PDA

View Full Version : 210 Gear DIFF


Anibal Henriques
20-01-2012, 03:09 PM
Itīs coming :thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:

Reo
20-01-2012, 04:14 PM
looks good!

muratti
20-01-2012, 04:47 PM
Since WHEN and WHERE is this available???

Anibal Henriques
20-01-2012, 05:06 PM
Since WHEN and WHERE is this available???
It is on is way ,arrived at China and now is coming to europe ,Diff and Body -shell:thumbsup:

kimipt
20-01-2012, 07:09 PM
Hey Anibal, where can i get this? :drool::drool:

Autocratic
20-01-2012, 07:36 PM
Won't run it, even though I'm on the SC10 gear diff. I refuse to have any kind of e-clip on my car, ever again. Doesn't matter how big the clip is.

stephenh
20-01-2012, 08:00 PM
what he said, lol. E Clip has been a pain. Whats the idea of an e-clip in a gear diff? How can it be smoother than say the SC10 one?

fastinfastout
20-01-2012, 10:57 PM
what's the problem with E-clips in gear diffs?

I have built several gear diffs from other manufacturers, and most of them had E-clips

Autocratic
21-01-2012, 01:56 AM
The SC10 diff had a pin that locks the outdrive in, which can't come out because of how the internal gears are slotted. A clip can easily get stressed and come loose.

muratti
21-01-2012, 06:58 AM
what's the problem with E-clips in gear diffs?

I have built several gear diffs from other manufacturers, and most of them had E-clips

Either never had a problem with E-clips in my whole 15 years of building RC.

hotrodchris
21-01-2012, 09:07 AM
I would rather have a pin fitting as well, find eclips awkward and can pop off or stretch and weaken whereas a pin held in place by the gear is not going anywhere.
But do like the look of the diff compared to the SC110 one!

mattr
21-01-2012, 10:07 AM
Either never had a problem with E-clips in my whole 15 years of building RC.Can't understand the hate either, large parts of my bike are held together with e-clips (and c-clips) even user serviceable and load bearing parts.

And i bet most of the haters drive too........ large chunks of your car (inc. safety critical parts) are held together by C/E-clips..........

Dazzler
21-01-2012, 10:40 AM
Maybe the ARRMA outdrives and gear set will drop straight in. That's cross pin driven. I'm more than happy with the design as is. Just need to get my hands on one..

corsa148
24-01-2012, 09:25 AM
Been lookin for reviews om this diff what are the advantages over running this has anyone got any links to Durango site with any reviews
:D

jonathan may
24-01-2012, 09:42 AM
less maintance for one advantage i run a sc10 gear diff in my 210 with 50wt schumacher oil and it felt better then the ball diff

Michiel H.
24-01-2012, 01:39 PM
All over the place when used on dirt.

raymondkerr
24-01-2012, 02:16 PM
Does anyone have advise on which weight of oil to use in the 210 Gear Diff. Having never ran a gear diff in a 2WD before ??? will be running on a small tight carpet track which is fairly high grip.

On the 410 I normally run 7k rear, 12.5k front. :confused:

/tobys
24-01-2012, 02:23 PM
Check the TD site for DEX210 indoor setups (Ardent & Broxtowe Indoor as 2 examples). The ones I've looked at seem to be running either 3K or 5k...

Hulk
24-01-2012, 02:25 PM
Hi mate,

ive been running the geared diff since using the car at the oople race in July.

I tend to run anything between 1k to 5k, but have found 3k to be a good all rounder on most tracks.

On a high grip track you can go really light on the oils, which really allows the car to pivot whilst still giving you loads of drive on corner exit.

I think a good starting poing would be 3k. If you need more rotation then go down in the oil or up if you need less rotation.

Think you will find 3k works really well.

Craig

jamiekerr14
24-01-2012, 02:26 PM
It varies I have seen some have run 650 some have run 1-2-3+.. I have been running a SC10 diff in mine for a good 3-4 meetings.. and have tried 3k-2k-1k and favoured 2k.
A lot depends on the track layout grip.. driving style and so on...

jimmy
24-01-2012, 02:35 PM
Chris Doughty put in the TQ at last weekends Players and finished 3rd overall using the gear diff - he ran 7,000 cst oil in it.

raymondkerr
24-01-2012, 02:52 PM
Cheers Guys (Craig, Jamie & Jimmy) :thumbsup:

I'll look at starting with 3K and see how it goes.

Raymond.

Hulk
24-01-2012, 02:52 PM
7k obviously proved to be really good at Worksop but that's on a cork surface, which is fairly loose traction. 7k on Loose traction tracks will help prevent the car from diffing out under power.

On a high grip track you shouldnt really have any issues with the car diffing out which enables you to go much lower on the diff oils. this allows lots of quick rotation which is good on tight technical tracks with plenty of grip.

Diff oils vary from track to track, so best thing to do is have a play around and see what works for you. :)

Anibal Henriques
24-01-2012, 02:54 PM
I think the rule is ,less grip more K,5k up ,more grip(full carpet track) 5K down.
Im waiting and waiting to get this gear diff,in Tresrey they have allready got it ,im think more 3 weeks and is for sale in europe ,let cross fingers :thumbsup:

TonyM
24-01-2012, 07:33 PM
MB Models are stating that they expect their stock in later this week.

corsa148
24-01-2012, 07:44 PM
So could someone give me a run through how these work over the standard is there an tec spec on the Durango site

ConceptRacing
24-01-2012, 09:25 PM
I have been looking for a diff oil comparison chart as I presume diff oils are the same as shock oils and that every oil is slight different unless they are all measured in cst.

Hulk
24-01-2012, 10:11 PM
I have been looking for a diff oil comparison chart as I presume diff oils are the same as shock oils and that every oil is slight different unless they are all measured in cst.

As far as know all diff oils are measured in cst.

