PDA

View Full Version : TRF-511 -The end of the road?


james54321
28-07-2011, 09:51 AM
i am a happy 511 owner however after the recent IFMAR championships, i cannot help but think Tamiya are going to push for the 502x development.. I am not just talking about where Lee came (which i think was very respectable), it was more to do with the overwhelming majority of shaft driven cars in the top tiers. Even in Europe the Team Associated b44.1 (which lets be honest has a fair few similarities with the 502x) takes up a large chunk of the final groups.. This is not a debate of shaft vs belt but just wondering that if the 502x could be developed just like the 501x was (and here is another one would you prefer to drive a 501 or a 502x?), Tamiya could have another great car on their hands just like the 511 is/was. Maybe Lee could answer this one but from a business model point of view Tamiya surely need to develop the 502x and have their top drivers racing it considering they don't even produce (or if they do in small numbers) the 511 anymore..

apologies if this seems a bit of a rant but just wanted to share my thoughts and see what everyone else thinks..

mattybucks
28-07-2011, 10:10 AM
I think it's the 502 that at the end of the road. People on here have been trying to sell them for weeks.

511's are still in great demand with people still paying top money for the awesome kit. I also think that Tamiya/Lee are developing a few new parts for the 511 (I'm sure Lee will confirm).

The 511 is already the UK National Champion (2 years running now) Current European Championship winning car (also at Finland).

Don't forget the new double WC was at the top of his game. That does not mean that the B44.1 is the better car, just the driver was on form and the conditions were more suited to that car.

Unless Tamiya bring out a new 4wd car, or Lee moves to a different team then I can't see him using any other car for the forseeable future.

Jamie.T
28-07-2011, 10:15 AM
I certainly think it would be great if Tamiya developed the 502 and brought it along like the belt driven cars were. The 502 is a very capable car with some minor adjustments, however i think the 511 will take some beating, especially on tracks here in the UK and parts of Europe.

Each car suits a surface type better than another, and it was clear to see at the Worlds that the shaft driven cars got it done, but that's not to say they were better cars as Lee was right up there amongst them with the belt driven 511.

I would certainly like to see Lee running the 502 and comparing his times with the 511 on some of the tracks hes visited, that is the only way to really see the difference. Ive run my 502 and 511 back to back and found the 511 faster, but with time and development the 502 could be as fast. Lets see what happens in the future....

dbizzle5
28-07-2011, 10:15 AM
If Lee starts using the 502x again then they would all of a sudden be the car to have again and the band wagon would be a rollin....

West Ridge Racing
28-07-2011, 10:43 AM
Well, in My opinion the 511 is all time best car I have driven and talking results from the wc Dustin evans did a great job with that old xxx4. I hope that Tamiya see this trend from over here in Europe and keep the 511 alive. I have heard that the 502 was made to compete against kyoshos and yokomos in Japan where they have ā huge market. The 511 was not as popular there as it is here. If they start copying Fredriks diff covers they would easily sell a lot more of 511s. I for one.

Alfie
28-07-2011, 11:54 AM
I certainly think it would be great if Tamiya developed the 502 and brought it along like the belt driven cars were. The 502 is a very capable car with some minor adjustments, however i think the 511 will take some beating, especially on tracks here in the UK and parts of Europe.

Each car suits a surface type better than another, and it was clear to see at the Worlds that the shaft driven cars got it done, but that's not to say they were better cars as Lee was right up there amongst them with the belt driven 511.

I would certainly like to see Lee running the 502 and comparing his times with the 511 on some of the tracks hes visited, that is the only way to really see the difference. Ive run my 502 and 511 back to back and found the 511 faster, but with time and development the 502 could be as fast. Lets see what happens in the future....

Watch this space:p

dobber
28-07-2011, 12:40 PM
I run the 502X and its a fantastic car. I'd love for it to be developed more with a few more hop ups and support. It works extreamly well on the grasstrack i race at.

DaveG28
28-07-2011, 12:43 PM
Unfortunately I am not as convinced that that the 502 just needs ambit of fettling to be as good as a 511, although it can be close!

The issue is I think a fair amount of parts need remoulding, and that's not cheap! It really needs the front tower to match the kickup angle, and personally I think part of what makes the 511 so good is that the steering is also angled with the front suspension. To do that on the 502 needs new chassis/gearbox case moulds. Plus the the camber links need redesigning (although there is a workaround for this!)....a lot of work!

