PDA

View Full Version : 511 or 502?


mattybucks
19-10-2010, 01:38 PM
Who's going to be getting a 502 and who going to keep running a 511?

feniks
19-10-2010, 02:17 PM
in the beginning I will keep running the 511 and put them back to back and compare them if the 502 is reliyebel and has the same pase I micht change.

marco NL
19-10-2010, 02:53 PM
I will keep running the 511 and go test the 502 and if that is better I go for the TRF502:D

AndrewCaunt
19-10-2010, 03:22 PM
Ashleys going to keep 511X i dont think you can better the car.:thumbsup:

Jan Larsen
19-10-2010, 04:24 PM
I'm keeping my 511 for two reasons. 1: I got loads(!) of spares and 2: I hate shaft drive because of the torque steer. And its the best handling 4WD I've ever had.

Smartalec
19-10-2010, 04:27 PM
Ashleys going to keep 511X i dont think you can better the car.:thumbsup:
What's the X stand for Andy? :confused:

sime46
19-10-2010, 05:34 PM
Its a kiss. Hes an affectionate soul!:wub:thumbsup:

AaronR
19-10-2010, 06:16 PM
I am staying 511. :wub Nearly all of my racing is indoors.

_valtsu_
19-10-2010, 07:09 PM
Belt drive is better for drive on my driving style. So I'm not going to buy 502.

I ran one final after this picture, so it has to be reliable. :)
http://lh4.ggpht.com/_UpLguEpuDtQ/TL3r9WT5GnI/AAAAAAAAAJ4/JiMn3sBc4Kw/s640/tamiya.JPG

Smartalec
19-10-2010, 08:59 PM
Belt drive is better for drive on my driving style. So I'm not going to buy 502.

I ran one final after this picture, so it has to be reliable. :)
http://lh4.ggpht.com/_UpLguEpuDtQ/TL3r9WT5GnI/AAAAAAAAAJ4/JiMn3sBc4Kw/s640/tamiya.JPG
Jesus, I never realised that racing in sewers was popular :)

Smartalec
19-10-2010, 09:02 PM
I'm staying with the 511 unless anyone can prove to me that the 502 will be better. I loved driving the B44 and i'm sure that the 502 will be similar but I absolutely have a ball driving my 511 so i'm sure it's here to stay for quite some time :thumbsup:

mattybucks
19-10-2010, 09:05 PM
Jesus, I never realised that racing in sewers was popular :)

I like the mud effect chassis

stegger
19-10-2010, 10:48 PM
Belt drive is better for drive on my driving style. So I'm not going to buy 502.

I ran one final after this picture, so it has to be reliable. :)
http://lh4.ggpht.com/_UpLguEpuDtQ/TL3r9WT5GnI/AAAAAAAAAJ4/JiMn3sBc4Kw/s640/tamiya.JPG


Quality mate, hardcore !!! I remember my gold bathtub RC10 coming like that at a northern league meeting in southport years ago. :thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:

Fabs
20-10-2010, 06:25 AM
Sticking with the 511 for the time being, I got it because it's belt driven and I'm not interested in getting another shaft car.

Belsten
21-10-2010, 08:05 PM
both :woot:

Funkymojo
21-10-2010, 08:13 PM
I'm keeping my 511 for two reasons. 1: I got loads(!) of spares and 2: I hate shaft drive because of the torque steer. And its the best handling 4WD I've ever had.

I agree with you that the 511 is one of the best handling 4WD ever :thumbsup: and yes no matter what, there'll always be torque steer on shaft drive...

DaveG28
21-10-2010, 09:40 PM
both :woot:

:thumbsup::thumbsup:

mikeyscott
18-11-2010, 12:24 PM
Tempted to change from a Cat SX to a 511, never really driven a shaft based car, so interested about this torque steer.... :confused:

Welshy40
18-11-2010, 01:40 PM
Unlike Dave im sticking to the 511. I can easily destroy a shaft car but not so easy with this.

Jan Larsen
18-11-2010, 01:52 PM
Tempted to change from a Cat SX to a 511, never really driven a shaft based car, so interested about this torque steer.... :confused:

I did exactly that about 1,5 years ago, best decision ever.

Torque steer is mostly noticeably in onroad, but on carpet, it can also be felt in offroad. When you apply a lot of throttle on a high grip surface, the car tends to steer to a side (which one depends on motor location) on its own, much like a 1:1 FWD car with too much power. To combat this, they started to make belt driven cars in TC and not long after offroad followed. And this was when we still raced with brushed motors - imagine today where we have brushless motors with 3 times the torque.

MattADH
18-11-2010, 02:14 PM
The best way to understand this is to pick the car up from underneath and hold it in your hand. If you pull the throttle hard, you will feel the car and pivot in your hand wanting to pull the front up. If you grab the brake, teh front will go down. With a shaft drive, the car will pivot to one side when you pull the throttle hard...