Just stick with Team Durango oils so you know exactly what your using. All the team drivers will more than likely be using TD's oils, so using their oils will make it easier to copy set ups from the website. :thumbsup:

corsa148
24-01-2012, 10:54 PM
Is this worth upgrading over the standerd diff

Hulk
24-01-2012, 11:21 PM
In my opinion its defo worth having a geared diff as an option.

The ball diff seems better suited to low grip tracks as it helps generate traction without diffing out.

The geared diff is great on high grip tracks such as carpet or astro. Your able to achieve more rotation and more drive in a straight line.

Geared diff also has the advantage of fit and forget for most people. The only parts you ever really have to replace are outdrives when they wear out. The ball diff requires more maintenance and replacement of parts.

Both have their advantages and disadvantages so by having one of each, you can choose which to run depending on the surface.

slowjun
25-01-2012, 01:48 AM
7k obviously proved to be really good at Worksop but that's on a cork surface, which is fairly loose traction. 7k on Loose traction tracks will help prevent the car from diffing out under power.

On a high grip track you shouldnt really have any issues with the car diffing out which enables you to go much lower on the diff oils. this allows lots of quick rotation which is good on tight technical tracks with plenty of grip.



Pardon my ignorance but when you mean diffing out, is this when the tires rotates faster than the other? so when your track is low traction do i need a lower wt oil or heavy?

thanks

/tobys
25-01-2012, 07:14 AM
It's when the inside wheel breaks traction under power.

I'm guessing a using a stiffer oil on low traction slows the diff operation down and thus helps reduce this. On high grip, a lower weight oil can be used as the available traction reduces the chance of this happening.

slowjun
25-01-2012, 09:18 AM
tnxs, will have to try to bring in heavier on my diff and see what happens...

jonathan may
25-01-2012, 10:58 AM
so on a damp astro track with 650cst oil in the diff it is too light and will spin out so need to go higher?
what would be a good starting point for diff oil for a astro and grass track

Anibal Henriques
25-01-2012, 12:01 PM
For Astro i guess 3 or 5K would be good .

ConceptRacing
25-01-2012, 12:09 PM
Hopefully I will try it this Sunday at Broxtowe and see how it goes, fitted a Arrma diff with 3000 diff oil, not sure if i should run a little thicker as its only a 2 gear diff but wont know till i try it.

Anibal Henriques
25-01-2012, 12:16 PM
Hopefully I will try it this Sunday at Broxtowe and see how it goes, fitted a Arrma diff with 3000 diff oil, not sure if i should run a little thicker as its only a 2 gear diff but wont know till i try it.
Concept give us the feedback.
i think with two gears is a litle bit diferent the feel to a four gear diff isn`t ?

jonathan may
25-01-2012, 12:23 PM
so 650cst is to thin by the sounds of it then it only around 45wt oil

corsa148
25-01-2012, 10:12 PM
Well I've got a diff on order now but without sounding stupid once this is fitted you can still adjust the slipper clutch:confused:

shark
25-01-2012, 10:23 PM
Yes mate .

DEXtrain
27-01-2012, 06:14 PM
Anyone tried some type of thick grease in the gear diff?

sparrow.2
27-01-2012, 08:23 PM
Hopefully I will try it this Sunday at Broxtowe and see how it goes, fitted a Arrma diff with 3000 diff oil, not sure if i should run a little thicker as its only a 2 gear diff but wont know till i try it.


Didn't you find the diff to be too small in diameter? I fitted the Arrma diff but then didn't have the guts to drive it as looked to have way too much room to the idler and only barely meshed.

ConceptRacing
27-01-2012, 09:44 PM
It was a direct fit, added both shims to either side of the outdrives, just needs testing now.

sparrow.2
27-01-2012, 09:53 PM
I know it fit directly. The mesh was so bad I thought I'd get the calipers out and found the Arrma diff to be about 1mm smaller in diameter than the ball diff.
On top of that the diff is made of alloy and has fairly narrow teeth so the question is how long the idler will last... One idea was to use the metal idler included with the diff gear but that was smaller than the kit one too...

tyreman
31-01-2012, 02:49 PM
Just got my gear diff today, and can't help feeling that there could have been some instructions to go with it, for people that haven't built a gear diff before, or maybe a guide on how many shims to use.

Just a thought.

paulc
31-01-2012, 03:11 PM
Is it not shimmed the same as the standard ball diff ?

tyreman
31-01-2012, 03:26 PM
There are no shims inside a ball diff, i have got the information from downloading the 410 manual, but personally think that sort of information should be in the pack with the diff.

jimmy
31-01-2012, 03:28 PM
Don't you use.............................. all of them?

washy13
31-01-2012, 03:36 PM
wot diff oil are people using on the durangos own gear diff?

MarkLeeds
31-01-2012, 03:47 PM
Just got my gear diff today, and can't help feeling that there could have been some instructions to go with it, for people that haven't built a gear diff before, or maybe a guide on how many shims to use.

Just a thought.

I thought the same as I never run gear diff before. Found this online :thumbsup: http://www.petitrc.com/setup/durango/setupdex210/DEX210_GearDiffAssembly/index.html

chris_dono
31-01-2012, 04:14 PM
We got these in stock today (in limited numbers) at CPD Racing

OneKiwi
31-01-2012, 05:57 PM
I know it fit directly. The mesh was so bad I thought I'd get the calipers out and found the Arrma diff to be about 1mm smaller in diameter than the ball diff.
On top of that the diff is made of alloy and has fairly narrow teeth so the question is how long the idler will last... One idea was to use the metal idler included with the diff gear but that was smaller than the kit one too...


LOL i went through 4 small idle gears and yes it is too small and not a direct fit, I hope the TD gear diff is the size of the ball diff and not a plastic copy of the arrma diff that is too small

corsa148
31-01-2012, 11:22 PM
Just got my geared diff has anyone got a detailed build of it as you don't get any instructions with it:eh?:

hottuna
01-02-2012, 12:07 AM
Just got my geared diff has anyone got a detailed build of it as you don't get any instructions with it:eh?:
http://www.petitrc.com/setup/durango/setupdex210/DEX210_GearDiffAssembly/index.html :)

TonyM
01-02-2012, 09:47 PM
I built my official Durango 210 gear diff today and I must say with two open ends it's much easier fitting the cir-clips compared to the 410 diff. Also the crown gears slotted neatly onto the shafts without requiring a hammer:thumbsup:

The tolerances look good and it meshed well in the gearbox. I followed the ball diff build and put two bronze shims either side of the outdrives, but I think this is just a tad tight for the gear diff - probably one each side is better.