Finally, strength, I didn't do a single bulkhead or front tower at the worlds, I genuinely believe I would have done 3-5 front gearbox cases with the 502...@Ģ100!!

Still, I do think the 502 can do plenty quick laps!!

Plus, as someone said, if Lee used the 502 and won Southport we'd probably see everyone trying to buy one!!! I may still get another too as I like the new bling!!

chrispattinson
28-07-2011, 01:03 PM
From speedtech models:


Hi Chris,
The ETA on 511 kits is late August. That's the word from Tamiya America.

Thanks for inquiring,

Jeff Yung
Speedtech R/C

KyleHirano
28-07-2011, 01:12 PM
I think the 511 and the 502, are both capable of winning the worlds, and are top notch buggies. I just think AE has top drivers, and they spend a lot of money on a race team. AE spends more money advertising and putting together a dream team of racers. AE kits lack quality because of it.

Belts rule, shafts suck

Just my opinion.:thumbsup:

Welshy40
28-07-2011, 01:35 PM
If I was from TRF I would question why the guys are still running the older models instead of using the newer kits. My guess is the shaft drive isnt a quality product as Lee would be running it.

Maybe they should keep developing the 511 as there are items on the car that were badly designed in the first place like the stupid slop on the hubs (this makes a huge difference on handling), badly positioned spur gear so not easy when it strips, cheap quality bearings and by redesigning and upgrading them they may actually get a worlds win.

fastinfastout
28-07-2011, 02:05 PM
If I was from TRF I would question why the guys are still running the older models instead of using the newer kits. My guess is the shaft drive isnt a quality product as Lee would be running it.

Maybe they should keep developing the 511 as there are items on the car that were badly designed in the first place like the stupid slop on the hubs (this makes a huge difference on handling), badly positioned spur gear so not easy when it strips, cheap quality bearings and by redesigning and upgrading them they may actually get a worlds win.
would gluing the bearings on the hub be a quick fix? What I did was score the inside of the hub with a knife.

I noticed this on my db01r, but not so on my 511, not as much anyway!

KyleHirano
28-07-2011, 02:23 PM
I'm running a DB01r and there is a lot of slop in the hubs. Bearings just fall out of them even when new?

TRF201 aluminum rear hubs are a great improvement over the plastic ones.

Does someone make a geared diff for the 511 or DB01r?

GRIFF55
28-07-2011, 07:05 PM
I have to agree with Amish (daveg28) , the 502 can do amazingly fast laps but just not as consistent as are possible with the 511. Thus making the 511 way easier to drive for mere mortals like us.
Also got to say, if something was released with all the sexy 502 new bling, i'd be tempted too.

The 511 is a VERY VERY good car, it has got itself on quite a high platform to be beaten...

DCM
28-07-2011, 10:08 PM
Dunno if it is the different material used in the TRF/DB01R, but on the stock DB01 items, the only play I get, is from the bearings when they wear.

Fredrik Emilsson
28-07-2011, 11:01 PM
The issue is I think a fair amount of parts need remoulding, and that's not cheap! It really needs the front tower to match the kickup angle


Donīt think the angle of the tower is that important. I agree that the bulkhead/shock mount is a bit too far back though.

I wouldīnt worry about future cars, bet Tamiya listens to the factory drivers...

DaveG28
28-07-2011, 11:33 PM
Donīt think the angle of the tower is that important. I agree that the bulkhead/shock mount is a bit too far back though.

I wouldīnt worry about future cars, bet Tamiya listens to the factory drivers...

I know the angle in itself is technically not important, the issue is even when you spacer the tower forward the angle difference makes it very difficult no to bind the top of the shocks, there is still no forward/backward movement. If you spac it forward to give he movement, the shock is again at. Different angle to the arm....mayb it's nothing, but I like loose shocks!

Welshy40
29-07-2011, 05:55 AM
would gluing the bearings on the hub be a quick fix? What I did was score the inside of the hub with a knife.

I noticed this on my db01r, but not so on my 511, not as much anyway!

Why, I mean why should you as you have already paid a much higher price for this car and it should have been designed properly before selling it. Tamiya has always been over priced so youd expect them to do it correctly before selling it. I would buy it again but only if it has decent bearings, zero slop, a slipper clutch and spur that are on one side of the car (similar design to the YZ10) so maintenance can be done easily and messing pinion/spur will be easier as well.

ottoswe
29-07-2011, 07:18 AM
Regarding Lee and the 511 at worlds, he won the practise a final and the car looked awesome, but Lee was 'alone' with his car and setup. Marc and Viktor is great talents but i think in a worlds you would perfer the offroad knowledge from lets say the ae team with 10 top level electric offroad drivers.

