG
Outdrives are made from these (http://www.amainhobbies.com/product_info.php/cPath/1_25_1460_232/products_id/5211/n/Kyosho-Wheel-Shaft-2-ZX-5).

Rear:
https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/_UpLguEpuDtQ/TULHMARc49I/AAAAAAAAAMw/lMEuLASwmnU/s640/Diff2.JPG

marco NL
28-01-2011, 02:18 PM
yo mate

Thanks mate for the pictures

do you have more details what jou must change

and a part list what i need

Thanks marco

_valtsu_
28-01-2011, 02:43 PM
I'll try some day, when I have more time.

MHeadling
28-01-2011, 02:47 PM
Discostu on here ran the gear spec r diffs in his 501, they lasted about 2 weeks, they were only running on 13.5 motors indoors.

I would steer clear of them from what I have seen, Lee Martin seems to go well with ball diffs! :p

marco NL
28-01-2011, 03:06 PM
so they are not strong enough???

Jan Larsen
28-01-2011, 03:12 PM
They're plastic all over, including the gears, which I suspeect could be a weak point on landings. That said, it holds up just fine in my touring car with a 4,5T bolted in.

Fabs
02-04-2011, 09:50 PM
I believe Spec-R has released a diff for the TA05 which should be a direct fit for the TRF 511/501X :thumbsup:

fastinfastout
03-04-2011, 01:48 AM
I think gear diffs are overated for offroad.

I have also heard people breaking belts regularly, so they really are not maintenance free.

Jan Larsen
03-04-2011, 10:09 AM
I wouldnt say regularly, but yes, they do require replacement every once in a while. The front belt lasted all last season and got replaced before this season got underway, the rear was changed once last year and again before this season began. I expect to replace it again mid-summer(ish).
I've learned that if you tighten the belt one notch more than you'd do with normal diffs, they last longer. It also makes the car accelerate harder.
At local race meetings I normally race both 2WD and 4WD on the same day which makes for a hectic schedule. I dont have the time nor the energy to re-do both diff in the 511 during the day so in that regard, the geardiffs are perfect.

Fabs
03-04-2011, 10:38 AM
Belts wear anyway, but when my rear diff lasts at best 1 training session before it needs rebuilding, and even then halfway through the session it's very gritty already, then I'd rather use gear diffs for training and put the ball diffs for racing.

fastinfastout
03-04-2011, 10:48 AM
how do you find the car with gear diffs?

I know the onroad guys love it, but took a bit of time to get use to. I'm still a little skeptical on the gear diff usage for offroad however. I own a durango, and I dont know if the car would perform better with ball diffs.

Jan Larsen
03-04-2011, 06:28 PM
My times are as fast or faster with geardiffs compared to normal diffs. We just had a major local race take place where me and my teammate were the fastest on track with 16.835 (me) and 16.806 (him) where I was running geardiffs and he ran normal diffs, so laptime wise, its about the same. The surface was high grip carpet. Only 1 other driver dipped below the 17 sec mark (Jonas Kaerup, former TC Euro Champ).

Unless we see loose dirt any time soon in this country, I'll never go back to normal diffs in my 4WD.

max1973
08-04-2011, 09:20 AM
Hi Guys my Name is max from Austria and i am very interestet on these geradiffs!!
Can i have a PM where i can order the Geardiff´s!!
Thanks Max

t8rtot
05-06-2011, 04:06 AM
How are these diffs holding up? Anyone gone back to their regular diffs?

t8rtot
08-06-2011, 09:32 PM
is it just me or does it seem like if your not a regular poster on here then your questions go unanswered on oople?? i've posted multiple times in various threads but never seem to get a response, its been this way for 2yrs now.. :cry:

it seemed like quite a few were using these diffs but now its like they never happened?

Jan Larsen
09-06-2011, 04:53 PM
I'm still using them. However, at the recent Nordics I had to switch to the normal ball diffs because of a very unusual tracl surface. Astroturf with long hair, high bite and bumpy. A surface that was terrible to drive on and the only place where I've felt the normal diffs outperformed the geardiffs.
The remaining rounds in our national championship is regular carpet where I'll be using the geardiffs again.