It could be my imagination, but I felt the standard 'O' rings that came with the set seemed to bed a little tighter into the recess compared to the 410 diff. Therefore, rather than use the other alternatives, I've fitted these and I'll be interested to see if they will leak.

Following an earlier tip from HULK (Craig) I've always built my 410 diffs smearing Marine grease on the 'O' ring and I've never had a problem with oil leakage so I did the same on this build.

I can't wait to try it at Formby this weekend (medium grip carpet).

raymondkerr
01-02-2012, 11:08 PM
Got my diff today, built it without any problems. Used 3000wt oil. Ran tonight on high grip carpet, but the car was very difficult to drive. The back end was stepping out badly when applying power exiting corners. Tried mini pins and staggered ribs, then moved onto yellow mini spikes all round, which improved slightly.

With the gear diff I am now able to set my slipper correctly as the diff no longer slips. Got the slipper set, so that the front doesnt lift pulling away at full throttle.

I'm thinking I now need to go with heavier oil, maybe 5 or 7k?? I'm happy that the diff now works correctly without the slipping of the ball diff, but the car is much much more difficult to drive, and even with reasonablly new tyres the traction just isn't there and that's on a high grip carpet track. Plan on going with heavier oil before trying it again on Sunday at a different carpet track.

jonathan may
01-02-2012, 11:17 PM
dont you run thinner oil on high traction tracks as the diff will not diff out as much. from a previous post.

jonathan may
01-02-2012, 11:18 PM
Hi mate,

ive been running the geared diff since using the car at the oople race in July.

I tend to run anything between 1k to 5k, but have found 3k to be a good all rounder on most tracks.

On a high grip track you can go really light on the oils, which really allows the car to pivot whilst still giving you loads of drive on corner exit.

I think a good starting poing would be 3k. If you need more rotation then go down in the oil or up if you need less rotation.

Think you will find 3k works really well.

Craig
this

raymondkerr
01-02-2012, 11:30 PM
I'll need to rethink the setup, I don't have oil thinner than 3k at the moment. Wondering if I could maybe change shock oils and positions to increase the rear traction.?? Running kit springs and 35wt oil in the shocks.

OneKiwi
02-02-2012, 08:34 AM
Anyone have the gear diff in stock? Im looking for 2+
thanks

Big G
02-02-2012, 09:38 AM
I filled mine with 3k during the build.

The action feels a little notchy, but I'm sure this will smooth out after a few races.

3k in the 210 diff feels really tight(?) compared to 3k in a 410 diff...

raymondkerr
02-02-2012, 11:41 AM
I found the same when building the diff with 3k. The lowest I have ever went on the 410 for 5k in the rear. But I have to say after a couple of runs, the gear diff felt fairly smooth.

Although after last nights testing, I'm not sure where to go next with the setup. I think 3k is probably about right and I feel that I might have to redo my shocks. I'll need to look at some setup sheets.



I filled mine with 3k during the build.

The action feels a little notchy, but I'm sure this will smooth out after a few races.

3k in the 210 diff feels really tight(?) compared to 3k in a 410 diff...

GRIFF55
02-02-2012, 02:04 PM
Mr Doughty was using 7000 in his at Worksop I think and it looked amazing!

jimmy
02-02-2012, 02:09 PM
When I spoke to Chris he was running 7kcst but by the end of the meeting he was on 5kcst apparently.

corsa148
03-02-2012, 07:06 AM
Built my gear diff last night just not sure if I over filled it as around the main seal if the casing there is a little assess coming out or will this just fade off?

AmiSMB
03-02-2012, 09:37 AM
Fill to just the top of the cross pins as then there is room left for the sun gear after that. The excess you are seeing will just be the little extra that has come out as you have put the last side on.

hottuna
04-02-2012, 07:14 PM
Has anyone experienced the gearbox binding with the gear diff? When i assemble it, it turns really heavy.
I've measured the diff gears, and the new one is slightly bigger, will it wear down? This wasn't the case when the ball diff was new.

3 gear setup

paulc
04-02-2012, 07:47 PM
Hi Yes i have the same problem assembled as 4 gear i think it's the acual geared diff gear. Hoping Adam is at Worksop tomorrow to show him.

hottuna
04-02-2012, 08:10 PM
Hi Yes i have the same problem assembled as 4 gear i think it's the acual geared diff gear. Hoping Adam is at Worksop tomorrow to show him.
Hmm, not good :( I want to practice with the gear diff tomorrow for next weekends race.
Hope I don't ruin the bearings :cry:

If you meet Adam tomorrow let us know ASAP what he says about it :) Must be a moulding problem?!

tyreman
04-02-2012, 08:12 PM
Mine does the same so i have put the ball diff back in until it's resolved.
tried new gearbox casing and idler gears as well just to rule it out.

I spoke to the guy's at MB Models and they suggested to loosen the screws as they could be compressing the gear out of shape, did this but no difference.

sly
04-02-2012, 08:13 PM
Hi Yes i have the same problem assembled as 4 gear i think it's the acual geared diff gear. Hoping Adam is at Worksop tomorrow to show him.


Yes please do show him as this is a problem that needs to be resolved very quickly as we all have waited a long time for the diff and the finished item looks good but is a poor fit.