Belt is the way to go and Lee did an amazing job!

mattybucks
29-07-2011, 07:25 AM
Why, I mean why should you as you have already paid a much higher price for this car and it should have been designed properly before selling it. Tamiya has always been over priced so youd expect them to do it correctly before selling it. I would buy it again but only if it has decent bearings, zero slop, a slipper clutch and spur that are on one side of the car (similar design to the YZ10) so maintenance can be done easily and messing pinion/spur will be easier as well.


The car is easy to work on, maintenance is a dream compared to other cars I've had. 4 screws to get the diffs out, true the slipper shaft is probably the hardest part of the car to remove but it still easy to do. I've not mover the motor or changed the spur for about 6 months.

Welshy40
29-07-2011, 10:24 AM
I agree this is probably the best car out there and if you take away the wishbone the best chassis design by far and as you said easy access to the diffs but the let down is the layshaft slipper design, and hate to say it but was designed by someone who doesnt race or have a clue which is not the way to go.

I got through quite a few spur gears and was a pain to replace whereas if they designed it like the YZ10 where the spur was on the side and the spur could be removed and replaced in twenty seconds and also meshing was simple to do unlike the 511 which I had to give to Kevin Moore to do for me as I just couldnt get it right.

lewis
29-07-2011, 12:06 PM
I agree this is probably the best car out there and if you take away the wishbone the best chassis design by far and as you said easy access to the diffs but the let down is the layshaft slipper design, and hate to say it but was designed by someone who doesnt race or have a clue which is not the way to go.

I got through quite a few spur gears and was a pain to replace whereas if they designed it like the YZ10 where the spur was on the side and the spur could be removed and replaced in twenty seconds and also meshing was simple to do unlike the 511 which I had to give to Kevin Moore to do for me as I just couldnt get it right.
Iv'e heard it all now, Tamiya employ a complete idiot to redesign the 501 into the 511 and you had to get Kevin Moore to mesh the gears for you as it is so hard to do....God help me... Have you thought about knitting:thumbsup:

fastinfastout
29-07-2011, 12:42 PM
Iv'e heard it all now, Tamiya employ a complete idiot to redesign the 501 into the 511 and you had to get Kevin Moore to mesh the gears for you as it is so hard to do....God help me... Have you thought about knitting:thumbsup:
knitting has its obstacles too.......a prick could lead to an infection:o

KyleHirano
29-07-2011, 01:06 PM
Regarding Lee and the 511 at worlds, he won the practise a final and the car looked awesome, but Lee was 'alone' with his car and setup. Marc and Viktor is great talents but i think in a worlds you would perfer the offroad knowledge from lets say the ae team with 10 top level electric offroad drivers.

Belt is the way to go and Lee did an amazing job!

I agree, its hard to compete when your going against the dream team that is AE, who probally had 20+ guys swapping setups. That's OK because Tamiya is 20 times higher quality, than anything AE has.

I'm a firm believer that belts are faster than shafts (my opinion), I believe shaft is so popular because it allows your drivetrain to be enclosed, where a belt takes takes a little more engineering to enclose it, most arent, Belts are more prone to problems.

mattybucks
29-07-2011, 01:13 PM
Iv'e heard it all now, Tamiya employ a complete idiot to redesign the 501 into the 511 and you had to get Kevin Moore to mesh the gears for you as it is so hard to do....God help me... Have you thought about knitting:thumbsup:

Lew, you've hit the nail on the head. It's easy to mesh it correctly, and I don't care that it takes 5 minutes to swap the spur. The car works, and thats the end of it.

The XX4 now thats a car that's a nightmare to work on!! If you do a spur or snap a belt at a meeting you had might as well just go home.

bzb
29-07-2011, 01:52 PM
the funny ting is now many people just buy a b44.1 just because it has won an tink its the best for everybody :thumbsup:

DCM
29-07-2011, 02:08 PM
FFS, in the advent of brushless motors, how often do you REALLY need to mesh your motor? It can't be any harder than a DB-01!! Mine is on the original spur gear, meshing isn't that hard either, to be honest!! Picking flaws in a car with maybe only minor blemishes!