Think thats about right - hope it helps...

simoncrabb
18-11-2010, 02:16 PM
I'm wondering why Tamiya have decided to do a shaft car now?

mikeyscott
18-11-2010, 02:18 PM
Many thanks to you both for the clarification.

Certainly intersting to know

muratti
18-11-2010, 04:49 PM
I'm wondering why Tamiya have decided to do a shaft car now?

I am sure not all Race tracks worldwide are High grip surfaces. Mine is dirt and medium grip or loose depends on the weather and i never felt that torque steer you guys are talking about but i believe that on carpet it can be much more noticeable.
In the end i think we all have to buy the car that is the quickest for the individual driver. I personally am not good enough to notice that i would be much slower on my own track with a belt or shaft driven car because i simply make too many mistakes.
I think both the 502X and 511 are superb cars. I find it relaxing to just be able to buy both technologies from the best quality manufacturer i know and have the safety not to have done anything wrong :)

RBX
18-11-2010, 05:33 PM
I wonder if torque steer is less noticeable with brushless motors(they have lower inertia at start up) when compared to brushed motors...hmmm

Jan Larsen
18-11-2010, 06:37 PM
Quite the opposite. The sheer amount of torque would simply triple the effect that we saw from the brushed motor era. Of course, this only applies in modified classes.

DaveG28
18-11-2010, 07:06 PM
I think some of these effects need separating out to be honest. Whilst I'm sure you do get the effects mentioned please bear in mind:

1. The drivetrain centre assembly/shafts spin in the opposite direction to the motor making a partial offset?

2. The up/down you can notice in your hands on belt drive isn't only the motor, you have 4 big wheels, driveshafts etc still doing all that, you'll still have plenty of nose attitude throttle adjustment available over jumps

3. People on here make it sound like shaft drive is a disaster due to torque steer, remember the last 3 worlds at least have been won by shaft cars, and on the higher grip uk tracks before 2010 the last 3 national series winners at least were shaft drive, at least as far as I recall?

So I would have thought any problems would be pretty minimal to be honest!

Jan Larsen
18-11-2010, 07:24 PM
Yes, its not very noticable in offroad as various results show, but onroad is a different matter. Only highly skilled or experienced drivers will notice it.

Funkymojo
18-11-2010, 07:32 PM
I've seen both the 511 and 502X. In terms of bling bling ali parts, the 511 beats the 502X hands down. As all 511 owners would know, the 511 handles like a dream, it drives very well. As for the 502, i'm sure it will handle just as well. The belt vs shaft debate has been going on for ages. Belt drive cars are generally more forgiving in terms of handling and power delivery compared to a shaft drive (well, maybe that's just me). I think it all boils down to driving style, both the 511 and 502X are great cars, just get the one that suits your driving style. :thumbsup:

muratti
18-11-2010, 08:30 PM
I think it all boils down to driving style, both the 511 and 502X are great cars, just get the one that suits your driving style. :thumbsup:

Just as i would have said it! :)

Funkymojo
18-11-2010, 08:44 PM
I did exactly that about 1,5 years ago, best decision ever.

Torque steer is mostly noticeably in onroad, but on carpet, it can also be felt in offroad. When you apply a lot of throttle on a high grip surface, the car tends to steer to a side (which one depends on motor location) on its own, much like a 1:1 FWD car with too much power. To combat this, they started to make belt driven cars in TC and not long after offroad followed. And this was when we still raced with brushed motors - imagine today where we have brushless motors with 3 times the torque.

For most part i agree with you but i can't agree on the part where you said "they started to make belt driven cars in TC and not long after offroad followed." Belt drive 4wd buggies have been around for a long time. All the great 4wd buggies of old like the Schumacher CAT, Yokomo Super Dog Fighter, Kyosho Optima Mid and Lazer ZX..etc were belt driven. During that time period, the only prominent company that used shaft drive on their 4wd buggies was Tamiya with their Hot Shot, Avante, Egress, Top Force... :)

Jan Larsen
18-11-2010, 09:28 PM
Cant argue with you about that since I have no experience with cars going that far back. But I most likely stand corrected :)

Colinevan
18-11-2010, 11:07 PM
Slightly off topic, and purely on a handling terms only. What is the main difference between the handling on a 501 and 511 then?

Thanks

Col.

Fabs
19-11-2010, 12:02 AM
I think some of these effects need separating out to be honest. Whilst I'm sure you do get the effects mentioned please bear in mind:

1. The drivetrain centre assembly/shafts spin in the opposite direction to the motor making a partial offset?

2. The up/down you can notice in your hands on belt drive isn't only the motor, you have 4 big wheels, driveshafts etc still doing all that, you'll still have plenty of nose attitude throttle adjustment available over jumps

3. People on here make it sound like shaft drive is a disaster due to torque steer, remember the last 3 worlds at least have been won by shaft cars, and on the higher grip uk tracks before 2010 the last 3 national series winners at least were shaft drive, at least as far as I recall?