Andrew Twigger
04-02-2012, 08:17 PM
Mine measured .15mm larger in diameter. I was concerned about the tight mesh too and so contacted Durango directly. Chris Doughty was on hand and said that the mesh needs to be tight as there's no slip with the gear diff of course. It felt tight in the hand, but once back in the car didn't feel too bad. He seemed to think it would improve after a few packs. Now it's in the car I'm I inclined to agree.

hottuna
04-02-2012, 08:21 PM
I spoke to the guy's at MB Models and they suggested to loosen the screws as they could be compressing the gear out of shape, did this but no difference.
Tried the same, assembled without the idler gear, and the diff spins freely. It's definitly a faulty diff gear diameter, or wrong shape of the teeth :(

OneKiwi
04-02-2012, 09:31 PM
Happy then that I have the arrma idle gear that is a little smaller than the original TD one.

Neil26
04-02-2012, 10:22 PM
I have the same problem with my gear diff really tight
And very noisey

hottuna
04-02-2012, 10:26 PM
@ OneKiwi:
Good for you :) But that's not how it should be, TD parts should fit together :eh?:

@ Andrew Twigger:
.15mm larger in diameter is what i measured too. I can feel every teeth when i turn the layshaft by hand, and I have to use force.
If Chris Doughty says it's ok I will drive it like this and see if it loosen up.
I put the motor back in and let it run for some time with the gearbox free. After a minute the ESC and the motor was warm, it's a big resistance, i'm not sure this is ok... :(

corsa148
04-02-2012, 11:06 PM
Just started a new thread with this issue am just in the process of building my 210 got the geared diff an thought I had built it up wrong so taken it apart it's not the smoothest thing any ideas anyone not sure weather to put the standerd one in what's people options on it anyone run one for a full meeting??

Andrew Twigger
04-02-2012, 11:15 PM
I ought to expand on what Chris said because each case is different. He said once everything is assembled but without the motor meshed against the spur gear, the car should roll a few metres if you push it. If it is tight enough for this not to happen then there is an issue and you should not run the car. As said previously though, how tight the gearbox screws are can affect how free the drivetrain is.

Once assembled, mine would happily roll freely on the floor and so I would expect the initial tightness by hand will reduce once run. If anyone is in doubt then best not to run it in my opinion.

HTH

corsa148
04-02-2012, 11:23 PM
I ought to expand on what Chris said because each case is different. He said once everything is assembled but without the motor meshed against the spur gear, the car should roll a few metres if you push it. If it is tight enough for this not to happen then there is an issue and you should not run the car. As said previously though, how tight the gearbox screws are can affect how free the drivetrain is.

Once assembled, mine would happily roll freely on the floor and so I would expect the initial tightness by hand will reduce once run. If anyone is in doubt then best not to run it in my opinion.

HTH
Right ye loosened my screws slightly so once I get the wheels on will try that probs just to use to my ft b4 smooth as hell lol

big_whyman
04-02-2012, 11:47 PM
I have just built up my gear diff. It has gone into a complete gearbox (so I have the option of gear or ball). Mine is tight, but nowhere as near as tight as any of you guys are complaining. When holding the gear box I can spin the spurgear fairly easily. Just a thought but how have you guys shimed the diff? I put two either side as per the ball diff and noticed that the bearing where quite a tight fit onto the diff and had to push them on quite firmly before they seated properly. Just a thought for you to check that the bearings have pushed on all the way.:thumbsup:

HTH

Scott

hottuna
04-02-2012, 11:55 PM
how tight the gearbox screws are can affect how free the drivetrain is.

Once assembled, mine would happily roll freely on the floor and so I would expect the initial tightness by hand will reduce once run. If anyone is in doubt then best not to run it in my opinion.
HTH
I know it depends on how hard you tighten the gearbox and that it will effect the gearbox.
But with the gear diff it makes no difference to me. If i put the housing together without the screws, it's really hard to turn the layshaft by hand.

Chris-S
05-02-2012, 10:59 AM
I have used no shims on my gear diff, as putting in the same as the ball diff made it feel very tight, now with no shims it spins freely and with a small amount of side to side play.

jasonrcb
05-02-2012, 11:11 AM
I have 1 shim either side of the diff,also had it on the bench and ran a pack of lipo's through it at low speed,diff feels fine now and spins quite freely,i would have no issues now taking out on track

Reo
05-02-2012, 12:39 PM
one more with gear diff probs. not to good fit, it is to large.

Aran
05-02-2012, 05:33 PM
Mines a bit tight, I haven't used any shims the mesh was level without any

washy13
05-02-2012, 06:17 PM
its slowed mine right down. i have put a 7.5 motor in now in stead of the 10.5 i waz runing :mad:

paulc
05-02-2012, 06:28 PM
I showed Adam the problem with the diff today at Worksop today after abit of playing about it was'nt better so he's taken it to take a closer look Hopefully he'll post something in the next few days after taking alook

sly
05-02-2012, 06:37 PM
I showed Adam the problem with the diff today at Worksop today after abit of playing about it was better so he's taken it to take a closer look Hopefully he'll post something in the next few days after taking alook

Hopefully a quick fix for this let down in quality. I ran mine twice today and its still to tight to be happy about it.

paulc
05-02-2012, 06:52 PM
Personally i think it is the moulding of the actual gear but Adam has given me his witch is fine. Could it be down to builder error tightening the screws to much witch is putting the gear out of shape ? Carn't see it to be honest but thats the only other thing i can think of other than the moulding being wrong

sly
05-02-2012, 07:01 PM
Mine has one tighter spot during a rotation,
Have they used a different type/spec of plastic since the prototypes with different shrinkage characteristics?

raymondkerr
05-02-2012, 07:02 PM
I ran mines today for the second time, much improved over my first run, but it was on a different track. Went up from 3k to 5k oil and made a couple of other changes, also used Nanobytes on the rear (new) and staggers on the front (used) which seemed to help the car. I normally run yellow minipins.

My diff fitted inside the gear case, using both shims on each side as per the ball diff, it appeared to be a little on the tight side at first, but after a few packs, I can't say it is tight anymore.