KyleHirano
29-07-2011, 02:40 PM
Wrenching and fixing my RC, is fun and part of the addiction. :lol: no joke

Difficult spur gear access can be frustrating, but DCM is right,it's not that hard to set-up your gear mesh, the DB01 diffs aren't exactly easy to access either, but I deal with it because I like Tamiya, and let's face it every rc I've owned had something that I felt could be improved. There is no perfect buggy that can please everyone.

KyleHirano
29-07-2011, 02:48 PM
I would like Tamiya to stick with just one 4x4 buggy, like all the other companies due, they have 3 current platforms, 502, 511, and the DB01.
If they could just concentrate on one, I think team tamiya would be better off. otherwise your always second guessing yourself.

Like the worlds, I bet it crossed Lees mind maybe he should of ran the 502?

West Ridge Racing
29-07-2011, 02:58 PM
Like the worlds, I bet it crossed Lees mind maybe he should of ran the 502?

Do not think that. He probably thought he would of wanted more practise time on clay/dirt. He won the warm up after all:)

Chris
29-07-2011, 03:19 PM
Does someone make a geared diff for the 511 or DB01r?

Yes, Tamiya

james54321
08-08-2011, 09:24 PM
There have been an awful lot of people trying to sell there 511's on the forum here the last couple of weeks...
Is there something I don't know about? a 511 worlds edition coming out soon?...... Let's hope.. :)

DaveG28
08-08-2011, 10:10 PM
There's a thread about it on here, 42213 part number!

Dalton
08-08-2011, 10:25 PM
TAM42213 (http://www.hlj.com/product/TAM42213)TamiyaTRF TRF511 (Gear Diff Unit) (http://www.hlj.com/product/TAM42213)
http://www.hlj.com/graphics/futurerelease-s.gif Aug. Release (http://www.hlj.com/info/futurerelease.html)
8,600

42213 is the geared diff unit due for release this month

Fabs
08-08-2011, 10:39 PM
WOOP WOOP I'm a happy chappy !!!:thumbsup:

West Ridge Racing
10-08-2011, 06:50 PM
Best news ever! Now I can stop thinking of buying that Dex410 that I really never wanted. Geardiff dilemma solved.

bzb
10-08-2011, 07:53 PM
whats so good with the gear diff?

Fabs
10-08-2011, 11:03 PM
On my track the 511 diffs last about 4 runs before they need rebuilding... That's what's good about the geared diffs :thumbsup:

bzb
11-08-2011, 05:44 AM
ok tanks, i've never got issieus with the diff so far, tought there was someting else so special about gear diffs

james54321
23-08-2011, 05:14 PM
Well judging by the release of hop up parts for the 502x this month, including the new aluminium steering bridge, makes me think tamiya isn't throwing the towel in on the 502x either at the moment..
Let's hope the gear diffs for the 511 isn't one last 'gift' from tamiya and just the start...

DaveG28
23-08-2011, 11:11 PM
Tamiya USA seems to have new stock of 511's in recently (well, they showed out of stock, now they show in), still not 100% myself whether they are doing another 511 release with the diffs, or just gear diffs...seems like both cars stay current for now!

It'll be interesting to see if the new steering bridge can be flipped to run forwards without dremelling..., if not, suggests to me they are just doing bling for the 502, and the 511 is still getting the good stuff!!

james54321
05-11-2011, 01:19 PM
It finally seems the 511 has run its course and tamiya are pushing the 502x..
So much for the 511 worlds edition.. just a standard 511 with separate gear diff :(

Lee seems to be forging ahead now with the 502x..

a.m
06-11-2011, 08:02 AM
So, he has been told to by Tamiya then, SAD...

F1END
06-11-2011, 10:05 AM
So, he has been told to by Tamiya then, SAD...

I wouldn't jump to any conclusions just yet, but it does seem that way.

Would be nice to hear from Lee on this. He seemed to do OK with it in last years nationals. ;)

I've only just got a 511, as I prefer belt-drive and I already had a bunch of spares from my Durga that fit it, so I'm hoping it isn't dying just yet.