So I would have thought any problems would be pretty minimal to be honest!

The worlds being won by shaft cars is mostly due to the fact that there are more shaft cars being raced than belt, and it also very highly depends on who's driving what, which hasn't got much to do with whether it's belt or shaft. The last worlds are a perfect example...

The reason why shaft is so popular is the maintenance, and that's all there is to it. Come race on european tracks, and you'll realise how dusty most of them are and how very quickly an open belt drivetrain will get destroyed.

Torque steer I agree is barely noticeable on an off road car, that is mainly due to the high contact patch, the track width and the nature of the grip provided by the tyres, it's hugely noticeable on TC's due, again to the size of the contact patch, track width and type of grip (plus there's more traction with TC in most cases).

DaveG28
19-11-2010, 02:31 AM
The worlds being won by shaft cars is mostly due to the fact that there are more shaft cars being raced than belt, and it also very highly depends on who's driving what, which hasn't got much to do with whether it's belt or shaft. The last worlds are a perfect example...

The reason why shaft is so popular is the maintenance, and that's all there is to it. Come race on european tracks, and you'll realise how dusty most of them are and how very quickly an open belt drivetrain will get destroyed.

Torque steer I agree is barely noticeable on an off road car, that is mainly due to the high contact patch, the track width and the nature of the grip provided by the tyres, it's hugely noticeable on TC's due, again to the size of the contact patch, track width and type of grip (plus there's more traction with TC in most cases).

I wasn't arguing shaft is better, just that it can't be much worse as it keeps winning, and plenty of companies who know what they're doing use it. To read some posts on here since the 502 was announced, you'd think shaft cars were undriveable! I just think there's probably very little in it!

Funkymojo
19-11-2010, 04:57 AM
Slightly off topic, and purely on a handling terms only. What is the main difference between the handling on a 501 and 511 then?

Thanks

Col.

Having driven both cars, the 501 is a very neutral handling car. It's stable and slightly sluggish in the corners. The 511 is just as stable but it's more responsive and twitchier. It goes in and out of corners faster.

Colinevan
19-11-2010, 11:35 AM
Having driven both cars, the 501 is a very neutral handling car. It's stable and slightly sluggish in the corners. The 511 is just as stable but it's more responsive and twitchier. It goes in and out of corners faster.

Thanks :thumbsup:

tahe
21-11-2010, 02:21 PM
Can anyone say how much of torque drive is due to the engine being placed longitudinally?

I just built an Egress and I was fascinated by the driveshaft running from an elevated positions in the back to a very low position in the front.

I'm starting to wonder whether you could raise the spur gear and use a 90 degree angle to build a shaft driven car with the motor in a belt car position and how that would drive.

quarter throttle
21-11-2010, 06:49 PM
definately keeping my 511 i absolutely love it <3 :woot:

might get a 502 to try .. all depends whether dad will let me :lol:

Ash

sime46
21-11-2010, 07:39 PM
No brainer for me either. 511 is the absolute nuts. Great car.

F1END
06-12-2010, 01:13 PM
I'm considering upgrading my DB01 basher to a proper racing car, but I'd like to hear from people who have driven both the 502 and 511 (preferably Lee Martin ;))exactly what the difference in handling is (if any).

I understand the potential 'torque steer' issues, but does it actually make a noticeable difference? Is there more acceleration from the shaft drive?

I'm leaning towards the 511 mainly because of the amount of shared parts with the DB01, which I'll be keeping for bashing, but the 511 seems much harder to find right now.

Lee Martin
06-12-2010, 02:53 PM
Howdy.

once i have run the 511 and the 502 back to back i will have a detailed comparison...

Until then, you cant go wrong with either of them, the 511 was and still is a fantastic car and the 502 seems to be following in its footsteps!!!

Lee

polz
08-12-2010, 08:16 AM
i will keep my 511, but i cant say that the 502 isnt better or will be, i never drived a shaft car in offroad.

mikeyscott
11-12-2010, 05:36 PM
Howdy.

once i have run the 511 and the 502 back to back i will have a detailed comparison...

Until then, you cant go wrong with either of them, the 511 was and still is a fantastic car and the 502 seems to be following in its footsteps!!!

Lee

Do the 502 and 511 share a reasonable number of parts? Haven't touched my511 since getting it from Kifo as need a micro server etc and another of other things. Hopefully it'll get a test run before Petit! :(

muratti
12-12-2010, 09:43 AM
Well parts in the driveline differ much from the 511, that is obvious being a shaft driven car. Also Front Hinge pins are of a different length. You can use the suspension parts basically which includes all shims, washer, rear hinge pins, Uprights, Castor blocks etc.