The car does handle a fair bit different from the ball diff, it feels much heavier but does drive better and I am now able to set my slipper correctly which is something that I was struggling with, as the ball diff was slipping badly, even when tight.

corsa148
05-02-2012, 07:33 PM
Well got my 210 to the rolling chassis point feels ok just a bit stiff well almost fully turned but tried what someone said try rolling on the floor without the pinion an it rolls freely fly a good few meters

Autocratic
06-02-2012, 07:41 AM
For those running a gear diff, how are your lap times? Better or worse than the ball diff? Why did you switch to the gear diff in the first place?

TonyM
06-02-2012, 03:13 PM
I tried one round with the gear diff yesterday and it felt really good. I'm down to one shim either side.

corsa148
06-02-2012, 07:29 PM
The thing is if it is an over tightening issue wouldn't it have been wise to have instructions with hints an tips on parts that need to be to a Tourqe setting associated are good with there instructions there are hint an tips right through them telling u how's best to do itPersonally i think it is the moulding of the actual gear but Adam has given me his witch is fine. Could it be down to builder error tightening the screws to much witch is putting the gear out of shape ? Carn't see it to be honest but thats the only other thing i can think of other than the moulding being wrong

Aran
06-02-2012, 07:52 PM
Seems odd how everyone is having different experiences, sure TD will solve it :D

hottuna
07-02-2012, 02:32 AM
Report from first test with the gear diff... I had a bad feeling driving the car as the gearbox was turning so heavily. But after reading others who had tried I gave it a go on our sunday training.

After 4 races and lots and lots of training days with the ball diff i've had no problem at all.

But with just one training evening with the gear diff it ended up with a mashed bearing, spreading metal parts all over inside the gear housing causing damage to the idler gear and diff gear :(

This could of course be a coinsidence, but i doubt it. I'm sure it's a result of the heavy resistance the gear diff makes.
I replaced the bearing and assembled the gearbox housing, it still feels very harsh to turn it around.
I've always been impressed by Durango quality, but this time they have made a big mistake :(

As a footnote I can say that I had not the top speed on the straight as I use to have, and the ESC got very hot, that didn't happen before. The tranny felt a bit looser at the end of the training, but still plenty of friction.

It ended up with a damaged bearing, mail to Durango is being send :(

corsa148
07-02-2012, 11:56 AM
I emailed Durango tec department about the gear diff an they have said the diff requires NO shimming at all

stephenh
07-02-2012, 12:48 PM
That would be correct. No shims supplied with gear diff kit anyway. No issues with my own gear diff, wee bit notchy when first built but soon bedded in after a few runs and feels very smooth now. No shims and 1000cst.

Aran
07-02-2012, 01:29 PM
when you open the gearbox stick the gear diff in one half of the gearbox (with the rest of the gears installed) without any shims and you'll notice it is level with the rest of the gears, adding the shims with only cause this tight friction people are getting.

hottuna
07-02-2012, 02:24 PM
when you open the gearbox stick the gear diff in one half of the gearbox (with the rest of the gears installed) without any shims and you'll notice it is level with the rest of the gears, adding the shims with only cause this tight friction people are getting.

It's true that no shims should be used. But the problem with friction is because of the gear being to big. Durango is looking at the problem.

OneKiwi
08-02-2012, 02:29 PM
What have people used for orings? Are you using the ones that come with the kit or the 330099 orange ones?
Any leakage?

What grease are you coating it with? Black, clear or green slime? Or just soaking them in diff/shock oil under the build

/tobys
08-02-2012, 02:44 PM
I used the kit ones with Green slime. I also soaked the gaskets in diff oil prior to fitting.

However, I have yet to run it but just standing out of the gearbox on the workbench shows no leaks :thumbsup:

stephenh
08-02-2012, 06:41 PM
Kit ones, with black grease and soaked gaskets in some shock oil for a while. Running 650cst and no leaking - ran it last sunday for about 8 runs.

OneKiwi
08-02-2012, 07:54 PM
Thanks did the soaking and slime.

What did you think of 650? I just built mine with 2000 durango oil, I have 60wt losi oil that is about the same. What are you running on?

hottuna
08-02-2012, 08:28 PM
I used 2000 WT that's delivered with the 410 diff, mostly because it's the best I had at home.
It's hard to say if that was good or not, as I had big problems with the diff. ESC ran hot, no speed on the straight, bearing in gearbox went to 1000 pieces.

I used the orange Kyosho o-rings, wet them with the diff oil.
The diff itself feels great, no leakage, if only the diff gear was a bit smaller... I've contacted Durango and they are looking into the problem.

stephenh
08-02-2012, 08:29 PM
Started with 2k but the car felt lazy in the chicanes and tight turns. I went to 1k a liked it a lot. Tried 650 last week a thought it was too light. made the car snatchy and square up to quick. So back to 1k. Suggest you try that. I am racing on med-high grip astro.

stephenh
08-02-2012, 08:32 PM
Sorry meant to add I am using the Schumacher Ultimate Diff Oil ranges. As long as you have the CST ratings it will be fine whatever you use......

OneKiwi
09-02-2012, 03:02 PM
When I turn the outdrives on the bench (in hand) it does feel notchy, is that because it hasn't been run yet and needs a little running in or have I tightened it up too much or something?

Big G
09-02-2012, 04:01 PM
mine's the same. I'll race it tomorrow and report back

acorn28
09-02-2012, 04:03 PM
Mine also feels a little notchy, one side more so than the other. Nothing major though, sure it'll smooth out after a few runs.

When I turn the outdrives on the bench (in hand) it does feel notchy, is that because it hasn't been run yet and needs a little running in or have I tightened it up too much or something?

stephenh
09-02-2012, 07:49 PM
Yes mine was notchy in my hand the first time and also in the gearbox. It was fine after a run or two. Also each time I have rebuilt it with new oil the diff will feel fine in my hand (having been run) but still notchy in the gearbox until I give it a run and the diff seats again with the idle gears such is the fine mesh between all the gears. Just make sure there are no big notchy bits when turning the spur/outdrives when the gearbox is in the hand. sometimes it takes me 3 or 4 attempts to put it all back in the gearbox and have it feel someway smooth prior to a run.
One last point. I race on Astro with some sand, and you do need to go round every gear and remove any small traces of sand grains to stop it from feeling even worse. the mesh is sooooo tight you cant even have the smallest of blemishes in any of the gears
HTH

MatJohnson
10-02-2012, 08:46 AM
Ran mine for the first time last night. There was a slight notch when I turned the diff by the layshaft but it was fine last night, no overheating or anything.