Then again, just because Lee isn't using it, that doesn't make it dead.

bzb
06-11-2011, 06:06 PM
hey bzb is still using it, so it must at least be a bit cool :blush: :wub

Origineelreclamebord
06-11-2011, 07:36 PM
hey bzb is still using it, so it must at least be a bit cool :blush: :wub

Whether the TRF belt drive buggy era is at an end or not, the TRF501X and TRF511 will remain cool, no matter what :thumbsup:

rcaddict
10-11-2011, 01:26 AM
TRF511 kit availability may come to an end soon, but rest assured DB01 parts availability for a really long time. I thought Tamiya was going to re-release the TRF511 with gear diffs?? HEY TAMIYA! YOU LISTENING!?

a.m
10-11-2011, 06:44 AM
If thats the case i was seriously lucky. I got the last kit with Tamiya USA :-)

Might try and get one more somwere? Any ideas?

DaveG28
11-11-2011, 04:53 PM
Doesn't look dead yet:

http://www.tamiya.com/english/info/111111jmrca/index.htm

Chris
13-11-2011, 07:13 PM
Doesn't look dead yet:

http://www.tamiya.com/english/info/111111jmrca/index.htm

502X finished 9th
http://gallery.neobuggy.net/2011Races/Japanese-110th-Nats/i-fvjN55j/0/XL/AT41342-XL.jpg

511 finished 8th
http://gallery.neobuggy.net/2011Races/Japanese-110th-Nats/i-BrSzfFp/0/XL/AT41644-XL.jpg

201 finished 3rd
http://gallery.neobuggy.net/2011Races/Japanese-110th-Nats/i-b9bbVCj/0/XL/AT40673-XL.jpg

mikeyscott
13-11-2011, 07:19 PM
New looking springs too, all black??

jamiew
13-11-2011, 07:57 PM
where was that about???

also anybody got pics of the 502 with the shell off:)

bzb
13-11-2011, 08:21 PM
japan

and i always see the driver finished 8/9 or someting and not the car :)

pretty skilled photographer even @ indoor conditions

MHeadling
13-11-2011, 09:24 PM
Amazing pics, here is a link:

http://www.neobuggy.net/modules/news/article.php?storyid=11158

Good to see the 511 still going strong!

If I won the lotto I want a replica Yataba arena in my garden!

kidcongo
15-11-2011, 05:06 AM
Maybe they are working on this:

http://tamiyablog.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/tamiya-58507-db02.jpg


That chassis will combined the advantages of a cross-ways mounted motor (for in-flight correction) and the instant response and reliability of shaft drive.

WOW!!! could be the proverbial game-changer!

DaveG28
15-11-2011, 05:16 AM
Notice the camber links on the 502, nice brass then carbon link?

Also, seen Pidge run these before, what part number are the blue bits sitting between the shock bushing and the tower?

kentech
15-11-2011, 08:27 AM
Notice the camber links on the 502, nice brass then carbon link?

Also, seen Pidge run these before, what part number are the blue bits sitting between the shock bushing and the tower?

53873

http://www.tamiyausa.com/product/item.php?product-id=53873

Chris
15-11-2011, 12:35 PM
I'm developing aluminium upper arm mounts for the the TRF502X chassis. The upper arm mounts will have mounting positions at the same mounting location as the TRF 511 (except for the outer holes). The mounts will be available in set of 2 (L+R).

Pls send me a PM if you are interested.

ottoswe
21-11-2011, 09:23 PM
.. well the db02 isnt made for racing.. but the gyro effect made by the motor and the center shafts will make the car a bit special.

AaronR
22-11-2011, 02:59 AM
End of the road? No way! Newly built this weekend! :wub

http://img710.imageshack.us/img710/755/p1000852i.jpg (http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/710/p1000852i.jpg/)

Origineelreclamebord
22-11-2011, 06:35 AM
.. well the db02 isnt made for racing.. but the gyro effect made by the motor and the center shafts will make the car a bit special.

If it works as desired then surely it will end up on the TRF502's successor as well, or as a hopup for the 502 :lol:

a.m
22-11-2011, 12:02 PM
End of the road? No way! Newly built this weekend! :wub

http://img710.imageshack.us/img710/755/p1000852i.jpg (http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/710/p1000852i.jpg/)

Were do you get the servomounts?

AaronR
22-11-2011, 12:22 PM
Use two packages of Tamiya 54090 as there is one servo mount per package. :)

James
23-11-2011, 06:41 AM
Notice the camber links on the 502, nice brass then carbon link?

Also, seen Pidge run these before, what part number are the blue bits sitting between the shock bushing and the tower?

Whats the part number for the brass/carbon camber link? And also for the brass (or alloy) shock standoffs..?

Thanks!

Roel
23-11-2011, 08:45 AM
Shock standoffs are these :

54205 Aluminium Damper bushing (2pcs)