|
#21
|
|||
|
|||
Vintage guidelines
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
As I see it then, things to consider before Thursday re. Guidelines: Pre-2000 & Re-re (pre-2000 design) seems to be agreed Tyres: control tyre? Bear in mind some old cars don't take modern tyres (e.g. My Tamiya Hornet has very non-standard wheels) Motor: brushed and/or brushless? Turn/kV limits? This is probably the important factor... Batteries: NiCd/NiMH only or LiPo ok too? And important to bear in mind Josh's point about cost and Matt's on keeping the old cars 'safe' due to difficulty in obtaining parts (keeping speed down?) Anyway, I think that's it for now.... I'm holding off getting motor/esc until we are decided! Barry
__________________
RC10 (A stamp), RC10 Worlds, RC10 B4.2, Carisma GTB, RC8.2e South West Indoor RC: http://Team-SWIRC.org.uk Trader feedback: http://www.oople.com/forums/showthread.php?t=165264 |
#22
|
||||
|
||||
Pre 2000 sounds good, it'd make sure the cars are different to what we use today but without being too restrictive, like you guys say some parts just don't exist any more.
Now you need to find an old Losi XX CR Matt IMO, lipo's are handy because everybody already has them. I don't miss having to balance NIMH's or deep discharge Nicd's to keep them healthy. I'd be up for keeping power levels "stock" or thereabouts, I think they'd still be pretty quick around the track even with 27T brushed/17.5T brushless motors. Something to think about Thurs
__________________
Schumacher KF || Hobao H2 || Kyosho Inferno VE || Carisma GTB || Anything with a remote! |
#23
|
||||
|
||||
RC10
In my opinion, I would want to run a cheapy brushed Motor+ESC and NIMH pack to keep it reasonably crap to drive. To almost make it battle of the driver and not the car, as you see in the 2wd class the KF is just haulin' ass.
Also, people have discussed this in another thread somewhere for a different occasion/track. I will find that and quote some things to see what you guys think? -Josh
__________________
CML Distribution | Yokomo | Reedy | Schelle | P-Dub Racing | LMR | Pure-RC | Fresh RC | Number 5 RC |
#24
|
|||
|
|||
Batteries and motors!
Quote:
Quote:
Josh, if you get time some quotes from other's experience would be most helpful! I've seen a couple of places, I'll see what I can fish out too Barry
__________________
RC10 (A stamp), RC10 Worlds, RC10 B4.2, Carisma GTB, RC8.2e South West Indoor RC: http://Team-SWIRC.org.uk Trader feedback: http://www.oople.com/forums/showthread.php?t=165264 |
#25
|
||||
|
||||
Both quotes from Jimmy, this was for the RC10 control class we had at the oOos Series.
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
CML Distribution | Yokomo | Reedy | Schelle | P-Dub Racing | LMR | Pure-RC | Fresh RC | Number 5 RC |
#26
|
|||
|
|||
Batteries and Motors, more thoughts...
Quote:
I've been playing this evening with the RC10. I have had a Reedy 3300kV brushless with 2s 30/50c LiPos in it, however, a lot of the much older cars don't have a slipper clutch, the RC10 included. The Classic does have an adjustable ball diff (and bear in mind I'm no expert on the ball diff yet); however I have had to have the diff really tight to avoid over slipping with the brushless setup, to the point where the diff doesn't sound too healthy I've changed the setup this evening, to NiMH, Tamiya 540RS 23T sport tuned brushed motor and cheap-o MS ESC (£16!), and re-adjusted the diff, and it sounds much happier! It also feels more 'right' to me to have this setup; I'll leave it in and try the car at the track during practice on Thursday to see how it goes. I'm just very aware that if some folks have much older cars with no slipper, they will be stuck with slow crap motors, or risk trashing their transmission to keep up with the 'newer' slipper clutch wielding 'vintage' cars with hot (or even 'not-so-hot') brushless motors. It'd be interesting to see how a 17T or 21T brushless motor compares to the 23T brushed I have in... Does anyone have a stock brushless in a car they could bring for comparison? I'm all up for enjoying the 'naff-ness' of these great cars Thoughts please!
__________________
RC10 (A stamp), RC10 Worlds, RC10 B4.2, Carisma GTB, RC8.2e South West Indoor RC: http://Team-SWIRC.org.uk Trader feedback: http://www.oople.com/forums/showthread.php?t=165264 |
#27
|
|||
|
|||
And more thoughts...
I have also toyed with the idea of putting my old school Acoms 27mhz electronics in the RC10, but the thought of the long aerial and messing with crystals is just a step too far...