Big G
10-02-2012, 09:32 AM
What oil did you start with Toadeh? I'm gonna try 3k on carpet tonight and see where to do from there

MatJohnson
10-02-2012, 10:03 AM
Used 5k in it at Oz. Am running it tomorrow so will know more then mate, was just a quick test to see if the car worked mainly :)

corsa148
10-02-2012, 10:16 AM
Well running mine for the first time tonight I am running 3k in mine

Philim
10-02-2012, 10:46 AM
Ran mine on Tuesday with 2k in it. Felt really good and very quiet. Action a little stiff ...felt like drag brake was on but other than that it was good

Big G
10-02-2012, 02:24 PM
I'm unsure if I should start on 3k given how it feels in my hands, but you gotta start somewhere.

corsa148
11-02-2012, 12:08 AM
Well run mine tonight for the first time used 3k well impressed drove better than I ever thought:thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:

jonathan may
11-02-2012, 01:26 AM
so i have put the gear diff in my 210 but mine to with the gearbox closed is a very tight fit. Do they bed in or is the main gear to big. My sc10 geardiff feels alot loser and a lot smoother then the durango diff

TonyM
12-02-2012, 04:36 PM
Ran mine for a full session today at Formby and I was very pleased with the results. (3k oil on medium grip carpet was just about right). Mine started stiff (oooerrr missus!!!) but now it's as mooth as silk.

This is the best my car has felt and I for one won't be going back to a balled diff.

MatJohnson
13-02-2012, 09:02 AM
I ran the gear diff at Silverstone this weekend. Ended up on 7k but I think i've built something wrong as the car had no rear end at all. Was awefull to drive.

MHeadling
13-02-2012, 09:36 AM
So now a few people have done some running with the gear diff are they loosening up a bit now??

Any oil set ups for carpet for the diff??

spiro
13-02-2012, 09:51 AM
What have people used for orings?
Tresrey O-rings. Used the same for my DESC410 build.
http://www.tresrey-usa.com/products/O%252dRING-P5-%28BLACK%7B47%7D8pcs%29.html

burgie
13-02-2012, 09:55 AM
I ran the gear diff at Silverstone this weekend. Ended up on 7k but I think i've built something wrong as the car had no rear end at all. Was awefull to drive.

looking at what most others are running, i can only think that you have gone too thick on the oil - most others are running around the 3k mark.

Big G
13-02-2012, 10:36 AM
ran mine at leominster on carpet friday night with 3k in the diff.

instantly the car had a loose back end, but was running worn tyres. so I glued on some new pins and tried again. a lot better and balanced now.

Car seems to push like crazy exiting corners so I'll be working on curing that next meeting. Might drop the oil to 1k for next time.

The launch at the start of the final was ballistic :D

MatJohnson
13-02-2012, 10:42 AM
looking at what most others are running, i can only think that you have gone too thick on the oil - most others are running around the 3k mark.

Possibly yes. I'm going to go back to the ball diff and set the car with that, then look at moving to the gear diff. Its different teritory to me so I am best to look at basics first.

Don't think its a bad product though, just not for me at this time.

MHeadling
13-02-2012, 10:50 AM
So are the tight spots going after a few packs??

Are you running with out any shims??

TonyM
13-02-2012, 11:28 AM
Tight spots almost gone after 30 min running. I'm using one bronze shim either side.

corsa148
13-02-2012, 12:28 PM
Tight spots almost gone after 30 min running. I'm using one bronze shim either side.

Durango e said not to use any of the gold shims with the gear diff

TonyM
13-02-2012, 12:44 PM
I found that there was a minute element of movement with no shims.

smokedsalmonkid
13-02-2012, 09:24 PM
i tried the gear diff at taplow on sunday, a couple of runs and it smoothed out in the gearbox

it wasn't my cup of tea though i had nothing on the smooth wood corners compared to the ball diff. the back end would just step out on me unless i crawled round there.

i ran 3k do i go higher or lower this is verging undrivable :thumbdown:

big_whyman
13-02-2012, 10:14 PM
I also ran my gear diff in at the Winter Open, after 2 or 3 runs the tight spot disappeared. I was generally happy with the feel of the car with the gear diff although i struggled with the car snaking badly under acceleration. I managed to fix this in the final. Taking inspiration from Mr Doughty's (I love him now :woot:) Worksop setup I went up by 5 weight oil (from 30 to 35) and then went down two spring rates (from Dark Green to Light Blue). The car didnt feel as loose and the power was much easier to put down, indeed I found approx 3/4 a second on my quickest lap. The other thing I tried was the slipper setting, I found that I needed to run the car with the slipper approx a turn to 1.5 turn looser than on the ball diff ( this is with 5k diff oil). I think with better tires this would have been an optimum setup

Much thanks to David Poulter for all his help with the car on Saturday, I like bugging him now, hes so poilte :thumbsup: and he's ace!!!! lol

MatJohnson
14-02-2012, 08:42 AM
smokedsalmonkid, sounds like you had the same experience that I had. From reading, everyone said go down the oils to me, which is the oposite to what I thought I should do.

wazee
24-02-2012, 05:19 PM
*puuush*

It seems that the gear diff is available again, at least here in germany.
The durango site still not showing any stock but I should have mine on monday.

Going to report if it's the real 210 gear diff :P

OneKiwi
27-02-2012, 03:01 PM
Mine seems to be binding and not spinning freely in the house, in turn bumping up the motor temps which is not good.

Think it matters what way it sits in the housing?

Kusal
27-02-2012, 04:01 PM
*puuush*

It seems that the gear diff is available again, at least here in germany.
The durango site still not showing any stock but I should have mine on monday.

Going to report if it's the real 210 gear diff :P
Where did you order it from in Germany?

wazee
27-02-2012, 04:57 PM
Where did you order it from in Germany?

From Ruddog the official Durango Distributor.
Mine is still on the way but hopefully arrives tommorow.

Oops
28-02-2012, 09:22 AM
thank you wazee !

I've searched it a long time after your first post and finaly found it on Ruddog website.

Gear Diff orderd on saturday evening, shipped yesterday :thumbsup:

My english is not very good but my german skill is close to zero. By chance the site has an english version :lol:

wazee
28-02-2012, 11:02 AM
thank you wazee !

I've searched it a long time after your first post and finaly found it on Ruddog website.

Gear Diff orderd on saturday evening, shipped yesterday :thumbsup:

My english is not very good but my german skill is close to zero. By chance the site has an english version :lol:

No problem, I'm happy to hear that you got one.
Mine arrived today and I will build it this evening.

Unfortuntaly the ruddog website is not available in english but if anyone wants to order something you could use the google translator or just write
him an email to; [email protected] - I'm pretty sure he answers in english ;)

At the moment there are about 50 gear diffs left, so plenty for those who haven't had the chance to get their hands on one.

Oops
28-02-2012, 07:41 PM
yes, there is an english version of the site

only the order status modification emails are only in German, but google translation is one of my best friends :D

OneKiwi
06-03-2012, 08:40 AM
So any news on the mouldings being too big?

I still have to use the arrma idle gear otherwise its too tight, this works but I still want to use the TD parts. Mine is too noisy with the extra metal idle gear.

I like the silent assassin approach, not the screaming banshee

I even seem to have one spot that is tighter than the rest.

/tobys
06-03-2012, 09:36 AM
I still have a tight spot on mine that has not really improved after 2 full meetings of running...

However, it has not caused any apparent issues with the mesh, sounds nice and quiet and is still fast with no overheating. I just made sure the gears were lubricated with black grease and this seems OK. Just need to make sure ZERO grit gets in between the teeth though, as that would be a recipe for disaster!

I've also had to replace the kit x-rings with the shock o-rings as I had a leak at one side...yet to be run but hopefully it will keep the oil inside the diff better! So far only ran with 3K oil and it seems OK, although would like to try going up and down to see how it feels - when I ran on dry Astro the other week, the car didn't seem to want to rotate as much as I would have liked on power...maybe going lighter would help?

hottuna
20-03-2012, 05:35 PM
So any news on the mouldings being too big?

Yes, I can confirm that some gears are to big. I got a new diff gear send to me today.
The new one fits like a glove, and the gear box spins silk smooth :thumbsup:

OneKiwi
20-03-2012, 06:03 PM
got mine today as well

hottuna
27-03-2012, 12:22 AM
Drove the car last day with the new diff gear. Such a difference! The gearbox is so smooth, and almost soundless.
I'm happy Durango sorted it out, and thought of us customers :)
I was surprised when I suddenly got a mail that they wanted to send me a new diff gear. 10 points to Durango :thumbsup:

joho
27-03-2012, 04:43 AM
Yes, I just bought a new gear diff and it's perfect. I believe the new batch all came with the correct size gears. Great reaction from TD!:thumbsup:

s22jgs
27-03-2012, 06:21 AM
issue on mine wasnt really worth worrying about it was so minor, but i got sent a new diff case anyway so all good

Fernandez
27-03-2012, 07:23 AM
Yes, I just bought a new gear diff and it's perfect. I believe the new batch all came with the correct size gears. Great reaction from TD!:thumbsup:

where did you buy ?

dobber
27-03-2012, 11:42 AM
where did you buy ?

My thoughts too as I'm wanting to buy one!

steve73
01-04-2012, 10:09 AM
Quick question: What is the right size for the screw driver for the 8 screws at the Diff?

Aran
01-04-2012, 11:03 AM
Got a new main gear too, fits perfectly and spins freely!

Steve I they are 0.050". Like this hex driver:
http://www.jespares.com/electric-models?page=shop.product_details&flypage=flypage.tpl&product_id=7343&category_id=536

steve73
01-04-2012, 12:45 PM
Thanks, 0,05 is what i tried, but now 4 screws are damaged.....trying to get a new driver tomorrow :thumbdown:

DBL15
16-04-2012, 10:42 PM
where did you buy ?

hi guys just wondering where is everyone buying these from as they cant be found at any of my shops i buy from :confused:

ridgeracer
17-04-2012, 05:51 PM
hi guys just wondering where is everyone buying these from as they cant be found at any of my shops i buy from :confused:


Je spares has them

Fernandez
24-04-2012, 08:57 PM
I have a gear diff from the second batch. filled with durango 1000cst.
It does feel smooth but at the same time it feels a bit to tight/heavy.

when turning by hand you can feel the teeth of the spider gears getting contact, Is that because it is brand new?

Is it because I use the 2 copper shims from the ball diff on each side? or do I need lighter diff oil ?

I only ran 1 raceday ( 6 heats of 6 minutes ). Do I need to give it some time? maybe after a few packs ?

any thoughts ?

edit:
Or is it maybe , that I used O-rings from Tresrey # TYS246 red o-rings
when installing those O-rings they were slightly to big, but I got them to fit and put the e-clip in the groove with a little force. Could they couse such a drag ?

Kusal
24-04-2012, 09:53 PM
Normally you do not use any copper shims of the ball diff on the gear diff; take them out, put the gear diff back in the gear box and pinch the gearbox together. There should be a slight lateral movement of the diff.
But I agree that the gear diff feels a bit notchy but it will go away once run in.

jkclifford
25-04-2012, 05:40 AM
I had a 410 diff that was notchy as hell even after 30mins rum was still not smooth.

I filled it with cutting oil, spun it up with an electric drill for a few seconds ( put an old drive shaft in the chuck held the main gear) tipped out the grey slurry, smoooooooth as silk. (you will prob need new seals as the Cutting oil makes them swell)

mark christopher
25-04-2012, 05:30 PM
your prob not knocking the large gear onto the outdrive enough

jkclifford
27-04-2012, 03:39 AM
That would make it tight, bit not give it a tight spot or knock at one point in the revolution.