I have found the web site I was thinking of (other than the oOple RC10 class that Josh posted about above) - click through and have a look: http://revival.a1racingclub.com/classic-racing.html There is too much to cut and paste, however: I couldn't see a motor limit... But they are grouping cars by age... Scroll down and look at the cars list for each group... And they have 'nostalgia points' for those using brushed motors, old school tx/rx, NiMH/NiCd etc.. Mostly appropriate for a big meet with lots of folks, but might be some useful ideas there, for example the RC10 Worlds is two 'age' classes above the classic, as it's transmission etc. is quite different. Looking forward to getting some classic track time during practice on Thursday (I've got the sticks back to use with the cars too Matt!), and hopefully the wheels and carpet tyres for the Classic will have arrived by then... Barry
__________________
RC10 (A stamp), RC10 Worlds, RC10 B4.2, Carisma GTB, RC8.2e South West Indoor RC: http://Team-SWIRC.org.uk Trader feedback: http://www.oople.com/forums/showthread.php?t=165264 |
#28
|
||||
|
||||
Saw the revival thing posted somewhere,
would we allow the 'stealth' transmission with the new stuff on it? or would we keep it old school and simple? -Josh
__________________
CML Distribution | Yokomo | Reedy | Schelle | P-Dub Racing | LMR | Pure-RC | Fresh RC | Number 5 RC |
#29
|
|||
|
|||
If I recall correctly, the RC10 Worlds (which is vintage/classic re-re), comes with the stealth transmission (Classic doesn't), so it has to be allowed really... But I do think keeping motors and possibly batteries old school is the thing to do.... Discuss! the difficulty is trying to keep an even-ish field with 15/20 years worth of 'vintage' cars that people may bring....
__________________
RC10 (A stamp), RC10 Worlds, RC10 B4.2, Carisma GTB, RC8.2e South West Indoor RC: http://Team-SWIRC.org.uk Trader feedback: http://www.oople.com/forums/showthread.php?t=165264 |
#30
|
|||
|
|||
Day off today, so I've been doing some reading... Here is some relevant bits from the vintage off road nationals in the US:
( http://vintageoffroadnationals.com/rules/ ) CLASSES **All classes are limited to cars produced 1994 and earlier. Contact us for other approvals** 2wd Buggy 27 turn ROAR legal stock and 17.5 brushless motors only (under current rules). Radio gear “electronics” are open. Tires/wheels are open Li-Po batteries are allowed. Classic Limited to “non-pro” and entry level cars (Tamiya Hornet, Mauri Ninja, Royal Ripper for example) All 1/10 Buggies, 2wd or 4wd, 2ws or 4ws allowed Handout Tamiya RS540 motors only Radio gear “electronics” are open. Tires/wheels are open (including narrow front tires) Li-Po batteries are allowed.
__________________
RC10 (A stamp), RC10 Worlds, RC10 B4.2, Carisma GTB, RC8.2e South West Indoor RC: http://Team-SWIRC.org.uk Trader feedback: http://www.oople.com/forums/showthread.php?t=165264 |
#31
|
||||
|
||||
Quote:
I have a 17.5T "stock" brushless motor, but no chassis to fit it to for testing really. Barry your welcome to test it in your RC10 gold pan and see how it goes? could give all of us a bit of a base line for retro performance. Probably a tiny bit slower than the 23T you've got fitted at the moment I'm guessing? Quote:
From reading what other clubs do, it sounds like limiting the motor is the biggest performance equaliser? So many things to consider. Matt's gonna have fun with this
__________________
Schumacher KF || Hobao H2 || Kyosho Inferno VE || Carisma GTB || Anything with a remote! |
#32
|
||||
|
||||
Ok it appears that i've missed this bit of the forum and have been looking in the other SWIRC page
I'm working at the mo but will be on here when finished What about if we all agree on a year for the Vintage? Say anything released up to 31st December 1995 or something like that? 1st Jan 1998? Something along them lines? I guess it all depends on how much fun we all want to have and with what budget? If we said anything before 31st December 1999 that would fall into cars made pre 2000 and would open it up a lot more? The rules you have posted up Barry are really interesting, thats really good to work from
__________________
Schumacher KF Racer @ South West Indoor RC https://www.facebook.com/pages/South...3948047?ref=hl Link above |
#33
|
|||
|
|||
Quote:
Quote:
I think the fundamental rule, as Richard said, is "staying in the spirit" of running a 20yr old RC We want to keep it as open as possible to begin with, the more Buggies the better! We could always 'massage' the guidelines based on experience at a later date. My tuppence-worth: Why not start with... 2wd buggies designed before 2000 (manufactured before 2000, or re-re based on pre-2000 design), motors 'in the vintage spirit!... and leave the rest open If we find folk are turning up with super-fast brushless 1999 models and win every week, maybe that's the time to go with something like: 2wd pre-2000 buggies: 27 turn ROAR legal stock and 17.5 brushless motors only (under current rules). Radio gear “electronics” are open. Tires/wheels are open Li-Po batteries are allowed. So just limiting the motor. Just my thoughts based on what we've found online, and comments from Josh, Matt and Richard above I've put the 3300kV back in the RC10 and had another play with the diff. From what I've read, the 3300kV falls somewhere in between 13.5t - 17.5t sensored brushless, so probably a bit quick... (though I'm sure my driving will limit me more than the equipment!lol). I'll bring the 23t brushed along on Thursday too, and maybe try your 17.5t brushless too Richard. Kinda depends if I get my wheels and tyres in time! Barry
__________________
RC10 (A stamp), RC10 Worlds, RC10 B4.2, Carisma GTB, RC8.2e South West Indoor RC: http://Team-SWIRC.org.uk Trader feedback: http://www.oople.com/forums/showthread.php?t=165264 |
#34
|
||||
|
||||
Looks like we're all thinking pre-2000 as a general consensus then?