If all the diff parts were like the newer machined main diff ring, I'm sure that would build one sweeeet diff.............

mark christopher
27-04-2012, 07:50 AM
That would make it tight, bit not give it a tight spot or knock at one point in the revolution.

If all the diff parts were like the newer machined main diff ring, I'm sure that would build one sweeeet diff.............
not if there was a high point on the gear..........

jkclifford
27-04-2012, 09:28 AM
True, a high point on the gear will drag all tue way round.

Best engineer in the world can't build a smooth diff with poor components.

Generally though its just flashing on the gears which scratches off with a Stanley knife.
(once you've found the offending tooth/ teeth!)

ConceptRacing
30-04-2012, 07:37 PM
Ran mine for the first time at RHR at the weekend in my 210, ran it with 3000 diff oil, no shims on the outdrives, loved the way it handled, didnt really notice that much difference in overall handling, felt like i had more steering, more consistant when the track was dry, slightly more stable coming out of corners, felt easier to put the power down, harder to drive when track got slippy, I think i will try this at Coventry soon to see how it feels on a track i know well, overall I think I prefer this to a ball diff.

jkclifford
30-04-2012, 11:32 PM
Try 60wt shock oil you'll notice the difference then!!

Fernandez
01-05-2012, 07:54 AM
60wt shock oil in the diff, I even heard team associated black grease in the diff.

seems like you can put everything in this diff.

who runs what? and why 60wt shock oil ?

jkclifford
01-05-2012, 08:30 AM
the more freely the diff works the quicker it will react to weigh transfer from wheel to wheel, allowing the car to turn in easier, and be able to get on the power with only the inside wheels driving makes getting back on the powers feel smoother.

I ran 50wt on polished wood block loads of steering and safe on the throttle!!

Fernandez
01-05-2012, 08:38 PM
ran the diff on a med grip hardpacked dirt/clay track. at first I had 1000cst durango. That was way to thick, I put 50% less of the same oil and for a few minutes with 25% throttle and holding one wheel, and then the other wheel.
Diff became a little looser , less tight.
But still way to thick. when I go on throttle coming out on a turn the back of the dex is still nervous, I have to go real easy on power.

Im gonna try 50wt Losi oil and see how we get from there

/tobys
01-05-2012, 09:04 PM
Don't you find with such light oil the inside wheel "diffs out" under power, especially on the low grip surface?

When I went lighter oil on mine (on med grip astro), I found the back end was freed up a lot but had more of a tendency to spin out on the exit of tight hairpins etc...

jkclifford
02-05-2012, 03:16 AM
Don't you find with such light oil the inside wheel "diffs out" under power, especially on the low grip surface?

When I went lighter oil on mine (on med grip astro), I found the back end was freed up a lot but had more of a tendency to spin out on the exit of tight hairpins etc...

yes but you can tune that out with the shocks and roll centres. As with all set up changes to gain one you loose another!

Fernandez
02-05-2012, 07:09 AM
Don't you find with such light oil the inside wheel "diffs out" under power, especially on the low grip surface?

When I went lighter oil on mine (on med grip astro), I found the back end was freed up a lot but had more of a tendency to spin out on the exit of tight hairpins etc...

I have felt a lot of ball diffs at our track from different cars.
TLR 22, centro, b4.1 .
And they all feel much lighter.

Even the TLR 22 gear diff witk 3K diff oil feels lighter than my durango gear diff,

So Im not afraid it will " diff out "


I ran the ball diff at first with the dex210 and now I run the gear diff.
I could push the dex very hard with the ball diff and the back of the car just followed the front.
And now with the gear diff, I can not push as hard, but when I do the back just spins out under throttle, mostly on exit corners

jkclifford
02-05-2012, 09:38 AM
Gear diffs do feel more positive,

Maybee you was getting a bit of slip through the ball diff, try backing the clutch off.

Fernandez
02-05-2012, 10:31 AM
Gear diffs do feel more positive,

Maybee you was getting a bit of slip through the ball diff, try backing the clutch off.

Sorry, My Engish is not the best. could you explain it a bit more



edit: I saw a neumann setup for indoor carpet low grip with around 650 cst oil, that is somewhat like losi 55 shock oil

s22jgs
02-05-2012, 01:59 PM
Sorry, My Engish is not the best. could you explain it a bit more



edit: I saw a neumann setup for indoor carpet low grip with around 650 cst oil, that is somewhat like losi 55 shock oil

650 is equivalent to 45 losi

I'm running 650 on both carpet and astro now

jkclifford
02-05-2012, 02:42 PM
Sorry, My Engish is not the best. could you explain it a bit more



edit: I saw a neumann setup for indoor carpet low grip with around 650 cst oil, that is somewhat like losi 55 shock oil

The ball diff might have been slipping a bit when you got on the power

Gear diff won't slip so all the powers you pit in all be going to the wheels.

set the clutch so you get 1.5 m to 2m of slip when pulling away

hotrodchris
02-05-2012, 06:29 PM
I found the gear diff is fine in the dry but a nightmare in the wet!

guinness
03-05-2012, 03:58 AM
hi guys ,just building my new DEX210 ,now im at the diff gear build section.
i assembled the gear diff following instruction,once is all finished it feels a bit crunchy . is that normal???

OneKiwi
03-05-2012, 06:16 AM
If its new then yes after a few controlled laps it should bed in better and be smooooth

Fernandez
03-05-2012, 07:08 AM
had a swift talk/chat with hupo honigl.
He finds that the gear diff is not for a dirt track, just for indoor carpet or astro turf.

I can understand that. now that Im busy with the gear diff and when running on dirt you have to go so thin in oil to get the power down without spinning out.

I have no 50wt Losi oil in my gear diff and had it run in. it is now smooth and not so tight anymore. I feels right now when I feel it by hand. I just have to drive it yet on my track.

keep you posted