I can't see anyone turning up with a 5.5t motor and an ESC with mad timing to run vintage, if they do they've missed the point!! I'll bring the 17.5T along Barry, it would be interesting to see a vintage buggy go with it just so we can see what to expect. Do you have any connectors on your ESC -> motor or just soldered straight to the motor? I've got an Axial 27T brushed motor that can be used for testing as well - I must admit though, I've only ever ran that and the 17.5T on 3s lipo (rock crawler) so I don't know what to expect!
__________________
Schumacher KF || Hobao H2 || Kyosho Inferno VE || Carisma GTB || Anything with a remote! |
#35
|
||||
|
||||
RC10
Sweet, should be putting a order in for stuff tomorrow
-Josh
__________________
CML Distribution | Yokomo | Reedy | Schelle | P-Dub Racing | LMR | Pure-RC | Fresh RC | Number 5 RC |
#36
|
||||
|
||||
My RC10 T2 - see if you can spot any original parts Now all we need is a Vintage 1/10 truck class I must put some time into making it race ready and bring it down one night, I bet it would be fun on the track. Home made shock towers (Lexan), hand polished chassis (originally black). Its seen 4s lipo + barn jumps and survived, but not seen an indoor track before. Josh - your joining the RC10 club then?
__________________
Schumacher KF || Hobao H2 || Kyosho Inferno VE || Carisma GTB || Anything with a remote! |
#37
|
||||
|
||||
Richard that truck is sweet! Fit some buggy tyres to it and get it down to the track haha. Was that released at the same time as the buggy?
This is all getting really exciting! Ive now got about 7 vintage cars im watching on Ebay but some sellers seem to think their completely worn out 20 year old cars are worth more than gold lol. Its proving pretty hard to work out what one to buy Have we all agreed on a year to buy up to? It will help me narrow down my search and anyone else looking to buy, ive a few that i'm looking at . I mean there's no immediate rush we can wait until Thursdays race night to talk a few things over. I'm thinking pre 2000 to keep things a little cheaper BUT 95/96/97/98 could all be considered? The rules that have been posted from the other events are very interesting. Simple and to the point. If we just start by deciding on 1. Manufactured before date. 2. Motor limit (anything up to the chosen turn)
__________________
Schumacher KF Racer @ South West Indoor RC https://www.facebook.com/pages/South...3948047?ref=hl Link above |
#38
|
||||
|
||||
RC10
Ordering today hopefully (RC10 Classic/Gold Tub).
I would say Designed/First Made Before 2000. 17.5 should be okay, but we will have to do a little bit of testing! -Josh
__________________
CML Distribution | Yokomo | Reedy | Schelle | P-Dub Racing | LMR | Pure-RC | Fresh RC | Number 5 RC |
#39
|
||||
|
||||
Hi, just wanted to offer another different opinion on the rules. I think using Nimh or Nicad batteries just creates more hassle and cost, most people have ditched their old batteries in favour of lipos. The same is true with brushed motors, pretty much everyone now uses brushless and having to purchase new motors and escs just creates yet another financial barrier of which there are already too many in R.C. car racing. The same goes for radios, no one wants to go back to the days of making sure everyone is on different crystals etc. In addition to this tyres should be open.
I think as a rough guideline cars should be pre 2000 but with room for exceptions and flexibility on the day so that if people turn up with something they are allowed to use it - a common sense approach would be needed. I also think 2wd and 4wd should race together as its only for fun and the most important thing is getting a good number of cars in the race. Having lots of rules and regulations will only put people off and create more cost and if anything, will make racing more serious and competitive as people do anything they can to squeeze performance out of outdated electrics etc.
__________________
Durango, Novarossi, Losi, Sanwa, Savox, AKA, Optifuel, Tamiya, Kyosho and lots of mods |
#40
|
||||
|
||||
In conclusion I suggest:
Any pre 2000 1:10th scale electric chassis, monster trucks, buggies, 2wd and 4wd etc (with room for flexibility on the day) Open batteries but no higher than 7.4v (2s lipo) Open esc Brushless motors from 10.5t or above or any brushed motor Open tyres Open radio gear While this make not make the racing as "fair" as possible, I think rules along these lines would be the most fun, cheapest for the racer, and lead to a higher number of people racing in the class, which is the most important thing. Thanks, Jon.
__________________
Durango, Novarossi, Losi, Sanwa, Savox, AKA, Optifuel, Tamiya, Kyosho and lots of mods |
|
|